Andrew Garfield doesn't do "normal" when it comes to dating. He’s not the guy you’ll find on a curated Instagram grid soft-launching a romance with a bikini model. In fact, he famously told Esquire that he will "never, ever" confirm or deny anything about his personal life. But in early 2024, the internet lost its collective mind when the Spider-Man star was spotted holding hands with a woman who wasn't just another Hollywood starlet.
Her name is Dr. Kate Tomas. She’s a "professional witch" with a PhD from Oxford.
If you were looking for Andrew Garfield girlfriend 2024 updates back in March, you probably saw those grainy paparazzi shots of them in Malibu. They were on a double date with Phoebe Bridgers and Bo Burnham. It felt like the ultimate indie-sleaze crossover event. But while the headlines focused on her "magical" profession, the actual relationship was a whirlwind of intellectual intensity, public scrutiny, and a very quiet ending.
The Reality of Andrew Garfield and Dr. Kate Tomas
Most people assume celebrity relationships are just about red carpets. This wasn't that. Kate Tomas isn't just a "spiritual advisor"—she’s a literal doctor of Philosophical Theology. She’s spent decades studying mysticism and the Western Esoteric tradition.
The two were first linked in March 2024. They were seen at a grocery store in Malibu, looking like every other couple trying to decide which almond milk to buy. Then came the dinner at Zinqué. Garfield, 41, looked his usual casual self in a black cap, while Tomas stood out in a floral sundress and loafers.
They seemed genuinely smitten. There were reports of them leaving the Chiltern Firehouse in London later in June. It looked like Garfield had finally found someone who matched his own deep, often philosophical way of looking at the world. He’s a guy who gives 20-minute interviews about the nature of grief and love; dating an Oxford-educated mystic actually makes a lot of sense when you think about it.
👉 See also: Martha Stewart Young Modeling: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the "Witch" Label Was Complicated
Honestly, the media handled the "professional witch" thing about as gracefully as a sledgehammer. Tomas eventually spoke out about the "misogynistic nature" of the public interest in her. In an interview with The Sunday Times, she pointed out how frustrating it is that no matter how accomplished a woman is, she’s often reduced to who she’s dating.
She wasn't just Andrew Garfield's girlfriend; she was a woman with a thriving international practice and a best-selling book. She even had to go on her podcast to shut down rumors that she used "magic spells" to seduce him. Because, apparently, in 2024, people still find it easier to believe in love potions than a genuine connection between two eccentric, intelligent people.
What Led to the Split?
By the time the leaves started turning in late 2024, the romance had fizzled. It wasn't a dramatic explosion. There were no "sources close to the couple" leaking messy details to TMZ every hour.
Instead, Kate Tomas herself confirmed it in the most low-key way possible: an Instagram comment.
In October 2024, a fan asked if she and Andrew were still together. Her response was blunt but kind. "We broke up months ago," she wrote. She added that she was sure he’d be happy to know he is still loved.
✨ Don't miss: Ethan Slater and Frankie Grande: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
"We broke up months ago but I'm sure he will be happy to know that he is loved." — Dr. Kate Tomas via Instagram
There’s been plenty of speculation about why they called it quits. Some "blind items" on gossip sites like DeuxMoi suggested that Tomas found Garfield wasn't "politically radical" enough for her. Others hinted that the sheer pressure of the paparazzi—who she said would take 150 photos just to find the four where she looked the worst—was the real dealbreaker.
The truth is likely a mix of both. Dating a man who is essentially Hollywood royalty while trying to maintain a career as a spiritual mentor is a logistical nightmare.
Andrew Garfield's Dating History Before 2024
To understand why the 2024 relationship with Kate Tomas was such a talking point, you have to look at who came before. Andrew has a "type," but it’s more about a vibe than a look.
- Emma Stone (2011–2015): The gold standard of celebrity exes. They are still incredibly supportive of each other.
- Rita Ora (2018): A brief, surprising crossover into the pop world.
- Alyssa Miller (2021–2022): A serious relationship with the model that ended just as Spider-Man: No Way Home was peaking.
- Olivia Brower (Early 2024): A very fleeting sighting in London right before he met Kate.
Each of these women is vastly different, but they all share a certain fierce independence. Garfield doesn't seem to date "fans." He dates peers.
🔗 Read more: Leonardo DiCaprio Met Gala: What Really Happened with His Secret Debut
Moving Into 2025: Who Is He Dating Now?
If you've moved past the 2024 archives and are looking at the current landscape, things have changed. As of early 2025, Andrew has been heavily linked to actress Monica Barbaro.
You might recognize her as Phoenix from Top Gun: Maverick or for her role as Joan Baez in the Bob Dylan biopic A Complete Unknown. The two were first spotted at a W Magazine event in January 2025. By February, People confirmed they were "quietly dating."
They’ve been much more public than he was with Tomas. They attended a play together in London and were even seen holding hands at Wimbledon in July 2025, wearing matching Ralph Lauren outfits. It seems the "shaggy blonde hair" era of Andrew Garfield (yes, he went blonde recently) is being spent firmly by Monica's side.
The Takeaway for Fans
Tracking Andrew Garfield’s love life is a lesson in patience. He isn't going to give you a "get ready with me" video for a date night. He isn't going to tweet about his heartbreak.
If you’re following the Andrew Garfield girlfriend 2024 timeline, the story is one of a brief, intense connection with a brilliant woman that simply couldn't survive the glare of the spotlight. It reminds us that even for "The Amazing Spider-Man," balancing a private identity with a public persona is a constant struggle.
What to do next:
If you want to keep up with Andrew's latest moves without falling for clickbait, keep an eye on theater sightings in London or New York. He tends to frequent smaller productions rather than big Hollywood parties. Also, keep an eye on Monica Barbaro’s upcoming press tours—while they likely won't walk a carpet together, the "separate arrivals" at the same events are usually the clearest signal he’s giving.