Honestly, if you've ever spent five hours straight burning through Nook Miles Tickets just to find a blue cat with glasses, you know the struggle is real. We’ve all been there. You're looking for Raymond, or maybe Shino, and instead, the game gives you a green hippo in a diaper for the third time in a row. It’s frustrating. But when we talk about Animal Crossing all villagers, we aren't just talking about a list of names. We are talking about a massive, complex system of personality subtypes, hobby data, and RNG (random number generation) that determines who lives on your island and—more importantly—who stays there.
There are over 400 villagers in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. 413, to be exact, if you count the ones added in the 2.0 update. That is a staggering amount of code just to decide if a squirrel wants to talk to you about fitness or if a cranky wolf is going to complain about his knees.
The Math Behind Animal Crossing All Villagers
Most players think every villager has an equal 1 in 413 chance of appearing on a Mystery Island. That’s wrong. It’s actually much more annoying than that. The game doesn't just roll a giant 413-sided die. First, it picks a species. There are 35 species in the game. Then, it picks a villager from within that species.
This means your odds of finding a specific cat are way lower than your odds of finding a specific octopus. Why? Because there are only four octopuses (Zucker, Marina, Octavian, and Cephalobot) but dozens of cats. If the game decides "Okay, I'm giving this player a cat," it then has to choose between nearly 30 different feline options. If it rolls "octopus," you've got a 25% chance of getting the one you want. This quirk of the programming makes popular cats like Raymond or Ankha statistically some of the hardest characters to encounter naturally.
Personalities Are Not Just "Types" Anymore
You probably know the eight basic personality types: Lazy, Jock, Cranky, Smug, Normal, Peppy, Snooty, and Sisterly (or Uchi). But did you know there are actually "A" and "B" subtypes for every single one? This explains why two Lazy villagers can feel totally different.
Take the "Lazy" type. A Subtype A Lazy villager might focus more on their internal dialogue about bugs, while a Subtype B might lean harder into talking about food and napping. According to data mined by researchers like Acnl_Gossip and documented on community hubs like Nookipedia, these subtypes affect the specific lines of dialogue a villager prioritizes. It’s the difference between a neighbor who feels like a real friend and one who feels like a broken record.
Why Some Villagers Become Viral Sensations
It’s kind of wild how the community decides who is "S-Tier." In the early days of New Horizons, Raymond was the king. People were literally selling him on eBay for real-world money, which is technically against Nintendo’s Terms of Service, but it happened anyway.
The obsession with Animal Crossing all villagers usually boils down to aesthetics. Raymond was the first Smug cat. He had heterochromia (different colored eyes). He wore a suit. He was "new." In previous games, you could use Amiibo cards to force a villager to move in. But since Raymond was brand new in New Horizons, he didn't have a card for a long time. You had to find him the hard way. That scarcity created a digital black market.
Then came the 2.0 update. We got Sasha, the first male villager with the "fashion" hobby and a "cute" aesthetic usually reserved for Peppy girls. We got Shino, the deer with the demon-inspired look. The meta shifted. Suddenly, the old favorites were "mid," and everyone wanted the new blood.
💡 You might also like: The Messy Truth About When Was Monopoly Created (It Wasn’t 1935)
The Friendship Point System is Brilliantly Evil
You want their photo. That’s the goal. Getting a villager’s framed photo is the ultimate sign of "completion" for that specific character. But the math is brutal.
Every villager starts with a base friendship score of 25 points. To get a photo, you need to hit at least 200 points.
- Talking to them: +1 point (once per day).
- Giving a "good" gift: Up to +3 points.
- Wrapped gift bonus: +1 point.
- Ignoring them: 0 points (contrary to popular belief, ignoring them doesn't lower points, but it doesn't help).
- Hitting them with a net: -3 points.
If you really want to maximize your relationship with Animal Crossing all villagers, stop giving them random fruit. Give them two non-native fruits wrapped in gift paper. Or give them assessed fossils. Fossils are great because they have a high "sell value" (which triggers the chance for the villager to give you a gift in return, like a photo) but they won't clutter up the villager's house because they are too big for them to display.
The Moving Out Myth
"If I hit them with a net, will they leave?"
No.
Seriously, stop hitting Pietro. It doesn't work.
The "move-out" mechanic is almost entirely random, though it is slightly weighted toward villagers you have a higher friendship with, ironically. The game's logic is that if you've befriended them, you've "finished" their story. Every 15 days or so, the game checks to see if someone should move. If you tell a villager to stay, the cooldown resets for five days. If you tell them to go, the plot opens up the next day.
If you're hunting for a specific character among Animal Crossing all villagers, the most efficient way is the "Campsite Method." It involves time traveling (if you're okay with that) to dates where the game is forced to spawn a guest in your campsite. The game prioritizes personality types you don't currently have on your island. If you have no Smug villagers, the campsite is much more likely to spawn a Smug villager. This is how people "farm" for Raymond or Marshal without spending 400 tickets.
The Forgotten History of Lost Villagers
Not everyone made the cut. When we look at the roster of Animal Crossing all villagers across the entire franchise, there are dozens who were left behind in the GameCube or DS eras.
Remember the Zelda crossovers? Epona, Medli, and Ganon? Or the Splatoon villagers like Cece and Viche? They appeared in New Leaf via Amiibo but are nowhere to be found in New Horizons. Fans are still holding out hope for a "surprise" update, but let's be real—Nintendo has moved on. There are also weird ones, like Huggy the bear or Fruity the duck, who haven't been seen since the early 2000s. They are the "ghosts" of the franchise, code that exists only in old cartridges and the memories of players who are now in their 30s.
Species Diversity and the "Ugly" Villager Paradox
There is a weird subculture of players who intentionally collect "ugly" villagers. We call them "dreamies" usually, but some people want an island full of the weirdest-looking animals possible. Villagers like Barold (the bear who looks like he has a five o'clock shadow and a basement full of monitors) or Jambette (the frog with the massive lips) have become cult icons.
It highlights a core part of the game: personality variety. If everyone had an island full of Sherb, Ione, and Rosie, the game would be boring. The "cranky" dialogue from a character like Gaston (the rabbit with the mustache) provides a necessary edge to a game that is otherwise aggressively sweet.
🔗 Read more: Warbanner of the Sun: How This World of Warcraft Trinket Actually Works
How to Curate Your Perfect Roster
If you are serious about managing your island's lineup, you need a strategy. Don't just take the first villager you see.
- Balance your personalities. You need at least one of each of the eight types to unlock all the DIY recipes and Reactions. If you don't have a Sisterly villager, you will literally never learn how to make certain items.
- Check their hobbies. There are six hobbies: Education, Fashion, Fitness, Music, Nature, and Play. Even if two villagers are "Lazy," a Nature-hobby lazy villager will spend more time sitting under trees with a book, while a Play-hobby lazy villager will run around the plaza with their arms out like an airplane.
- Use the "Move-Out" bubble wisely. If you see a bubble over a villager you want to keep, don't talk to them! If you ignore them, the bubble has a chance to "transfer" to a different villager the next day.
Final Insights for the Dedicated Resident Representative
Managing Animal Crossing all villagers is less about "collecting them all" and more about finding the right chemistry. The 400+ characters are tools for self-expression. Your island's roster says more about you than your furniture does.
To take your island to the next level, stop looking at "tier lists." Tier lists are based on popularity, not your personal gameplay experience. A "C-tier" villager like Cube might end up being your favorite because of a weird interaction you had during a fishing tourney.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Audit your personality types: Go to your map and list your villagers. If you're missing a "Sisterly" or "Smug," prioritize finding one to unlock missing DIYs.
- Start the "Fossil Method": Wrap large, assessed fossils and give them to your favorites daily. It’s the fastest way to get photos without ruining their interior design.
- Check the Campsite: If you have a guest, even if you don't want them, talk to them. It "clears" them from the RNG pool for a while, improving your chances of seeing someone better next time.
- Visit Treasure Islands: If you're truly desperate and tired of the grind, search Twitch or Discord for "Treasure Islands." These are hacked islands where you can often find specific villagers in boxes for free, bypassing the RNG entirely.
The "perfect" island doesn't exist. There is only the island you're on right now. Whether you have the rarest cats or a bunch of "ugly" hippos, the game is about the slow burn of friendship, one bug-catching contest at a time.