If you’ve spent any time watching Watch What Happens Live, you’ve probably wondered why the man who orchestrates everyone else’s drama hasn't walked down the aisle himself. Honestly, it’s the million-dollar question. Andy Cohen and boyfriend searches spike every single time he posts a shirtless vacation photo or stands a little too close to a handsome friend on a red carpet. But as we kick off 2026, the reality is a bit more complicated than a simple relationship status update.
Andy is currently single. Yeah, really.
Despite the constant buzz, the Bravo mogul is entering the new year without a partner. He’s been super vocal about it lately, even joking on dating apps about being "catfished" by people using his own face. Can you imagine? Swiping right on Andy Cohen only to tell him he's a fake.
The Mystery of the Missing Partner
Why is the most connected man in Hollywood still single? It’s not for lack of trying, or at least lack of interest. Andy has admitted he’s still on the apps—specifically Raya—though he’s had his fair share of frustrations. He’s looking for something specific. Not just a "bravo-holic" looking for a ticket to a Real Housewives reunion, but someone "strong, funny, and driven."
Funny is the big one for him. If you can’t make him laugh, you’re basically dead in the water.
🔗 Read more: Emma Thompson and Family: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Modern Tribe
He’s also been incredibly candid about how his life as a father has shifted his priorities. Raising Ben (now 6) and Lucy (now 3) as a single dad changed the "boyfriend" math. He told People a while back that he’s now looking for the kind of guy you’d bring home to your son, not just someone who looks good in a swimsuit in Mykonos.
That Persistent John Mayer Rumor
We have to talk about John Mayer. We just do.
The internet has been trying to manifest an Andy Cohen and boyfriend reveal involving the "Gravity" singer for over a decade. They travel together. They celebrate birthdays together. They literally look like a couple. But Andy has shut this down more times than a Real Housewives production during a legal dispute.
He recently joked that he needs a "gay version of John Mayer." That’s the dream, apparently. He’s admitted they are "incredibly connected" and that he loves the guy, but it’s strictly platonic. They have a deep, soul-mate level friendship that just doesn't involve the bedroom. It's a nuance that a lot of fans struggle to wrap their heads around, but hey, that's their dynamic.
💡 You might also like: How Old Is Breanna Nix? What the American Idol Star Is Doing Now
Looking Back: The Ex-Files
It hasn't always been a solo act. Most people forget—or never knew—that Andy actually has a few significant exes who still pop up in his life today.
- John Hill: If you listen to Radio Andy, you know John. They dated for about three years in the early 2000s when John was on Broadway. They are the ultimate "exes-to-BFFs" success story. In late 2025, they even joked on WWHL about an old sex tape from 2003 that's supposedly sitting on some "janky" old format.
- The Harvard Student: Around 2017-2018, Andy was linked to a Brazilian PhD student from Harvard. They were spotted on various beaches, but it eventually fizzled out. Andy has always been a bit protective of his non-famous partners, likely because dating a public figure is a total nightmare for someone in academia.
- The PR Exec: More recently, in late 2024 and early 2025, Andy was seen out and about with a handsome PR executive. People thought this was finally it. But like many NYC flings, it seems to have settled into the "just friends" or "it's over" category by the time 2026 rolled around.
The Single Dad Era
Being a single gay dad in the public eye is a heavy lift. Andy has spoken about the "world of worry" that comes with it. He’s not just looking for a boyfriend; he’s looking for a potential co-parent or at least someone who can handle the chaos of two toddlers.
He’s also very aware of the image he projects. He wants his kids to see a healthy, stable household. That means he isn't just parading a rotating door of guys through his West Village apartment.
What’s Next for Andy’s Love Life?
So, what should we expect for the rest of 2026?
📖 Related: Whitney Houston Wedding Dress: Why This 1992 Look Still Matters
Honestly, Andy seems pretty content. He has a massive support system—including his "work husband" Anderson Cooper. Their annual New Year's Eve chemistry is so palpable that people still ask if they’re dating (they aren't, Anderson is basically family).
If an Andy Cohen and boyfriend hard-launch happens this year, it’s probably going to be someone low-key. Someone who doesn't care about the cameras. Andy has hinted that he prefers dating outside the industry because it keeps things grounded.
The Takeaway for Fans:
- Don't believe every rumor: Just because he's on vacation with a guy doesn't mean they're engaged.
- He's picky for a reason: Between his career and his kids, his "free time" is non-existent.
- The apps are a mess: Even for multi-millionaire moguls.
If you’re looking for love yourself, take a page out of Andy's book: stay busy, keep your standards high, and make sure your best friends are the ones who will be there when the dates fail.
Keep an eye on his Instagram stories for any mysterious "hand shots" at dinner—that's usually the first sign of a new flame. But for now, the King of Bravo is doing just fine on his own throne.