You probably remember the business cards. The raincoat. The chainsaw. But honestly, if you haven’t revisited American Psycho lately, you might have forgotten just how much heavy lifting Reese Witherspoon does as Evelyn Williams.
It’s easy to overlook her. In a movie where the lead is literally hacking people apart to the sounds of Huey Lewis and the News, a shallow socialite talking about "potpourri" feels like background noise. But that’s kind of the point.
Evelyn isn't just Patrick Bateman's fiancée. She’s his cage.
The Casting Battle You Didn't Know About
Back in 1999, the production of this movie was a total mess. Director Mary Harron had to fight tooth and nail just to keep Christian Bale in the lead role. The studio, Lionsgate, was obsessed with the idea of getting Leonardo DiCaprio. They thought Bale wasn't "famous enough."
To appease the money men, Harron had to stack the supporting cast with "known" faces. This is basically why we ended up with a powerhouse lineup: Willem Dafoe, Jared Leto, and of course, Reese Witherspoon.
At the time, Reese was fresh off Election and Cruel Intentions. She was the "It Girl" for playing sharp, slightly terrifying blondes. Casting her as Evelyn was a stroke of genius because she brought a specific brand of high-society chirpiness that makes Patrick’s internal screaming feel so much louder.
Why Evelyn Williams Actually Matters
If you look at the structure of the film, Evelyn is the primary tether to Patrick’s "normal" life. While he’s out here obsessing over the font on a business card or the bone-white coloring of a colleague's stationary, Evelyn is the one forcing him into the mundane rituals of the 1% in the 80s.
📖 Related: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
Think about the dinner scenes. They’re excruciating.
She’s talking about wedding invitations and "the mid-day" while Patrick is literally losing his mind. There's this one specific beat where she's crying about their relationship in a restaurant, and Patrick is just doodling a murder on a paper tablecloth with a crayon.
Reese plays it with this perfect, oblivious desperation. She isn't a victim in the traditional slasher sense—she’s a victim of the same shallow culture that created Patrick. She’s so self-absorbed that she can't even see the monster sitting across from her. It's dark. It's funny. It's totally underrated.
Behind the Scenes: The "Method" Tension
It’s no secret now that Christian Bale went full "Method" on set. He was being social, but only as Patrick Bateman.
Chloë Sevigny has famously mentioned how intimidating and "challenging" it was to work with him because he wouldn't break character. While Josh Lucas initially thought Bale’s acting was "terrible" before realizing the genius of the satire, Reese had to play the person closest to him.
She had to be the one person Patrick couldn't just "eliminate" easily because she was part of the social fabric he was desperate to belong to.
👉 See also: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
The Breakup Scene: A Masterclass in Satire
The climax of the American Psycho Reese Witherspoon connection is undoubtedly the breakup scene. It’s peak dark comedy.
Patrick finally snaps. He tells her, "I’m into, uh, murders and executions mostly."
And what does Evelyn do? She assumes he says "mergers and acquisitions."
She doesn't hear him because, in her world, people don't say things like that. When he finally tells her he's a "f***ing pro" and that he doesn't think they should see each other anymore, her reaction isn't fear. It's social embarrassment. She’s more upset about the "waited-on" status of their relationship than the fact that her fiancé is clearly a lunatic.
The "Legally Blonde" Connection
It is wild to think that just one year after American Psycho hit theaters, Reese Witherspoon would transform into Elle Woods for Legally Blonde.
In a way, Evelyn Williams is the "Evil Mirror" version of Elle Woods. They both have the hair, the outfits, and the high-pitched social standing. But where Elle uses her status for good and breaks stereotypes, Evelyn is the embodiment of every vapid, soul-crushing stereotype of the Reagan era.
✨ Don't miss: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
If you watch them back-to-back, you can see how Reese used the same "perky" energy to two completely different ends. One is a hero; the other is a symptom of a sick society.
Why We’re Still Talking About This in 2026
The reason American Psycho has stayed relevant—and why the American Psycho Reese Witherspoon performance still gets analyzed—is that the "hollow" culture it mocked hasn't really gone away. It just moved to Instagram and TikTok.
Evelyn is the original influencer. She’s obsessed with the aesthetic of a life rather than the reality of it.
Honestly, if the movie were made today, Evelyn would be the one filming a "Get Ready With Me" video while Patrick is in the background doing his 1,000 stomach crunches. The tragedy of her character is that she is the only person who could have stopped him if she had just listened for five seconds. But she was too busy checking the reservation at Dorsia.
What to Look for on Your Next Rewatch
Next time you put this on, don't just wait for the "Hip to Be Square" scene. Watch Reese’s face during the Christmas party.
- Look at how she holds that tiny pig. It’s absurd.
- Pay attention to how she treats the "help" or the people she deems "below" her.
- Notice the way she reacts when Patrick starts sweating or acting "weird."
She isn't just a supporting character; she’s the mirror that reflects Patrick's deepest fear: that he isn't special, he’s just another boring guy in a suit with a boring fiancée.
Final Takeaways for Film Buffs
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific era of film, here are a few things you can do:
- Compare the Book to the Film: In Bret Easton Ellis’s novel, Evelyn is even more insufferable. Reading her chapters makes you realize how much humanity Reese actually brought to the role.
- Watch the "Evelyn" Scenes with the Sound Off: You’ll notice how much physical comedy Reese puts into her movements—the way she adjusts her hair or looks around a room. It’s all about performance.
- Check Out Mary Harron’s Interviews: The director has spoken at length about how she wanted the women in the film to be the only ones who felt "real," even if they were shallow.
Reese Witherspoon might have been a "studio requirement" for the cast, but she ended up being the secret weapon that made the satire stick. She played the part of the perfect 80s fiancée so well that we almost missed how terrifying she actually was.