You hear that low, mechanical hum before you even see the ship. It’s tucked away at the very back of your island, anchored at that tiny "secret" beach most players forget exists for weeks. Jolly Redd has arrived. He’s a fox. He’s charming. He’s also trying to scam you out of 4,980 Bells for a piece of canvas that belongs in a dumpster. Honestly, the first time I saw his "Treasure Trawler," I thought I was getting a deal on a real Gallant Statue. I wasn't. I ended up with a statue holding a book, which—spoiler alert—is not how Michelangelo designed it.
Navigating Animal Crossing New Horizons Redd art is basically a crash course in art history with very high stakes. If you buy a fake, Blathers will give you that look. You know the one. That judgmental, wide-eyed stare from the museum curator that says, "I can’t believe you thought this was real." And since you can only buy one piece per visit, a mistake means waiting another week or more for the fox to return.
Why Redd is the Most Stressful Part of Island Life
Nintendo really leaned into the "shady dealer" vibe with Redd. The Trawler is dimly lit. You can’t zoom in as much as you’d like. It’s intentional. They want you to make a mistake. Unlike other NPCs like Leif or Celeste, Redd is actively working against your progress.
Success requires a sharp eye. You have to compare the in-game item to the real-world masterpiece it’s mimicking. But even then, some fakes are "haunted." They blink. They smile. They move at night. It’s creepy as hell, but some players actually prefer the fakes for their home decor because of these paranormal quirks. If you're looking to complete the Museum's Art Gallery, though, you need the genuine article. There are 43 pieces in total—paintings and statues—and many of them have very convincing counterfeits.
The Anatomy of a Redd Scam
The fakes aren't just random. They are specific, consistent deviations from the original work. Take the Amazing Painting (The Night Watch by Rembrandt). In the real version, the guy in the middle is wearing a red sash. In the fake? No sash. It’s a tiny detail that’s easy to miss when you’re squinting at a Switch Lite screen in handheld mode.
Then you have the Academic Painting, which is Vitruvian Man. The fake has a coffee stain in the top right corner. Why? Because Redd is a monster.
Some items are always real. If you see the Calm Painting (A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte), buy it immediately. There is no fake version of that one. The same goes for the Flowery Painting and the Great Statue. Knowing which pieces are "safe" saves you a lot of mental energy.
🔗 Read more: Gothic Romance Outfit Dress to Impress: Why Everyone is Obsessed With This Vibe Right Now
The Most Common Fakes and How to Identify Them
Let's get into the weeds. If you want to master Animal Crossing New Horizons Redd art, you have to memorize the "tells."
The Scary Painting is a classic. It’s based on Otani Oniji III as Yakko Edobei. In the real version, the eyebrows are arched in a way that looks concerned or surprised. In the fake, they are slanted downwards, making him look angry or "scary." It’s a subtle shift in the ink lines, but it changes the whole vibe.
Moving to statues, the Beautiful Statue (Venus de Milo) is a frequent trap. Look at her neck. Does she have a necklace? If she does, it’s a fake. The real Venus doesn't wear jewelry. Redd is just trying to "accessorize" her to trick you.
- Informative Painting: The fake has an extra leaf in the corner.
- Motherly Statue: The fake has the wolf's tongue hanging out.
- Mystic Statue: If she’s wearing an earring, it’s a fake.
- Wild Painting Left/Right Half: These are the hardest. You have to look at the color of the creatures. If the colors are swapped or the "God" is the wrong shade, you're looking at a forgery.
Most players don't realize that some fakes are actually worth more to the community than the real ones. The Ancient Statue fake hovers. If you interact with it, it glows and floats. People pay big Nook Miles Ticket prices on Nookazon for that specific fake just to build "alien landing site" themes on their islands.
Don't Forget the Redd's Raffle Factor
Redd isn't just about the art. During the August fireworks shows, he sets up a stand in the Plaza. This isn't where you get your paintings. This is where you get the "useless but fun" stuff. Bubbles, sparklers, uchiwa fans, and those little canned drinks.
It’s a different side of the character. He’s still taking your money, but at least he’s giving you a physical prize every time. It’s a 500 Bell buy-in. If you’re trying to build a summer festival area, this is your primary source for decor. Just don't expect him to sell you a genuine Mona Lisa while the fireworks are going off.
💡 You might also like: The Problem With Roblox Bypassed Audios 2025: Why They Still Won't Go Away
Is the Art Market Different in 2026?
A few years into the game's life cycle, the "economy" of art has shifted. In the early days, people were desperate. You’d see players trading 50 Gold Nuggets for a single Valiant Statue. Now, with the 2.0 update and the ability to open Redd’s permanent stall on Harv's Island, the scarcity is gone.
If you haven't been to Harv's Island lately, go. You can pay 100,000 Bells to fund Redd’s shop. This gives you two pieces of art to look at every single day. If you buy one, he replaces it the next day. If you don't buy anything, the stock stays the same until Monday. Pro tip: Buy a fake on Monday just to force him to cycle in a new piece on Tuesday. It’s the fastest way to finish the museum.
The Ethical Dilemma of Time Travel
I’m not here to tell you how to play your game. But if you're hunting for that final Rock-Head Statue, the "natural" way might take you years. Time traveling—changing your system clock—is the standard method for art hunters.
You find a day Redd is visiting. Check the art. If it’s all fake, buy one anyway (to clear the slot), save, and move the clock forward one day. Then move it back. Redd will be back with entirely new stock. Is it cheating? Maybe. Does Blathers care? No. He just wants the owls in the museum to have something to look at.
The struggle is real when you realize you've been time traveling for three hours and all you've found are four Wistful Painting fakes where the girl is wearing a star-shaped earring instead of a pearl. It gets tedious. But that feeling when you finally see the Tremain Painting without the hunter in the snow? Pure dopamine.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Visit
Don't just walk into the Trawler and wing it. You'll lose Bells and, more importantly, your pride.
📖 Related: All Might Crystals Echoes of Wisdom: Why This Quest Item Is Driving Zelda Fans Wild
First, always use the Camera app on your NookPhone. When you’re looking at a piece of art, open the camera and zoom in as far as you can. The lighting in the boat is terrible, and the "Inspect" view doesn't always show the fine details like the coffee stain on the Vitruvian Man or the shape of the eyebrows on the Scary Painting.
Second, check your Museum's "Critterpedia" equivalent for art. Before you buy, verify what you already have. There is nothing more soul-crushing than buying a genuine Sinking Painting only to realize you donated it two years ago and it’s already hanging in the wing.
Third, utilize the Harv's Island cycle. If you have the Bells, buy a fake every single day. It sounds counter-intuitive, but by removing a fake from the rotation, you’re forcing the game to generate a new item for the next day. This significantly increases your odds of seeing a "Real" version of the rare statues like the Robust or Gallant.
Fourth, look for the "Haunted" fakes. If you’re into the spooky aesthetic, keep an eye out for the Wistful Painting (fake version closes its eyes at night) or the Ancient Statue (floats). These are actually more valuable for trading with other players than some of the "real" common paintings.
Fifth, cross-reference with a high-res guide. Don't guess. The differences are sometimes down to a single pixel or a slight color shift.
If you follow these steps, your museum will be full in no time, and you'll stop being Redd's favorite mark. He’ll still call you "Cousin," and he’ll still try to overcharge you, but at least you’ll be the one in control.