You've seen the tweets. Every year, right around February or March, the internet sets itself on fire because a "mid" show beat out a "masterpiece" for a plastic trophy. It’s a bloodbath. If you’ve ever scrolled through a comments section after a major ceremony, you know exactly what I’m talking about. The rage is real.
But honestly? Most of us are looking at anime of the year awards all wrong. We treat them like objective truth, when they’re actually a weird, messy mix of marketing, popularity contests, and industry politics.
Take the 2025 Crunchyroll Anime Awards that just wrapped up in Tokyo this past May. Everyone thought Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End was a lock. It had the critical acclaim, the "prestige" feel, and it basically lived at the top of MyAnimeList for months. Then Solo Leveling walked away with the big Anime of the Year win. The salt was legendary. But if you look at how these things are built, the result actually makes a lot of sense.
The Battle Between Hype and Quality
There is a massive gap between what "critics" love and what the average person actually watches on their lunch break. This is where the friction starts. Most major ceremonies, especially the ones with global reach, use a weighted system.
Usually, it's something like a 70/30 split.
🔗 Read more: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
- 70% of the power goes to a panel of judges (journalists, influencers, industry pros).
- 30% comes from the public fan vote.
You’d think the judges would keep things "high-brow," right? Not always. Even judges get swept up in the zeitgeist. Solo Leveling was a global phenomenon. It brought in a massive new audience from the manhwa world. When a show has that much momentum, it becomes very hard for a slower, more meditative series like Frieren to hold the line, even if the latter is technically "better" by traditional storytelling standards.
The "Big Three" Ceremonies You Actually Need to Care About
If you're trying to keep track of who's winning what, don't get distracted by every random blog poll. There are three heavy hitters that actually move the needle in the industry.
- The Crunchyroll Anime Awards: This is the "Oscars" of the anime world now. It’s flashy, it’s held in Japan, and it gets millions of votes. In 2025, they even added a Global Impact Award to recognize shows that break out of the "anime bubble."
- Tokyo Anime Award Festival (TAAF): This one is for the purists. The winners are chosen by industry people in Japan. This year, they actually gave Best TV Series to Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End, while the Best Film went to Look Back. It’s often a much better reflection of what the actual creators in Japan think is good.
- The Game Awards (Best Adaptation): Okay, it’s not strictly an anime show, but this category has become a huge deal. Watching The Last of Us beat out Devil May Cry or Arcane Season 2 this past December sparked a whole new debate about whether "faithful" adaptations should win over "prestige" TV.
Why "Popularity Contest" Isn't Always a Bad Word
We love to complain that these awards are just popularity contests. "Of course Demon Slayer won Best Animation again," we sigh, while Dandadan sits in the corner with its experimental style.
But here’s the thing: Popularity is a metric of impact. If a show manages to get 18 million people to care enough to vote, it did something right. Solo Leveling won because it felt like an event. Dandadan (which took home Best Character Design at the 2025 CR Awards) might be the "cool" choice, but awards shows are built on consensus.
💡 You might also like: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
The Recency Bias Problem
One thing nobody talks about is the timing. Most awards look at the "previous year," but the voting usually happens in January or February. If a show came out in January of the previous year, everyone has forgotten about it by the time the ballots open.
If your favorite show aired in the Fall season? It’s fresh. It’s in the memes. It wins.
This is exactly why Solo Leveling—which had its big moments earlier in the cycle—had to fight so hard against the "Fall hype" of shows like Blue Box or Ranma 1/2.
Navigating the Sub-Categories (Where the Real Quality Is)
If you want to find the shows that actually pushed the medium forward, stop looking at the "Anime of the Year" category. Look at the technical wins.
📖 Related: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
At the most recent ceremonies, we saw some incredible nuance:
- Best Score: Hiroyuki Sawano taking it for Solo Leveling was a rare case of the popular choice actually being the undisputed technical best.
- Best Slice of Life: Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines! grabbed this one, which was a huge win for a show that could have easily been dismissed as "just another rom-com."
- Best Original Anime: Ninja Kamui managed to snag this, proving there's still a huge appetite for stories that aren't based on a pre-existing manga.
How to Actually Use These Awards
Don't use them to validate your taste. Your taste is fine. Use them as a discovery tool.
If a show you’ve never heard of, like The Birth of Kitaro: The Mystery of GeGeGe, wins the Anime Fan Award at TAAF (which it did in 2025 with over 21,000 votes), that’s a signal. It means there’s a dedicated fanbase in Japan seeing something you’re missing.
Next Steps for the Savvy Fan:
- Audit the Nominees: Go back to the 2025 "Anime of the Year" nominee list. If you haven't watched The Apothecary Diaries or Delicious in Dungeon, start there. They were nominated for a reason.
- Follow the Studios: Look at who won Best Animation. If Ufotable (Demon Slayer) or Science SARU (Dandadan) are winning, look at their upcoming projects. That’s where the budget is going.
- Check the Judges: Look at the judge list for the next Crunchyroll cycle. If it's all YouTubers, expect a popularity sweep. If there are more directors and historians, expect some "weird" picks.
The trophies might be plastic, but the data they provide is gold. Just don't let a "Best Isekai" win for Re:Zero ruin your week.