You've been there. It’s 10:00 PM on a Tuesday, the mist is rolling over your island’s secret beach, and that sketchy green trawler is docked at the shore. You walk inside, the lighting is terrible, and Jolly Redd is grinning at you like he didn't just try to sell you a "monstrous" statue last week. You're staring at a canvas, squinting at your Switch screen, trying to figure out if the girl in the earring is actually supposed to be wearing a star or a circle. Honestly, Animal Crossing real paintings are the bane of every museum completionist's existence.
One wrong click and you’re out nearly 5,000 Bells. Worse, you’re stuck with a "Basic Painting" that Blathers won't even touch with a ten-foot pole.
It’s frustrating.
But here’s the thing: Nintendo didn’t just make these differences random. They’re based on actual art history, and once you know what to look for, Redd becomes a lot less intimidating. You basically become an amateur art appraiser overnight.
Why Animal Crossing Real Paintings Are Harder Than They Look
Most people think it’s just about a smudge here or a color change there. It isn't. The developers at Nintendo were incredibly clever with how they handled the transition of famous works like the Mona Lisa or The Night Watch into the low-resolution world of New Horizons.
Take the Academic Painting, for example. This is Vitruvian Man by Leonardo da Vinci. In the real world, it’s a masterclass in human proportions. In the game? The fake version has a giant coffee stain in the top right corner. It’s almost insulting. But other fakes are subtle. The Serene Painting (Lady with an Ermine) features a woman holding an ermine. In the fake, the animal is a round, grey raccoon-like creature. If you aren't looking closely at the color of the fur, you'll miss it.
The Haunting Factor
Did you know some of the fakes are haunted? This is a detail a lot of casual players miss. If you accidentally buy a fake Scary Painting (the one based on Otani Oniji III as Edobei), the eyebrows might change direction at night. In the fake Wistful Painting, the girl’s eyes will actually close once the sun goes down. It’s creepy. It’s weird. And honestly, it’s a reason some people actually collect the fakes on purpose.
📖 Related: Tony Todd Half-Life: Why the Legend of the Vortigaunt Still Matters
But if your goal is a 100% complete museum, those hauntings are just a reminder of your failure to spot the "scam."
The Paintings That Are Always Real
Before you get too deep into the weeds of analyzing every brushstroke, you should know that some items are "safe." There are several Animal Crossing real paintings that simply do not have a fake counterpart. If you see these on Redd's ship, buy them immediately. No questions asked.
- The Calm Painting (A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte by Georges Seurat) is always legitimate.
- Flowery Painting (Sunflowers by Vincent van Gogh) is another safe bet.
- Glowing Painting (The Fighting Temeraire by J.M.W. Turner) will never be a forgery.
- Moody Painting (The Sower by Jean-François Millet) is always the real deal.
- Mysterious Painting (Isle of the Dead by Arnold Böcklin) has no fake version.
- Nice Painting (The Young Flautist by Édouard Manet) is always genuine.
- Perfect Painting (Still Life with Apples and Oranges by Paul Cézanne) is always real.
- Proper Painting (A Bar at the Folies-Bergère by Édouard Manet) is safe.
- Sinking Painting (Ophelia by John Everett Millais) is never a fake.
- Twinkling Painting (The Starry Night by Vincent van Gogh) is always real.
- Warm Painting (The Clothed Maja by Francisco de Goya) is always legitimate.
- Worthy Painting (Liberty Leading the People by Eugène Delacroix) is another guaranteed win.
Why did Nintendo do this? Probably to throw us a bone. If every single item had a fake, the museum would take a decade to finish. These "always real" pieces are your best friends when you're trying to fill those empty spots in the art gallery.
Breaking Down the Most Common Forgeries
Let’s get into the nitty-gritty. You’re standing in the back of the boat. The "sneaky" music is playing. You’ve got your camera app open in "handheld" mode to zoom in. Here is what you're actually looking for in the most notorious fakes.
The Famous "Moving" Fake: The Scary Painting
Based on Toshusai Sharaku’s actor print, the real version has eyebrows that curve downward, making the subject look grumpy or intense. In the fake version, the eyebrows curve upward, making him look almost surprised or scared. If you see "sad" eyebrows, it’s a fake. You want the angry ones.
The Subtle Earring Swap: Wistful Painting
Johannes Vermeer’s Girl with a Pearl Earring is one of the most recognizable pieces of art in history. In the game, the fake version replaces the pearl earring with a star-shaped one. It's a tiny detail. If you aren't zoomed in, it looks like a reflection. But if it’s a star, walk away.
👉 See also: Your Network Setting are Blocking Party Chat: How to Actually Fix It
The Milk Pouring Mistake: Quaint Painting
Vermeer again. This time it’s The Milkmaid. In the real version, a thin stream of milk is trickling out of the jug. In the fake version, there is a thick, heavy pour of milk coming out. It’s a very "blink and you'll miss it" kind of difference, but once you see it, the fake looks ridiculous.
The Blue Boy’s Hair: Basic Painting
Thomas Gainsborough’s The Blue Boy is a classic. In the real painting, the boy has bangs that cover most of his forehead. In the fake? He has a very distinct, very 90s-looking bowl cut with a massive forehead showing. It makes him look like a completely different person.
The Art of the Deal: Dealing with Redd’s RNG
Redd is a cousin you can’t trust. He shows up at your island maybe once every two weeks if you're lucky, though the 2.0 update changed things by allowing him to set up a permanent stall on Harv’s Island. This was a game-changer.
On Harv's Island, Redd sells two pieces of art. They refresh every Monday. If you buy a piece, he replaces it the next day. This is the secret "pro" strategy for hunting Animal Crossing real paintings. Even if both items on his stall are fakes, buy one anyway. It forces a new item to spawn the next morning. It’s a bit of a Bell sink, but it speeds up the museum process by about 400%.
Don't just wait for him to come to your secret beach. You'll be playing until 2030 if you do that.
The Emotional Toll of the Blathers Rejection
There is no feeling quite like walking into the museum, puffing your chest out, and handing a painting to Blathers, only for him to look at you with that pitying owl stare. "Hoo... I'm afraid this is a forgery!"
✨ Don't miss: Wordle August 19th: Why This Puzzle Still Trips People Up
It stings.
But don't throw the fakes in the trash! While you can't sell them to Tommy and Timmy at Nook’s Cranny (they won't take "illegal" goods), you can use them for decoration. Some players actually prefer the fake Ancient Statue because its eyes glow blue and it floats when you interact with it. The fake Moving Painting (The Birth of Venus) is often used in outdoor "art studio" builds because it looks close enough to the real thing for a background prop.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Art Hunt
If you want to stop getting scammed, you need a system. Don't rely on your memory. Even experts get tripped up by the Wild Painting Left Half vs. Wild Painting Right Half (where the colors of the gods are swapped in the fakes).
- Use the Camera App: Seriously. Open your NookPhone, go to the camera, and use the zoom feature. You cannot see the earring on the Wistful Painting or the eyebrows on the Scary Painting from the default overhead view.
- Check the Back: In New Horizons, you can actually look at the back of the painting. Real paintings often have a certificate of authenticity or a specific label on the back of the frame. It’s not a 100% foolproof method for every piece, but it’s a great secondary check.
- Harv’s Island Strategy: If you haven't unlocked Redd on Harv's Island, do it today. It costs 100,000 Bells to fund his plot. It is the single best investment you can make for your museum gallery.
- The "Fake" Disposal: If you end up with a fake you don't want, you can't sell it. To get rid of it, you either need to use a trash can furniture item to "discard" it, or take it on a Mystery Island tour and leave it on the ground there.
Completing the art wing of the museum is arguably the hardest task in the game. It’s a mix of patience, luck, and a little bit of art history knowledge. Just remember: if the painting looks "off" or if the subject is smiling too much, it’s probably one of Redd’s "special" deals that you should pass on. Keep your Bells, wait for the next Monday refresh on Harv's, and eventually, that final wing of your museum will be glowing with legitimate masterpieces.
Stay diligent. That fox is clever, but you're faster.
Next Steps for Success:
Go to Harv's Island right now and check Redd's current inventory. If he has two fakes, buy the cheapest one (likely a painting for 4,980 Bells). This guarantees a fresh item tomorrow morning. Repeat this daily until you see a piece that matches the "always real" list or passes your visual inspection. Once you've secured a real piece, don't forget to donate it to Blathers immediately before you accidentally use it as wall decor and forget about it for six months.