If you were watching TV on September 26, 2010, you probably remember the hype. Fox wasn't just dropping another half-hour of Seth MacFarlane’s usual cutaway-heavy chaos. No, they gave us something different. Family Guy Season 9 Episode 1, titled "And Then There Were Fewer," was a full-hour murder mystery that felt more like a movie than a cartoon. It was weirdly cinematic. Honestly, it kind of reset the bar for what the show could do when it actually tried to tell a cohesive story instead of just making fun of 80s pop culture for twenty minutes straight.
Most people forget that this was the first episode of the show to ever be broadcast in high definition and a 16:9 aspect ratio. It looked crisp. It looked expensive. It also signaled a shift in how the writers approached "event" television. By taking the entire cast of Quahog and sticking them in a spooky mansion, they managed to kill off characters we’d known for years. Permanent deaths. In a sitcom! That just didn't happen back then.
The Agatha Christie Connection
The whole thing is basically a massive love letter to And Then There Were None. You’ve got the isolated mansion on a cliff, the stormy weather, and a group of people with secrets being picked off one by one. James Woods—playing a heightened, jerk-ish version of himself—invites everyone to his manor to "apologize" for his past behavior. It’s a classic setup. But the execution is what makes it stand out in the middle of a long-running series.
Usually, Family Guy relies on a very specific rhythm. Joke. Cutaway. Joke. Plot point. Joke. This episode broke that rhythm. It took its time. It let the atmosphere breathe. You actually felt a bit of tension when Muriel Goldman or Diane Simmons were on screen, which is wild considering this is the same show that features a talking dog and a baby who used to want world domination.
Why the Mystery Actually Worked
It wasn't just a parody. It was a functioning whodunnit. When the bodies started piling up, the show didn't immediately go for the gag. It let the mystery drive the action. We saw characters like Derek Wilcox (Lois’s ex-boyfriend) get tossed off a balcony, and for once, the stakes felt real within the context of the show’s universe.
The reveal that Diane Simmons was the killer? Legitimate shocker for most fans. It wasn't some random background character or a "it was all a dream" trope. It was a series regular who had been behind the news desk since the pilot. Her motivation—being replaced by a younger woman at the news station and being dumped by Tom Tucker—felt grounded in the cynical reality the show usually mocks.
✨ Don't miss: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
The Body Count and Lasting Impact
Let's talk about the deaths because they actually mattered. Well, as much as anything matters in animation. Family Guy Season 9 Episode 1 didn't just kill off redshirts.
- Muriel Goldman: Mort’s wife. Her death actually stuck, leaving Mort as a widower for the rest of the series.
- Derek Wilcox: A minor character, sure, but his death provided one of the more gruesome visuals of the night.
- Diane Simmons: The big one. After Stewie sniped her off the cliff to save Lois, she was gone for good.
- Stephanie: Quagmire's date. She was mostly there to provide a body, but it added to the mounting dread.
Killing Diane Simmons was a massive creative risk. She was half of the news team! Replacing her eventually led to Joyce Kinney joining the cast, but the dynamic never felt quite the same. It proved that the writers were willing to prune the bush to keep things interesting.
The episode also solidified the "New Family Guy" era. This was the moment where the show fully embraced its status as a Fox powerhouse. It had the budget to do these hour-long specials. It had the confidence to move away from the status quo.
Technical Mastery in Animation
Seth MacFarlane has always been a fan of big, orchestral scores. This episode gave Walter Murphy, the show's composer, a chance to really flex. The music isn't just background noise here; it’s a character. It mimics those old Hollywood thrillers perfectly. It’s sweeping, it’s ominous, and it gives the mansion a sense of scale that the Griffin home just doesn't have.
Then there's the lighting. It sounds geeky to talk about lighting in a 2D cartoon, but "And Then There Were Fewer" used shadows and color palettes to convey a mood that was genuinely bleak. The heavy rains, the flickering candles, the dim hallways—it all contributed to a feeling of claustrophobia. You've got to respect the animators for stepping up their game for the Season 9 premiere.
🔗 Read more: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
The Problem With Modern Re-watches
Watching it today, some of the jokes haven't aged perfectly. That’s just the nature of the beast with a show that moves as fast as this one. However, the core plot remains incredibly solid. It's one of the few episodes you can show to someone who hates Family Guy and they might actually enjoy it because the storytelling is so tight.
One thing people often overlook is how the episode handled the "James Woods" of it all. At the time, Woods was a frequent guest star. Making him the "host" who seemingly gets murdered early on (only to be revealed as a victim of a different plot) was a clever subversion. It played with the audience's expectations of how celebrities are treated in the show.
What Most Fans Miss About Season 9
Season 9 is often cited by die-hard fans as one of the last "great" seasons before the show settled into a more predictable routine. Starting it off with an hour-long murder mystery was a statement of intent. It told the audience: "We can still surprise you."
If you look at the episodes that followed—like "Brian Writes a Bestseller" or "Road to the North Pole"—there was a lot of experimentation happening. But Family Guy Season 9 Episode 1 remains the high-water mark of that period. It combined the show’s signature mean-spirited humor with a narrative ambition we rarely see in adult animation outside of The Simpsons in their prime.
Breaking the Fourth Wall vs. True Immersion
Usually, Peter Griffin will look at the camera and tell you exactly what’s happening. In "And Then There Were Fewer," the fourth-wall breaks are dialed back. The characters are largely "in" the story. When they are scared, the show treats it as real fear. This shift in tone is why the episode sticks in people’s minds. It wasn't just a collection of skits; it was an event.
💡 You might also like: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
Actionable Takeaways for Superfans
If you’re planning a re-watch or introducing someone to the show, there are a few things you should keep in mind to get the most out of this specific episode.
- Watch the Unrated Version: The DVD or digital "uncut" versions have a few extra lines and slightly more graphic visuals that were trimmed for the Fox broadcast. It enhances the "horror" vibe.
- Look at the Backgrounds: Pay attention to the mansion's layout. The show actually kept the geography of the house consistent throughout the hour, which is a nightmare for animators but great for the mystery.
- Track the Timeline: If you watch closely, you can actually see Diane Simmons disappearing from scenes right before a murder occurs. The clues are there if you look for them.
- Listen to the Score: If you have a decent sound system or headphones, pay attention to how the music shifts when the perspective changes. It’s a masterclass in TV scoring.
The legacy of "And Then There Were Fewer" isn't just that it was a "big" episode. It’s that it proved Family Guy could handle drama and mystery without losing its identity. It remains a definitive piece of television history for the 2010s, marking the transition into the high-definition era with a literal bang.
Instead of just checking it out on a streaming loop, sit down and watch it as a standalone movie. It holds up surprisingly well as a piece of suspense, even if you know the ending. The craftsmanship in the script and the animation makes it a rare example of a long-running show successfully reinventing itself, even if just for a night.
Next Steps for the Viewer: Go back and watch the pilot episode immediately after finishing Season 9, Episode 1. Comparing the animation style and the character voices of Diane Simmons and Tom Tucker from the 1999 premiere to their final moments in this episode highlights exactly how much the show evolved over a decade. It’s the best way to appreciate the technical leap the series made.