You’ve seen the posters. You’ve probably argued with your friends at a bar about whether that one direct-to-video flick with Stifler’s cousin "counts." But let’s get the facts straight: if you’re looking for the American Pie 4 movie, you’ve likely already watched it without realizing it.
Most people call it American Reunion.
It’s a weird quirk of Hollywood branding. In the United States, Universal Pictures dropped the "4" and went with a title that felt more like an event. But look at the international posters in the UK or Australia, and there it is, plain as day: American Pie 4: Reunion. This isn't just a spin-off with a random relative of the main cast. This is the official fourth chapter that brought back the entire original gang from the 1999 classic.
The Confusion Between Sequels and Spinoffs
The American Pie timeline is basically a giant, messy family tree. Honestly, it’s easy to see why people get confused. Between 2005 and 2009, the franchise went through a "dark age" of sorts. We got four straight-to-DVD movies under the American Pie Presents banner—Band Camp, The Naked Mile, Beta House, and The Book of Love.
They were raunchy. They were loud. But they weren't "real" sequels.
📖 Related: Al Pacino Angels in America: Why His Roy Cohn Still Terrifies Us
Aside from Eugene Levy’s Noah Levenstein showing up as the glue holding those spin-offs together, the original cast was nowhere to be found. So, when 2012 rolled around and Jim, Stifler, Oz, Kevin, and Finch actually returned to East Great Falls, it was technically the fourth time the core group shared the screen. That’s why American Reunion is the definitive American Pie 4 movie.
What Really Happened in the Fourth Movie?
By the time the fourth film starts, the guys aren't kids anymore. Jim and Michelle have a toddler and a non-existent sex life. Kevin is a "house husband" who’s a bit too obsessed with The Real Housewives. Oz is a famous sportscaster with a supermodel girlfriend he doesn't actually like.
Then there’s Stifler.
Steve Stifler is the only one who hasn't changed, and that’s the tragedy—and the comedy—of it. He’s working a temp job for a boss who treats him like dirt, still clinging to the "Stiffmeister" glory days of 1999. The movie works because it acknowledges that being a "legend" in high school doesn't mean much when you're pushing 30.
👉 See also: Adam Scott in Step Brothers: Why Derek is Still the Funniest Part of the Movie
Is There a Fifth Movie Coming in 2026?
This is where the rumors get wild. For years, Tara Reid has been telling anyone who will listen that a script for a fifth movie exists and that it’s "one of the best ones yet." In 2021, Thomas Ian Nicholas confirmed that negotiations were actually happening, but they reportedly fell through over "business stuff"—likely the budget or actor salaries.
As of early 2026, here is the actual state of play:
- The Sujata Day Project: Back in 2022, Universal 1440 Entertainment announced a "fresh take" on the franchise written by Sujata Day (Insecure). This isn't necessarily American Pie 5, but rather a total reimagining or a new branch of the series.
- The Original Cast Status: Jason Biggs recently told People he’d love to return, but the "moving parts" are complicated. He’s currently busy with his own projects, including a comedy-thriller he directed and starred in alongside Meaghan Rath.
- The "Legacy" Script: There is a long-standing rumor about a script where Jim’s dad (Eugene Levy) and Stifler’s mom (Jennifer Coolidge) get married. This would make Jim and Stifler step-brothers. If that doesn't sound like a goldmine for comedy, I don't know what does.
Why the Fourth Film Still Holds Up
Usually, late-stage sequels feel like a desperate cash grab. Think about how many franchises try to "pass the torch" to a younger, cheaper cast and fail miserably. American Reunion avoided that trap by focusing entirely on the original chemistry.
The scene where Jim’s dad tries to give him "the talk" one last time, but they’re both grown men, is genuinely sweet. It captures that awkward transition from being someone's kid to being their peer.
✨ Don't miss: Actor Most Academy Awards: The Record Nobody Is Breaking Anytime Soon
The movie also didn't shy away from the gross-out humor that made it famous. From the "clear lid" kitchen incident to Stifler’s revenge on the jet-skiing bullies, it kept the R-rated spirit alive. It’s a rare example of a franchise growing up without losing its sense of (admittedly immature) humor.
How to Watch the Franchise Correctly
If you want the true experience of the American Pie 4 movie and the path leading up to it, you have to ignore the "Presents" titles. Stick to the theatrical four:
- American Pie (1999): The one that started the "MILF" craze and made everyone look at baked goods differently.
- American Pie 2 (2001): The summer beach house movie. Arguably the peak of the series' popularity.
- American Wedding (2003): The third film that trimmed the cast down but gave Stifler his biggest role yet.
- American Reunion (2012): The official fourth chapter where everyone returns to their roots.
Don't let the 4K box sets or streaming labels confuse you. While there are technically nine movies with the "American Pie" name on them, only those four tell the continuous story of Jim Levenstein and his friends.
If you are planning a marathon, skip the spin-offs unless you have a high tolerance for early-2000s direct-to-video tropes. Instead, focus on the evolution of the main characters. You’ll find that beneath the raunchy gags, there’s a surprisingly consistent story about friendship and the terrifying reality of growing older. Keep an eye on trade publications like The Hollywood Reporter for official news on Sujata Day’s new project, as that is currently the only active production in the American Pie universe.