If you’ve ever stared down a green tide of Orks or a literal wall of Tyranid chitin across a tabletop, you know the feeling. Dread. It’s that sinking realization that your plastic soldiers are about to get absolutely obliterated. But then you remember the most iconic line in the history of Games Workshop’s Warhammer 40,000. You remember that your super-soldiers are genetically forged to ignore the very concept of terror. And They Shall Know No Fear isn't just a catchy bit of lore flavor text from a 1987 rulebook. It is the mechanical heartbeat of the Space Marines.
Honestly, it’s kinda the reason people play the faction. It's the ultimate power fantasy. You aren't playing as some terrified conscript clutching a lasgun. You are playing as an eight-foot-tall demi-god who literally cannot process the urge to run away. Over decades of editions, this rule has changed more times than most players can count, but its soul remains the same.
What "And They Shall Know No Fear" Actually Means in the Lore
Before we get into the crunch of dice rolls and Morale Tests, let’s talk about the vibe. The Emperor of Mankind didn't just give the Legiones Astartes better guns. He rebuilt their brains. According to the Codex Astartes—the massive lore bible written by the Primarch Roboute Guilliman—the process of creating a Space Marine involves intense psycho-indoctrination.
They don't feel fear. Not really.
When a normal human sees a Greater Daemon of Khorne, their brain basically shuts down. Their fight-or-flight response kicks into overdrive, and usually, it's all "flight." A Space Marine sees that same daemon and thinks about the most efficient way to put a chainsword through its neck. It’s a biological imperative. This specific phrase—And They Shall Know No Fear—was reportedly first uttered by the Emperor himself during the unification of Terra. He wanted a force that wouldn't break when the galaxy got weird. And boy, does the 41st Millennium get weird.
How the Rule Has Evolved (And Why It Used to Be Broken)
The history of this rule is basically a history of Warhammer 40k itself. Back in the day, specifically during the 3rd through 7th editions, And They Shall Know No Fear (or ATSKNF for those who like acronyms) was incredibly powerful.
📖 Related: Is the PlayStation 5 Slim Console Digital Edition Actually Worth It?
If a unit failed a Morale check, they would normally fall back. For most armies, this meant potentially running off the board or being "swept" and destroyed in combat. Not the Marines. If they were forced to fall back, they just... did it. Then, at the start of their next turn, they automatically rallied. They didn't even have to roll for it. They just stopped running, turned around, and started shooting again. It made them frustratingly hard to shift off an objective. You’d think you had them beat, and then they’d just shrug and get back to work.
The Shift to 8th and 9th Edition
When 10th Edition rolled around, Games Workshop decided to simplify things. They introduced "Battle-shock."
Basically, instead of units running away and dying, they now lose the ability to hold objectives and use Stratagems. In the current state of the game, And They Shall Know No Fear has morphed again. Now, it usually allows Space Marines to ignore modifiers to their Battle-shock tests or gives them a better chance to pass. It’s less about "never running" and more about being incredibly resilient under pressure.
Is it as "cool" as the old version? Maybe not. But it’s balanced.
The Primarch Factor: Fear vs. Logistics
You can't talk about this rule without talking about the Primarchs. Take Konrad Curze of the Night Lords. His whole thing was fear. He used it as a weapon. He believed that if you were scary enough, you didn't have to fight a war; you just had to win the psychological one.
👉 See also: How to Solve 6x6 Rubik's Cube Without Losing Your Mind
Then you have the Ultramarines. They are the poster boys for And They Shall Know No Fear. They don't care how scary you are because they have a checklist. They have a manual. Fear is an inefficient use of resources, and Guilliman doesn't do "inefficient."
This creates a fascinating dynamic on the tabletop. If you’re playing Night Lords (using Chaos Space Marine rules), you’re trying to stack negative modifiers on your opponent's leadership. You want them to break. But if you’re playing against standard Space Marines, your best weapon is basically neutralized. It’s a thematic clash that has defined thousands of games over the last 30 years.
Why Do People Still Get This Wrong?
There's a huge misconception that "No Fear" means "No Caution."
Space Marines aren't stupid. Well, mostly. A Space Marine knows when a tactical withdrawal is necessary. The rule doesn't mean they blindly charge into certain death every single time (unless they’re Black Templars, maybe). It means that when they do move back, it’s a controlled, tactical decision. They aren't screaming in terror. They are repositioning to a better firing lane.
Another weird point of confusion: The Adeptus Custodes. People often think the Custodes have a "better" version of this rule. Technically, they do—they are often completely immune to certain morale mechanics—but they don't use the specific "And They Shall Know No Fear" branding. That is strictly an Astartes thing. It’s their brand. It’s their identity.
✨ Don't miss: How Orc Names in Skyrim Actually Work: It's All About the Bloodline
Applying the "No Fear" Mindset to Your List Building
If you’re actually playing the game, you need to know how to leverage this resilience. Since your units are less likely to break or lose their objective-holding capabilities, you can afford to be more aggressive with small squads.
A five-man Intercessor squad is a lot more "sticky" than five humans from the Astra Militarum. You can park them on a point and trust that even if they take casualties, they’ll stay put. You aren't just paying for the power armor and the bolter; you’re paying for the fact that they won't disappear because a scary monster looked at them funny.
- Prioritize Objectives: Use your Brave/Fearless status to sit on contested points.
- Don't Over-Invest in Leadership Buffs: You already have the best natural leadership in the game. Use those points for more guns instead.
- Watch Out for "Precision": Fear doesn't matter if your character gets picked off by a sniper. The rule protects the unit's psyche, not their health bar.
The Psychological Impact on the Opponent
There is a real-world psychological element to this rule. When you tell your opponent "I pass that check automatically" or "I get a re-roll because they know no fear," it’s demoralizing. It reinforces the idea that the Space Marines are the protagonists of the setting.
It feels unfair because, in a way, it is.
But that’s the point of the grim dark future. Everything is unfair. The Orks have infinite numbers. The Necrons literally get back up after you kill them. The Tyranids eat the map. The Space Marines? They just stay. They stand their ground when anyone else would have bolted for the drop pods.
Actionable Insights for Players and Hobbyists
If you want to lean into the "And They Shall Know No Fear" vibe for your next hobby project or game night, here is how you do it without being "that guy" at the local shop.
- Model Your Bravery: When building your miniatures, don't just put them in "firing" poses. Use the "heroic" bits. Use the bare heads with the shouting faces. It reflects the lore that these guys are literally screaming defiance into the face of gods.
- Know Your Current Edition: Rules change. In 10th Edition, check your specific Chapter tactics. Some Chapters, like the Dark Angels, have specialized ways of interacting with Battle-shock that feel like an "upgraded" version of the classic rule.
- Read the Horus Heresy Novels: If you want to see this rule in action, read Horus Rising. It shows the moment where the Marines realize that for the first time in their lives, they might actually have something to be afraid of. It adds a ton of weight to the phrase.
- Use Stratagems Wisely: Even with high leadership, you will eventually fail a roll. Keep a CP (Command Point) in reserve for "Insane Bravery." It’s basically the "And They Shall Know No Fear" panic button.
At the end of the day, And They Shall Know No Fear is more than a line of code in a rulebook. It’s the defining characteristic of the most famous sci-fi soldiers ever created. It’s the reason why, 40,000 years into the future, humanity is still kicking. They aren't the strongest, and they aren't the most numerous. They’re just the ones who refuse to blink first.