Ali Afshar is a guy who lived it. That’s the first thing you have to understand about American Fighter. While most Hollywood sports movies feel like they were written by someone who once saw a gym from across the street, this movie smells like real mats and desperation. It’s a 2019/2021 release (depending on which territory you’re in) that serves as a prequel to the 2016 film American Wrestler: The Wizard. But honestly? You don't need to see the first one to get punched in the gut by this one. It stands alone.
The story drops us into the 1980s. George Kosturos returns as Ali Jahani, a talented wrestler whose life is basically a series of impossible choices. His mother is sick back in Iran. He needs money. Fast. We’ve seen this setup a thousand times, right? "Fighter needs cash for family." It’s a trope because it’s a universal human anxiety. But director Shaun Paul Piccinino doesn't play it safe. He pivots the story from the clean, sanctioned world of high school wrestling into the jagged, blood-spattered underground of illegal fighting.
It's raw.
The Reality of the Underground Circuit in American Fighter
Most people watching American Fighter assume the underground fighting scenes are just Lionheart or Bloodsport clones. They aren't. Not exactly. While those 80s classics were about spectacle and roundhouse kicks, this movie focuses on the frantic, ugly nature of real violence.
Ali isn't a superhero. He’s a wrestler.
That distinction matters. In the film, he gets his clock cleaned because he tries to wrestle in a street fight. It's a hard lesson: knowing how to pin someone doesn't mean you know how to take a knuckle to the eye socket. The movie leans heavily into this transition. We see the technical struggle of an athlete trying to adapt his discipline to a world without referees. Tommy Flanagan (who you definitely recognize from Sons of Anarchy) plays McClellen, the crusty mentor type. Flanagan brings this exhausted, gravelly weight to the role that elevates the movie. He’s not Mr. Miyagi. He’s a guy who has seen too many kids get broken for a paycheck.
Bryan Craig also shows up as Byron, Ali’s friend who drags him into this mess. Their chemistry feels authentic. It’s that specific kind of young-adult friendship fueled by bravado and bad ideas. You know the type. The friend who thinks a "shortcut" to money is a good idea until someone starts bleeding.
Why the 1981 Setting Hits Different
Setting the movie in 1981 wasn't just a stylistic choice for the sake of synth music. It was a peak era for the "Iranian-American" tension. The hostage crisis was fresh. Xenophobia was rampant. Ali isn't just fighting for money; he’s fighting a culture that views him as the enemy the moment he speaks his name.
This adds a layer of "fight or flight" that most MMA movies lack. If Ali loses, he doesn't just lose a purse. He loses his chance to save his mother from a war-torn country. The stakes aren't just a trophy. They are life and death.
The production design does a lot of heavy lifting here. It’s not "neon" 80s. It’s "brown carpet and cigarette smoke" 80s. It feels lived-in. Grimy. It makes the transition from the sunny California wrestling mats to the dark, industrial fight pits feel like a descent into hell.
👉 See also: Why He'll Have to Go by Jim Reeves is Still the Greatest Heartbreak Song Ever Recorded
Breaking Down the Action: Wrestling vs. Striking
If you’re a fan of combat sports, you’ll appreciate the choreography in American Fighter. Usually, movies make every protagonist a master of all trades. Here, Ali is fundamentally a wrestler.
- He struggles with distance management.
- He forgets to protect his chin.
- He defaults to the double-leg takedown when he's panicked.
This realism is refreshing. There is a specific fight midway through the film where Ali faces a much larger striker. In a typical action flick, Ali would do some fancy flip. In this movie, he gets hit. A lot. He wins because of his wrestling cardio and his ability to endure pain, not because he suddenly learns how to box like Mike Tyson.
The stunt work, led by some very capable performers, keeps the camera close. You feel the impact. It's more Warrior than Cobra Kai.
The "Wizard" Connection
Since this is a prequel, it bridges the gap of how Ali Jahani became the man we saw in the first film. But interestingly, the tone is significantly darker. The Wizard was an inspirational sports drama. American Fighter is a grit-and-grind action thriller. It’s a bold move to change genres within a franchise, but it works because the character remains consistent. Ali is still the same guy—stubborn, loyal, and perhaps a bit too brave for his own good.
It’s worth noting that Ali Afshar, who produced the film and has a role in it, based much of this universe on his own life. Afshar was a real-life champion wrestler who came to the U.S. during the revolution. That’s why the emotional beats feel earned. It’s not manufactured drama; it’s a dramatized version of a very real immigrant struggle.
Technical Merits and Cinematic Flaws
Look, it’s not The Godfather. Let's be real. There are moments where the budget shows. Some of the secondary characters feel a bit thin, and the "bad guys" in the underground ring can sometimes veer into mustache-twirling territory.
But does it matter? Not really.
The movie succeeds because of its heart. George Kosturos puts in a physical performance that makes you hurt for him. You see the sweat. You see the actual bruising. The lighting in the fight scenes uses shadows to hide the smaller budget, creating a claustrophobic atmosphere that actually helps the narrative. It feels private. It feels like something you shouldn't be watching.
The pacing is also surprisingly tight. It clocks in at just under 100 minutes. No bloat. It gets in, tells the story, breaks a few ribs, and gets out. In an era where every movie is three hours long, that's a blessing.
Real Talk on the Ending
Without spoiling the specifics, the resolution of American Fighter doesn't give you a perfect Hollywood bow. It acknowledges that even when you win, you lose something. That’s the reality of the life Ali chose. The money comes at a cost, and the trauma of the underground circuit stays with you.
It's a bittersweet ending that respects the audience's intelligence. It understands that you can't just go back to being a normal college kid after you've been paid to beat people unconscious in a warehouse.
✨ Don't miss: Cast of House of Cards Season 1: The Dark Genius Behind the Shakespearian Drama
How to Get the Most Out of Your Rewatch
If you're planning to sit down with American Fighter, keep an eye on the background details of the 1980s setting. The news broadcasts and posters aren't just fluff; they build the pressure cooker Ali is living in.
- Watch for the transition: Pay attention to how Ali's stance changes from the beginning of the movie to the final fight. It’s a subtle bit of acting by Kosturos.
- The Soundtrack: It’s punchy. It drives the training montages without being overly cheesy.
- Tommy Flanagan's Face: Honestly, just watch his reactions. He says more with a squint than most actors do with a monologue.
For those looking for a gritty, mid-budget action movie that actually cares about its characters, this is a solid pick. It’s a reminder that sometimes the best stories aren't the ones with $200 million budgets, but the ones with something to prove.
Next Steps for the Viewer:
Check the credits—Ali Afshar’s real-life wrestling photos often pop up in these films, providing a direct link to the reality that inspired the script. If you haven't seen American Wrestler: The Wizard, go back and watch it after this. Seeing the "future" version of Ali makes the stakes in this prequel feel even heavier. Finally, look into the history of the 1981 California wrestling scene; the movie captures that specific subculture with surprising accuracy for a fictionalized drama.