:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-1210444218-3440a3b7a4f746d8b05f6306e5fc1d5d.jpg)
Shows come and go. But somehow, NBC's massive variety hit has managed to stick around since 2006 without losing its grip on Tuesday night ratings. A huge part of that staying power? The rotating door of celebrities sitting behind those big red buzzers. If you’ve ever wondered why some people lasted a decade while others vanished after a single summer, you aren't alone. It’s actually kinda chaotic when you look at the full timeline of America's Got Talent all judges.
Most people forget that the very first panel looked nothing like what we see today. Back in Season 1, it was David Hasselhoff, Brandy Norwood, and Piers Morgan. It felt like a weird experiment. Honestly, it was. Simon Cowell created the show but couldn't actually be on it yet because of his American Idol contract. He was pulling the strings from the executive producer's chair while "The Hoff" tried to make sense of talking puppets and fire eaters.
The Original Trio and the First Major Shakeup
Brandy didn't stay long. She was gone after just one year. While the official line was often vague, her departure coincided with a high-profile car accident she was involved in late in 2006. That paved the way for Sharon Osbourne to step in. Sharon brought that blunt, maternal energy that the show desperately needed. She stayed for six seasons, becoming a staple of the "classic" era alongside Piers and eventually Howie Mandel.
Howie joined in Season 5. No one knew he’d still be there over fifteen years later. He replaced David Hasselhoff, who left to pursue his own reality show, The Hasselhoffs, which—fun fact—got canceled after only two episodes. Ouch.
Why Howard Stern Changed Everything
When Piers Morgan left in 2011 to take over Larry King’s spot on CNN, the show made a massive pivot. They hired Howard Stern. This was a huge gamble for a "family-friendly" summer show. People expected the "Shock Jock" to be crude, but he ended up being one of the most disciplined and insightful critics the show ever had. He stayed for four seasons, moving the entire production to New York City just to accommodate his radio schedule.
✨ Don't miss: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
The Simon Cowell Era and the Modern Panel
The biggest shift happened in 2016. Simon Cowell finally took his seat on the panel for Season 11. By this point, the show had expanded to four judges. Heidi Klum and Mel B had joined back in Season 8, creating a dynamic that felt like a permanent party. Heidi brought the fashion and the "German precision," while Mel B was the "Scary Spice" firecracker who famously dumped a glass of water on Simon more than once.
But even "permanent" lineups don't last forever in TV.
In 2019, the show tried a complete refresh for Season 14. They brought in Gabrielle Union and Julianne Hough. It didn't go well. Both were gone after one season, leading to a massive controversy. Gabrielle Union later spoke out about a "toxic" culture on set, specifically mentioning issues with how her hair was perceived and certain jokes made by guest stars. NBC eventually did an internal investigation, and while they claimed no "racial bias" was found, the PR damage was done.
Today, the panel feels settled again. Since Season 15, we've mostly seen the core group:
🔗 Read more: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
- Simon Cowell: The boss, the grump, the guy who softened up after becoming a dad.
- Howie Mandel: The longest-running judge in history. His germaphobia and "dad joke" energy are part of the show's DNA now.
- Heidi Klum: The supermodel who actually seems to love the weirdest acts.
- Sofía Vergara: The Modern Family star who brought a fresh, hilarious energy starting in 2020.
Guest Judges and the "Judge Cuts" Chaos
If we’re talking about America's Got Talent all judges, we have to mention the guest stars. For a few years, the "Judge Cuts" round brought in celebrities to help narrow down the field. These weren't just random people; we saw Neil Patrick Harris, Reba McEntire, DJ Khaled, and even Ken Jeong.
There were also the emergency fill-ins. When Simon broke his back in an electric bike accident in 2020, Kelly Clarkson and Kenan Thompson stepped in to keep the live shows running. When Heidi got sick during auditions, Eric Stonestreet (Sofía's former co-star) jumped in. It’s a "the show must go on" vibe that few other series can match.
Money, Power, and the Buzzer
Why do they do it? Well, the money is ridiculous. Simon Cowell's net worth is estimated at over $600 million, largely because he owns the "Got Talent" franchise globally. Howie Mandel reportedly makes around $70,000 per episode, which adds up fast when you consider he's been there for hundreds of them.
It’s a grueling schedule, though. People think they just sit there and watch 90-second acts. In reality, audition days can last 12 to 14 hours. You're sitting in the same chair, under hot lights, watching some of the worst talent in America for hours before a "viral" act finally hits the stage.
💡 You might also like: America's Got Talent Transformation: Why the Show Looks So Different in 2026
Key Lessons from the Judging History
If you’re a fan or a student of television, the history of this panel shows a few things. First, chemistry is everything. The Simon-Howie-Heidi-Sofía group works because they actually seem to like each other. Second, the show isn't afraid to cut its losses. If a judge doesn't "pop" in the first six weeks, they're usually gone by next summer.
To stay informed on future lineup changes, keep an eye on official NBC press releases during the "upfronts" in May. That is usually when contract renewals are leaked or confirmed. If you're looking to audition yourself, remember that Howie loves comedy, Simon loves a "sob story" with a great voice, and Sofía is a sucker for a handsome magician.
Understand the judges, and you understand the show. It’s less about the talent and more about how that talent makes four very rich celebrities feel on a Tuesday night in July.