Before the meat dresses and the jazz duets with Tony Bennett, Lady Gaga was just a brunette girl named Stefani performing in gritty New York dive bars. She had big hair. She wore thick, dramatic eyeliner. People used to stop her on the street constantly. Not because they knew who she was, but because they thought she was Amy Winehouse.
Honestly, it’s wild to think about now. Gaga is such a singular force in pop culture that imagining her as a "lookalike" feels wrong. But back in 2007, Winehouse was the blueprint. She was the one who proved that a girl with a weird voice, an obsession with 60s soul, and a messy personal life could actually rule the charts. Gaga saw that. She felt it.
The connection between Amy Winehouse and Lady Gaga isn't just about a shared aesthetic or a love for vintage jazz. It's a story of survival, influence, and the way the music industry devours its own.
The Hair Dye That Changed Everything
Most fans don't realize that Gaga’s signature platinum blonde look was actually a tactical move. In 2008, as she was preparing to launch The Fame, the comparisons to Winehouse were becoming a problem. Amy was at the height of her Back to Black era. She was the "it" girl of the moment, but she was also the focus of a brutal tabloid frenzy.
Gaga told Digital Spy back in 2010 that she dyed her hair blonde specifically to create her own lane. She didn't want to be "the American Amy." She wanted to be Gaga. "I was nobody when she was first coming out," Gaga recalled. "I would be on the street and people would go 'Amy!'"
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
There was a deep respect there, though. Gaga wasn't running away from Amy's talent—she was running away from being a copycat. She once described Amy as the "flu" for pop music. Basically, Amy made the world a little "sick" with her sound, and once everyone was infected, they were ready for more unconventional artists. Without the door Amy kicked down, Gaga might never have been signed. Record executives in the mid-2000s weren't exactly looking for "offbeat" women until Amy made them profitable.
That "You Know Who" Moment in Five Foot Two
If you’ve watched the Netflix documentary Gaga: Five Foot Two, there is a scene that still gives fans chills. Gaga is talking about the VMAs, specifically her 2009 performance of "Paparazzi." You remember the one—where she ends the set hanging from the ceiling, covered in fake blood.
She mentions that if she’s going to be sexy, she’s going to do it while "bleeding to death" as a reminder of what fame did to Marilyn Monroe, Anna Nicole Smith, and... then she stops. She won't say the last name. She just says, "And what it did to, yeah. Do you know who?"
Director Chris Moukarbel later confirmed she was talking about Amy Winehouse.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
The tragedy of Amy's death in 2011 hit Gaga incredibly hard. She didn't speak for 48 hours. When she finally went on The View to talk about it, she was visibly devastated. She told the world that the lesson wasn't for Amy to learn—the lesson was for the world to be kinder to superstars.
The Tony Bennett Connection
There is a bittersweet "what if" that haunts the jazz world.
Tony Bennett, the legendary crooner who became Gaga’s close friend and mentor, also adored Amy. In fact, Amy’s final recording before she passed away was "Body and Soul" with Tony. He saw her as one of the truest jazz singers he had ever worked with.
When Gaga stepped into the studio to record Cheek to Cheek with Tony years later, Amy’s presence was everywhere. Gaga has admitted she thought of Amy almost every day during those sessions. There’s a persistent belief among music historians that if Amy had lived, she would have been the one making those albums with Tony. Gaga knows this. She has always treated her jazz era with a sense of reverence, almost like she was carrying a torch that was never supposed to be hers alone.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Breaking Down the Myths
People love a good conspiracy theory. You’ve probably seen the Reddit threads claiming Gaga "stole" Amy’s persona or that they were secret rivals.
Let's look at the facts:
- Did they ever meet? No. Despite being in the same industry at the same time, their paths never crossed for a formal meeting. Gaga has said she never really knew her personally.
- The Mark Ronson Factor: Both artists worked extensively with producer Mark Ronson. Ronson produced Amy’s Back to Black and later produced Gaga’s Joanne. He often spoke about the "ghost" of Amy being in the room during the recording of "Shallow" and other Gaga tracks.
- The Style: While Gaga leaned into high-concept art-pop, Amy stayed rooted in 60s Motown and jazz. Their sounds were worlds apart, even if their early "New York cool" aesthetics overlapped.
Why the Comparison Still Matters in 2026
We are still talking about Amy Winehouse and Lady Gaga because they represent two different outcomes of the same machine. Amy was the raw, bleeding heart who couldn't find a way to shield herself from the spotlight. Gaga is the master of the mask. She learned from the tragedies of the women who came before her—Amy included—and used costumes, personas, and "The Fame" as a protective layer.
Amy’s legacy is one of pure, unfiltered vulnerability. Gaga’s legacy is one of calculated, artistic survival. Both are essential.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Creators:
If you’re looking to dive deeper into this connection or apply their "expert" lessons to your own creative work, here is how to handle the history:
- Watch the Paparazzi VMA performance again. Now that you know Gaga was thinking about the death of the "star" (and by extension, Amy), the blood and the gore take on a much darker, more literal meaning.
- Listen to the Back to Black and Joanne albums back-to-back. Both were heavily influenced by Mark Ronson and feature that raw, analog sound that Amy pioneered in the mainstream.
- Respect the "Jazz Roots." If you want to understand why Gaga is so protective of her jazz career, listen to Amy’s Frank album. It provides the context for the "offbeat" vocal style that Gaga fought to bring to the pop charts.
- Acknowledge the Industry Shift. When discussing music history, remember that Amy was the catalyst. She made the "weird girl" commercially viable, which paved the road for Gaga, Adele, and eventually artists like Billie Eilish.
The influence isn't a straight line; it's a web of mutual respect and shared ghosts. Gaga survived the era that took Amy, and she has spent the rest of her career making sure we don't forget the girl with the beehive who changed everything.