Raymond is a smug grey cat with heterochromia and a crisp office vest. He doesn't do much. He sweeps his floor, talks about his favorite indie bands, and occasionally gives you a sweater he found in his closet. Yet, when Animal Crossing: New Horizons launched, people were literally selling this digital cat for the equivalent of hundreds of real-world dollars or thousands of Nook Miles Tickets on the black market. It was a fever dream. It was madness.
The weird world of animal crossing villager popularity isn't just about who looks the cutest on a postcard. It’s a complex, community-driven economy fueled by social media aestheticism, nostalgia, and the cold, hard math of spawn rates.
The Tier List Obsession
If you spend five minutes on Nookazon or the Animal Crossing subreddit, you’ll see the term "Tier 1" thrown around like it's a high-stakes stock exchange. It basically is. Since the game doesn't have an official ranking system, the community built its own based on supply and demand.
👉 See also: Minecraft how to upload a skin: What most people get wrong about character customization
Characters like Shino, Sasha, and Ione—who were added in the 2.0 update—immediately shot to the top. Why? Because they’re fresh. But also because Shino is a deer with a "peppy" personality that fits the "soft-core" or "fairy-core" island aesthetic that dominated Instagram and TikTok. People want their islands to look like a curated art gallery, and Shino fits the frame.
Then you have the permanent residents of the top tier. Marshal. Stitches. Beau. These guys have been popular since New Leaf or even earlier. They’re the "Old Money" of the Animal Crossing world. Marshal, a tiny marshmallow squirrel with a constant side-eye, is the king of smugness. He’s been the most sought-after villager for nearly a decade. Honestly, his house—which looks like a coffee shop—is a big part of it. We aren't just inviting neighbors; we're inviting furniture sets that happen to talk.
Why Some Neighbors Get Ghosted
It’s kinda sad when you think about it. For every Raymond, there are ten Al’s or Barolds.
Barold is a lazy cub with a beard and a house that looks like a high-tech surveillance room. People find him "creepy." He’s a victim of the "ugly villager" tag. In the world of animal crossing villager popularity, looks are almost everything, even though every "lazy" villager has the exact same dialogue lines. If you have Sherb, he says the same thing about the bugs in his walls as Barold does. But because Sherb is a blue goat with big soft eyes, we find it charming. When Barold says it, we call the island police.
The "Jock" personality type also struggles. Unless you’re Roald (the round penguin) or Dom (the fluffy sheep), jocks tend to rank lower. Why? Because players find the constant talk about "abs" and "protein shakes" annoying when it's coming from a neon-green gorilla. It feels mismatched.
The Secret Influence of Interior Design
You've probably noticed that popular villagers usually have incredible houses.
Take Julian. He’s a unicorn. That’s an immediate win for his popularity. But his house? It’s filled with the Starry-Sky wall and Zodiac furniture. It’s a vibe. When you invite Julian to your island, you aren't just getting a smug horse; you're getting a celestial-themed showroom that makes your island look high-effort.
Conversely, some "starter" villagers are doomed from the beginning. If a villager is one of your first two residents, they live in a generic "starter house" with wooden block furniture. They never get their "real" house unless you have the Happy Home Paradise DLC to remodel it. This creates a weird hierarchy where a villager’s worth is tied to whether they were "found" on a mystery island or "gifted" by the game's intro.
💡 You might also like: Playing Elder Scrolls Online on Steam Deck: What Most People Get Wrong
The Data Behind the Hype
While we talk about "vibes," the data is actually quite trackable. Sites like Animal Crossing Portal have run massive polls with hundreds of thousands of votes to determine animal crossing villager popularity.
- The Cat Supremacy: Cats are statistically the most popular species. Bob, Lolly, and Ankha are almost always in the top 20.
- The Personality Gap: Smug and Lazy villagers dominate the top ranks. Cranky and Snooty villagers—who used to be actually mean in the GameCube version but have been "nerfed" into being mildly grumpy—tend to sit in the middle.
- The "Meme" Factor: Ankha became a viral sensation for... reasons we won't discuss here... which catapulted her popularity outside of the core gaming community.
Sometimes, popularity is just about the "cool" factor. Cephalobot is a robot octopus. There are only four octopuses in the entire game (Octavian, Marina, Zucker, and Cephalobot). Because the species is so rare, they are all essentially high-tier by default. If you have an octopus, your island feels "rare."
Is the Hype Real or Just FOMO?
There is a huge element of "Fear Of Missing Out" here. If you see everyone on Twitter posting screenshots of Sasha, you’re going to want Sasha. You start to think your island is "basic" if you have a bunch of mid-tier ducks or pigs.
But here is the reality: the gameplay doesn't change.
👉 See also: Finding That 5 Letter Word Starting With At For Your Daily Wordle
A "Tier 5" villager like Jambette will give you the same DIY recipes, the same reactions, and the same birthday cupcakes as a "Tier 1" like Coco. The popularity is a social construct. It’s a meta-game we play with each other to show off our "dreamies."
Expert players—the ones who have been playing since 2002—often lean the other way. There is a growing movement of "ugly villager" appreciation. These players intentionally seek out the "weird" ones like Pietro the clown sheep or Coco the hollow-eyed rabbit because they have more "character" than another pastel-colored deer.
How to Manage Your Island’s Social Circle
If you're trying to navigate the waters of animal crossing villager popularity, don't get sucked into the Nook Miles Ticket grind unless you actually love the character. Burning 400 tickets to find Raymond just because he's popular is the fastest way to burn out on the game.
Instead, look at your island's "vibe." If you're going for a spooky theme, Lucky (the mummy dog) or Cherry (the goth dog) are your S-tier picks, regardless of what a global poll says.
Actions to Take Right Now
- Check your "Dreamie" list: Go to a site like Nookipedia and look at every single villager in a species you like. You might find a "Low Tier" villager that fits your island better than a "High Tier" one.
- Don't pay real money: Seriously. Between the 2.0 update and the ability to invite villagers via Amiibo cards (which are much cheaper or can be made via NFC tags), there is no reason to spend real cash on a digital villager.
- Use the "Move Out" mechanic: If you want someone new, stop talking to your "popular" villagers. It won't make them leave faster (it's actually random), but it saves you the emotional attachment when that thought bubble finally appears over their head.
- Focus on the House: If you have the Happy Home Paradise DLC, remember that you can eventually change any villager's house. This means "ugly" interior villagers are no longer a dealbreaker. You can keep the villager you like and give them the palace they deserve.
The most important thing to remember is that your island is for you. Whether you have an island full of "Tier 1" celebrities or a bunch of "ugly" misfits that nobody else wants, the bugs they catch and the coffee they drink taste exactly the same.