If you watch the evening news, you'd think every city in the country is a war zone. It's a scary thought. But the reality of American cities with highest murders is actually a bit more complicated than just a scary headline. Honestly, the numbers for 2025 and the start of 2026 are showing us something we didn't quite expect: a massive, nationwide cooldown.
The "murder capital" label is a heavy one. It sticks to a city like glue, affecting everything from property values to where people decide to grab dinner on a Friday night. But when we look at the raw data from the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) and the mid-year updates from the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ), the list of the deadliest spots isn't always what people think.
The Cities Leading the Grim Statistics
When people talk about the "highest murders," they usually mean the murder rate—the number of killings per 100,000 residents. This is how a smaller city like St. Louis can "beat" a massive city like New York or Los Angeles in the rankings.
🔗 Read more: Why the Downfall of the Soviet Union Happened the Way it Did
As of the most recent 2025 year-end summaries and early 2026 trends, St. Louis, Missouri continues to sit at the top of this tragic list. The city has seen a rate hovering around 69.4 per 100,000 people. That's a staggering number. However, even there, the total count has been dropping. It's a weird paradox. The city is getting safer, but it's still technically the most dangerous on paper.
Baltimore, Maryland follows closely behind. For years, Baltimore has struggled with a rate exceeding 50 per 100,000. Local experts like those at Johns Hopkins University often point to a "perfect storm" of police staffing shortages and entrenched gang activity in specific neighborhoods. If you're in the Harbor East or Fells Point, you feel perfectly safe. Go a few blocks west, and it’s a different world.
A Look at the Top Ten Rates
- St. Louis, MO: Still the outlier with the highest per-capita rate.
- Baltimore, MD: Significant drops recently, but still in the top tier.
- New Orleans, LA: Nightlife-related violence in the French Quarter has kept their numbers high.
- Detroit, MI: Interestingly, Detroit just hit its lowest homicide count in decades, but its shrinking population keeps the rate high.
- Memphis, TN: A city that has struggled with a spike in "interpersonal" violence—mostly arguments turning deadly.
- Cleveland, OH: High rates of gun violence in specific wards.
- Kansas City, MO: Often overlooked, but consistently in the top ten.
- Newark, NJ: Actually a success story lately, though still high on the list.
- Chicago, IL: The city everyone talks about. While it has the highest total number of murders, its massive population puts its rate at #10.
- Philadelphia, PA: Struggling with "transit hub" violence and retail-related shootings.
Why Some American Cities With Highest Murders are Actually Getting Safer
You've probably heard the term "post-pandemic surge." Between 2020 and 2022, murders in the U.S. went through the roof. It was terrifying. But 2024 and 2025 saw what many criminologists are calling the "Great Reset."
According to the Council on Criminal Justice, homicides in major study cities fell by about 16% in 2024, and that trend accelerated into 2025 with an additional 17% drop in the first half of the year. This is basically the largest single-year decline in American history. It's huge.
Take Baltimore as an example. While it’s still on the "highest murders" list, it recently saw a massive 56% decrease in homicides compared to its 2019 peak. That’s hundreds of lives saved. Similarly, Detroit recorded its lowest murder count since the 1960s. Why? Most experts point to a return to "proactive policing" and community violence intervention programs that finally got their funding after the pandemic chaos settled.
The Disconnect Between Total Murders and Murder Rates
This is where people get confused. If you ask a random person which city has the most murders, they’ll almost always say "Chicago."
✨ Don't miss: The Robin Westman Suicide Note: Why This Specific Story Keeps Surfacing
They’re right, but also wrong.
In 2024, Chicago recorded over 500 homicides. That’s a lot of people. It’s more than St. Louis and Baltimore combined. But Chicago has 2.7 million people. St. Louis has less than 300,000. When you do the math, a resident in St. Louis is statistically much more likely to be a victim of a violent crime than someone in Chicago.
Sorta makes you think about how we use these "top ten" lists, doesn't it? If we ranked by total numbers, the list would just be "The Ten Biggest Cities in America." That doesn't tell us much about actual safety.
Surprising Trends in 2026
- Washington, D.C. is an outlier. While most cities saw murders drop in 2025, D.C. actually saw a 36% increase early in the year. It’s one of the few places where the trend is going the wrong way.
- Oakland, CA has been a rollercoaster. It saw a 32% drop in 2024, but then a slight 15% bump in early 2025. It’s a city on the edge.
- Little Rock, AR and Virginia Beach, VA saw some of the highest percentage increases recently. Because their populations are smaller, a few bad weekends can send their rankings skyrocketing.
Is Poverty the Only Factor?
It’s easy to just say "poor cities have more crime." And yeah, Detroit and Memphis have poverty rates near 34%, which is way above the national average. When people are struggling to survive, crime often becomes a means of survival or a result of total social breakdown.
But it’s not just money.
👉 See also: Ridgeland SC Mugshots Last 72 Hours: What Most People Get Wrong
It's "concentrated disadvantage." This is a term used by researchers like Robert Sampson at Harvard. It means it's not just about being poor; it's about being poor in a neighborhood with no grocery stores, no jobs, underfunded schools, and a high number of vacant lots. In St. Louis, much of the violence is concentrated in the Northside—a place that has dealt with systemic disinvestment for fifty years. You can't fix that with just more police cars.
What This Means for You
If you're looking at these American cities with highest murders because you're planning a move or a trip, don't panic. Even in the "deadliest" cities, crime is hyper-local.
A study by the National Institute of Justice found that in most cities, about 50% of the violent crime happens on just 5% of the street blocks. Basically, if you stay out of specific, well-known "hot zones," your risk is almost zero.
Actionable Steps for Staying Informed
- Check Neighborhood Maps, Not City Stats: Use tools like NeighborhoodScout or local police "heat maps" to see exactly where incidents are happening.
- Follow the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ): They release quarterly "Crime Trends" reports that are way more up-to-date than the official FBI data, which usually lags by a year.
- Look for Trends, Not Totals: A city with 100 murders that is down from 200 is much safer than a city with 50 murders that is up from 10.
- Support Community Intervention: If you live in one of these cities, look into groups like "Cure Violence" or "Advance Peace." These are the folks on the ground actually lowering the numbers by mediating beefs before they turn into shootings.
The reality of crime in America in 2026 is that things are getting better, even if the "murder capital" rankings take a while to catch up. We’re seeing a historic shift back toward safety, but for the families in places like St. Louis and Baltimore, the numbers are still far too high. Understanding the difference between a "scary headline" and "actual risk" is the first step in having a real conversation about public safety.