If you thought the pinstriped suits from the first movie were peak Emily Nelson, you’ve got another thing coming. Honestly, I didn't think the team could top the 2018 wardrobe that basically turned menswear into a lethal weapon, but then Another Simple Favor dropped on Prime Video in May 2025. It turns out that when you take a high-fashion sociopath out of Connecticut and drop her onto the sun-drenched cliffs of Capri, things get weird. And by weird, I mean incredibly expensive and slightly dangerous.
Costume designer Renée Ehrlich Kalfus is back, and she clearly didn't come to play. She and Blake Lively have this shorthand now where the clothes aren't just "looks"—they’re literal plot points.
The Shackled Suit: A Literal Prison Break
Let’s talk about that first entrance. Most people would leave prison and maybe grab a pair of sweatpants. Not Emily. She walks back into Stephanie’s life wearing what the crew calls the "shackled suit." It’s a custom-made, grey-and-white striped boucle suit that is such a high-fashion middle finger to the judicial system.
The genius here? The stripes are horizontal.
It’s a direct nod to old-school, black-and-white prison uniforms, but executed with such precision that it looks like something off a Paris runway. Lively actually suggested the prison-garb vibe herself. To lean into the bit, they accessorized it with large silver hoop earrings that, if you look closely, are shaped exactly like handcuffs. It’s "Another Simple Favor" Blake Lively outfits at their most tongue-in-cheek. She’s telling you she was in jail without saying a single word.
She tops it off with sparkly Christian Louboutin boots. Kalfus called them the "Queen's jewels for your feet." It’s the ultimate "I’m back" statement.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
That 40-Pound Floral Top and the Capri Sunhat
When the action shifts to Italy for Emily’s wedding to a mysterious (and very rich) businessman, the budget clearly exploded. There is one specific look that almost broke Blake Lively—literally.
It’s a sculpted floral halter top by Tamara Ralph. It looks like a garden growing out of her chest, made of delicate but incredibly heavy 3D flowers. It weighed 40 pounds. 40! Lively had to film in it for two straight days. The costume team actually had to build a hidden corset underneath the top just to protect her torso and keep the weight from crushing her.
Fashion is pain, but that’s some next-level dedication to a silhouette.
Then there’s the hat. You know the one. The giant, floppy raffia hat from Fiore Capri that basically has its own zip code. In a movie full of "Another Simple Favor" Blake Lively outfits that feel meticulously planned, this was a total accident. Lively apparently found it in the corner of a tiny local shop in Capri while they were filming. She insisted on it. Paul Feig, the director, loved the absurdity of it. It’s so big it barely fits in the frame, which is exactly why it works for a character who wants to be seen and hidden at the same time.
The Wedding Dress That Required a Ferry to Naples
The climax of the film—Emily’s wedding—features a dress that is as beautiful as it is unsettling. It’s a custom piece with a 40-foot bejeweled veil that took about 100 hours to hand-stitch. But the "twist" is the color.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
Kalfus wanted a "blood-soaked" effect on the fabric, a subtle hint that the wedding wasn't going to end in a "happily ever after." Apparently, they ran out of the specific red dye they needed while on the island. The crew had to rush to catch the last ferry to Naples at 6:00 PM just to get more dye so they could finish the dress in time for the shoot.
Why the "Jackie Kennedy" Look Matters
Later in the film, we see a mourning look that is a dead ringer for Jackie Kennedy’s funeral attire. This isn't just a random reference. The all-black veiled ensemble, complete with lace layers and gloves, was a specific choice to show Emily’s transition into a "grieving widow" (whether she actually is one or not is a different story). It’s an exercise in performance.
High Fashion vs. Reality: Where to Find the Pieces
While many of the "Another Simple Favor" Blake Lively outfits are custom-made in the film’s workshop, several "real world" designers make appearances:
- Tamara Ralph: Responsible for the pearl-embellished white suit and that infamous 40-pound floral top.
- Fendi: Those pearl-embellished round sunglasses that are currently sold out everywhere.
- New & Lingwood: The red skull and crossbones towelling robe Emily wears while lounging.
- Prada: The orange embroidered organza pajamas. (Yes, her sleepwear costs more than most people's cars).
- Maria Tash: For the gold, diamond, and ruby spike hoop earrings.
The Evolution of the Power Suit
In the first film, Emily used menswear to dominate. In the sequel, the suits have evolved. They are softer, more "Italian socialite," but they still function as armor. Take the white pearl-embellished Tamara Ralph suit she wears on the plane. It’s satin, it’s shimmering, but the tailoring is razor-sharp.
She isn't just a suburban mom anymore; she’s a global predator.
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
One of my favorite "blink and you'll miss it" details is a Sea New York white lace tiered maxi dress she wears while playing the character of "Charity." It’s the most "feminine" we ever see her, and that’s exactly why you shouldn't trust her. The clothes in this movie are a warning system. If she looks soft, she’s probably about to stab you.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Own Wardrobe
You probably aren't planning a fake wedding in Capri or dodging a murder charge, but you can still steal the vibe.
- Jewelry as a Secret Language: Look for accessories that tell a story. Maybe not handcuffs, but pieces that feel "meaningful" to your personal narrative.
- The "Shackled" Silhouette: If you want to pull off the prison-chic look, look for boucle fabrics with contrasting horizontal lines. Keep the fit structured—sagging fabric ruins the "power" part of the power suit.
- Invest in One Absurd Accessory: Whether it's a $5,000 martini-shaped clutch (like the Judith Leiber one Blake wore on the press tour) or an oversized hat, one "too much" item makes an outfit memorable.
- Texture Over Color: Notice how many of Emily’s best looks are monochrome (all white, all grey, all black) but use heavy textures like pearls, 3D florals, or lace to create depth.
If you're looking to recreate these looks on a budget, start with structured blazers and high-waisted trousers. The "Another Simple Favor" Blake Lively outfits rely on the "V" shape created by sharp shoulders and a snatched waist. You don't need a 40-foot veil to command a room, but a pair of pearl-embellished sunglasses definitely doesn't hurt.
The movie is currently streaming on Prime Video, so you can go back and pause on every frame to see the stitch-work for yourself. Just don't blame me when you suddenly feel the urge to buy a 40-pound floral top.