Reality TV is a trip. One minute you're the "Minnesota Nice" guy everyone wants to win, and the next, you're getting roasted on Twitter for breaking the sacred bro-code. That's basically the trajectory of Andy Voyen. If you watched Love Island USA Season 4, you remember him. He was the 23-year-old realtor from Minneapolis who walked into the villa with a bright smile and left just eleven days later under a cloud of controversy.
But here’s the thing: most people only remember the "momma's boy" comments or that one chaotic recoupling. They miss the bigger picture of what actually happened after the cameras stopped rolling. Honestly, the story of Andy and Mady McLanahan post-villa is way more interesting than the edited drama we saw on Peacock.
The Recoupling That Ruined Everything
Let's talk about that moment. You know the one. Andy was coupled up with Mady. They seemed solid, if a little quiet. Then, out of nowhere, Andy chooses Sydney Paight during a recoupling.
The villa went silent. Zeta's face became an instant meme.
The problem wasn't just that he picked someone else; it was how he did it. Sydney was with Isaiah Campbell. Isaiah and Andy were supposed to be friends. In the world of Love Island, stealing your "best mate's" girl without a heads-up is the ultimate sin. He went from being the sweet midwesterner to the season's accidental villain in about thirty seconds.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why did he do it? Andy later said things felt "forced" with Mady at the time. He thought things with Sydney would be "easy and fun." It wasn't. It lasted about five minutes before he realized he’d made a massive mistake and fought to get Mady back.
The "Momma’s Boy" Label
Before the Sydney drama, there was the Courtney incident. Courtney Boerner was Andy’s first partner. It ended fast. Why? Because Andy talked about his mom. A lot.
He runs a real estate business with his mother, Jamie Voyen. In the real world, that’s a successful career. In the Love Island villa, it was a "red flag" for Courtney. She immediately checked out. Fans jumped on the bandwagon, labeling him a "momma's boy" who wasn't ready for a real relationship.
It’s kinda funny how a strong family bond gets twisted into a character flaw for TV. While it didn't work for Courtney, it clearly didn't bother Mady as much—at least not initially.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
What Happened with Mady After the Show?
This is where it gets messy.
When Andy was dumped on Day 11, Mady was devastated. She actually ended up self-eliminating later because she couldn't find a connection with anyone else. Fans were rooting for them. They reunited outside, posted cute TikToks, and did the whole "we're trying to make it work" press tour.
Then came the apple orchard.
On September 13, 2022, they announced their split. Mady later went on the After The Island podcast and spilled the tea. She revealed that Andy broke up with her during a date at an apple orchard. The weirdest part? He was posting photos of them together on his Instagram Story at the same time he was telling her it was over.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
According to Mady, he told her she didn't "fulfill" him. He even played "You Deserve Better" by James Arthur in the car after the breakup. It was a cold move for a guy who claimed to be "Minnesota Nice."
Where Is Andy Voyen Now?
If you check out Andy today, he’s moved far away from the reality TV spotlight. He didn't become a full-time influencer like some of his castmates. Instead, he leaned back into his actual career.
- Real Estate Success: He’s still a powerhouse in the Twin Cities real estate market. The Voyen Team is doing well, and he’s reportedly built a net worth of around $1 million through property deals rather than brand deals.
- Marriage: Sorry to the fans still holding out hope for a villa romance—Andy is officially off the market. He married Ally Voyen, and from the looks of it, he’s swapped the chaotic villa life for a much more stable, private existence.
- Modeling: He still does some modeling on the side (he’s 6'3" with blue eyes, so no surprise there), but it’s definitely secondary to the "day job."
The Lessons from the Andy Voyen Era
Andy’s time on the show was short, but it’s a perfect case study in how "nice guys" can struggle in a manufactured environment. He tried to "play the game" by following his gut (the Sydney situation), but he didn't have the stomach for the fallout.
If you're looking for actionable insights from the Andy Voyen saga, here they are:
- Communication is everything. If Andy had just talked to Isaiah before the recoupling, he probably wouldn't have been the season's pariah.
- Reality TV isn't for everyone. Some people are built for the drama; others, like Andy, are clearly better off selling houses and living a normal life.
- The "Edit" is real. We saw a guy obsessed with his mom and blondes. In reality, he was a guy with a successful business and a close-knit family who just didn't know how to navigate a dating show.
Andy Voyen might have been the "villain" for a week in 2022, but by 2026, he’s just another guy who found success after the cameras stopped rolling. He’s proof that you don't need to win the $100,000 prize to come out on top.
Next steps for fans: If you want to see what Andy is up to now, skip the old Love Island clips and check out his real estate listings in Minneapolis. It’s a lot less dramatic but a lot more impressive.