Redd is back. That shifty fox is parked at your secret beach again, grinning behind a dimly lit lantern and promising you the deal of a lifetime. Honestly, we've all been there—dropping 4,980 Bells on a "masterpiece" only to have Blathers look at us with pure, unadulterated pity. It hurts.
Learning the difference between animal crossing art real vs fake isn't just about finishing your museum; it’s about not letting a fox in a sweater vest play you for a fool.
The stakes are actually kinda high. You can’t sell fakes to the Nooklings. You can’t donate them. You’re basically stuck with a piece of "trash" unless you want to decorate your basement with haunted forgeries. But hey, some people actually prefer the fakes. Did you know some of the forgeries are literally possessed? We'll get into that.
How to Spot the Fakes Before You Buy
Redd usually has four items. Sometimes they’re all fake. Sometimes one is real. On rare occasions, you might find more than one genuine piece, but don't count on it.
✨ Don't miss: Red Dead Redemption 3: What Everyone Gets Wrong About the Release Date
The game gives you a "Zoom" feature for a reason. Use it. You need to look for tiny, almost microscopic deviations from the real-world inspiration. If you aren't an art history major, don't worry. Most of these "forgeries" are comically bad once you know where to look.
The Paintings: Eyebrows, Milk, and Coffee Stains
Let’s talk about the Academic Painting. This is Da Vinci’s Vitruvian Man. It looks legit at first glance, right? Look at the top right corner. If there is a circular brown stain—basically a coffee ring—it’s a fake. Also, if you buy the fake and turn it around in your house, there’s a key taped to the back. Weird, right?
The Famous Painting (the Mona Lisa) is another classic trap. In the real version, her eyebrows are very faint, almost non-existent. The fake version? She’s got these high, arched, "I’m judging your island layout" eyebrows that make her look sinister.
Then there’s the Wistful Painting. This is the Girl with a Pearl Earring.
- Real: Round pearl earring.
- Fake: The earring is a star.
Wait, it gets creepier. There’s a "haunted" version of the fake Wistful Painting where she closes her eyes at night. If you’re into the spooky vibe, that’s actually a win.
Statues: Watches and Alien Technology
Statues are harder because they’re 3D and Redd’s boat is dark.
Take the Robust Statue. It’s the guy throwing a disc. Look at his right wrist. If he’s wearing a freaking smartwatch, it’s a fake. Ancient Greeks didn't have Fitbits.
The Informative Statue is the Rosetta Stone. The real one is grey rock. The fake one is a glowing neon blue. It’s super obvious once you see it, but in the dim light of the Trawler, it can trick you if you're rushing. The fake also glows at night.
Then you have the Ancient Statue. The real one is a Jomon-period dogu. The fake one has antennae. Like an alien. And yes, if you interact with the fake one, it floats.
The "Always Real" List
Sometimes Redd is actually honest. Kinda. There are several pieces of art that never have a fake version in New Horizons. If you see these, buy them immediately.
📖 Related: Why Ellie The Last of Us 2 Full Body Design Still Bothers Fans
- Calm Painting (A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte)
- Common Painting (The Gleaners)
- Dynamic Painting (The Great Wave off Kanagawa)
- Flowery Painting (Sunflowers)
- Glowing Painting (The Fighting Temeraire)
- Moody Painting (The Sower)
- Mysterious Painting (Isle of the Dead)
- Nice Painting (The Fifer)
- Perfect Painting (Apples and Oranges)
- Proper Painting (A Bar at the Folies-Bergère)
- Sinking Painting (Ophelia)
- Twinkling Painting (The Starry Night)
- Warm Painting (The Clothed Maja)
- Worthy Painting (Liberty Leading the People)
- Familiar Statue (The Thinker)
- Great Statue (King Kamehameha I)
Dealing With the "Haunted" Forgeries
If you've already messed up and bought a fake, don't just throw it in the trash bin. Some forgeries are actually "haunted" and have unique animations that happen at specific times—usually at night or when you interact with them.
The Graceful Painting (the woman looking back) is a famous one. In the fake, the woman is much larger, taking up most of the canvas. At night, she actually turns her head to look at you. It's genuinely unsettling.
The Scary Painting is another one. The fake has eyebrows that make the man look sad instead of angry. But at night? He starts smiling.
Why Harv's Island Changes Everything
If you're tired of waiting for Redd to show up once every two weeks, you need to unlock his shop at Harv's Island. It costs 100,000 Bells to set up his stall, but it's the best investment you'll make.
He stocks two pieces of art every week. If you buy a fake one on Monday, he’ll replace it with a new piece on Tuesday. This is the fastest way to cycle through his inventory and finish that museum. Just remember: if you buy a fake at Harv's, you're out 5,000 Bells, but you're one step closer to seeing a real piece the next day.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Visit
Next time you hear that foghorn at the back of your island, follow this checklist so you don't get burned:
👉 See also: God of War PlayStation 2 Walkthrough: How to Survive the Original Spartan Rage
- Open a real-world photo of the artwork on your phone or laptop while you're standing in Redd's shop.
- Zoom in on the specific "tells"—eyebrows, hats, earrings, and hand positions are the most common changes.
- Check the back of paintings if you're at a Treasure Island or a friend's place; real ones have a small label, fakes usually don't (unless it's the Academic one with the key).
- Buy the "Always Real" items even if you already have them; they make great trading fodder for other players.
- Keep the haunted ones for a "cursed" room in your house; they are way more interesting than the real versions for interior design.
Don't let the lighting in the Trawler fool you. Redd counts on you being impulsive. Take your time, look at the "milk" in the Quaint Painting (it should be a thin trickle, not a waterfall), and you'll have a completed museum wing before the next seasonal update.