Look in your couch cushions. Check the cup holder in your car. Odds are, you’ll find a small, copper-plated zinc disc that’s basically useless. It’s the penny. Honestly, it’s a bit of a joke at this point. We’ve reached a stage where America must free itself from the tyranny of the penny not just because it’s annoying, but because it is actively draining the economy for no reason other than nostalgia.
Think about it. You can't buy anything with a single penny. Not a piece of gum. Not a stamp. Even the "penny candy" of the 1950s is long gone.
The U.S. Mint is currently stuck in a cycle of insanity. According to the 2023 Annual Report from the United States Mint, it now costs roughly 3.07 cents to produce a single one-cent coin. We are literally paying three cents to make one cent. If a private business operated like this, it would be bankrupt in a week. Yet, the government continues to churn out billions of these little metal circles every year, only for them to end up in jars or literal trash cans. It’s a fiscal facepalm.
The Math of a Failed Currency
The math just doesn't work. It hasn't worked for a long time.
In 2023 alone, the Mint shipped out about 4.5 billion pennies. When you factor in the cost of metal—mostly zinc with a thin copper coating—and the labor, electricity, and shipping involved, the "seigniorage" (the profit or loss a government makes on issuing currency) is deep in the red. We’re losing tens of millions of dollars annually just to keep the penny on life support.
Some people worry about "rounding." They think if we ditch the penny, businesses will round every price up to the nearest nickel and "steal" their hard-earned money. But that's not how it works in countries that have already taken the plunge. Canada killed their penny in 2013. Australia did it in 1992. New Zealand? They even got rid of the nickel back in 2006. In these places, if your total is $10.02, it rounds down to $10.00. If it’s $10.03, it rounds up to $10.05. It’s a wash. It balances out perfectly over time.
Besides, rounding only applies to cash transactions. If you’re paying with a credit card, debit card, or Apple Pay, the transaction stays at the exact cent. Since we’re moving toward a cashless society anyway, the "rounding tax" argument is basically a ghost story.
✨ Don't miss: Jerry Jones 19.2 Billion Net Worth: Why Everyone is Getting the Math Wrong
Why We’re Stuck in the Past
Why is this still happening? If it’s so obvious that the penny is a loser, why do we keep it?
Politics, mostly.
There’s a massive lobbying effort behind that little coin. The Zinc Lobby, specifically companies like Jarden Zinc Products (which sells the blanks to the Mint), spends significant money to keep the penny in production. They frame it as a "pro-consumer" issue, but let’s be real: they just want to keep selling zinc.
Then there’s the Lincoln factor. Abraham Lincoln is a national hero. He’s the man who saved the Union. Some people feel that removing the penny is somehow an insult to his legacy. But Lincoln is already on the $5 bill. He’s doing fine. He doesn’t need to be immortalized on a coin that people literally throw away because it’s not worth the weight in their pockets.
The Opportunity Cost of Your Time
Let’s talk about time. Time is the one thing you can't get back.
Have you ever stood in line at a grocery store behind someone digging through a change purse for two cents? It’s agonizing. Robert Whaples, an economics professor at Wake Forest University, has actually done the math on this. He estimated that the time wasted by individuals and cashiers handling pennies adds up to hundreds of millions of dollars in lost productivity every year.
🔗 Read more: Missouri Paycheck Tax Calculator: What Most People Get Wrong
If it takes you two seconds to handle a penny, and you do that a few times a day, you are effectively working for less than federal minimum wage just to move that copper around. It’s an efficiency nightmare.
When we say America must free itself from the tyranny of the penny, we aren’t just talking about the cost of the metal. We’re talking about the friction it adds to every single physical transaction in the country. It slows down lines, it complicates accounting, and it forces banks to spend money transporting heavy bags of worthless metal.
The Charity Argument
Charities often argue that the penny is vital for "penny drives." You’ve seen the jars at the checkout counter for St. Jude’s or local schools.
While it's true that pennies add up, they are a nightmare for the charities to process. They have to be collected, hauled to a bank (which is heavy and expensive), and counted. Most modern non-profits would much rather have you "round up" your digital transaction or drop a nickel or dime in the bucket. A nickel is worth five pennies but weighs much less than five times a penny. It’s just better logistics.
Even the military has figured this out. On U.S. overseas military bases, pennies haven't been used for years. They use a rounding system because shipping heavy crates of pennies across the ocean is a logistical absurdity. If the Department of Defense can manage without the penny, the rest of us probably can too.
What Actually Happens After the Penny Dies?
So, imagine a world where the penny is gone. What changes?
💡 You might also like: Why Amazon Stock is Down Today: What Most People Get Wrong
Honestly? Not much. Your life might actually get a little easier.
- Prices stay the same: Gas is still $3.49. That shirt is still $19.99.
- The "Total" changes at the register: If you pay cash for that $19.99 shirt and tax brings it to $21.32, you just pay $21.30.
- Pockets get lighter: No more jingling like a medieval peasant.
- The Mint saves money: That $90+ million loss per year suddenly disappears.
We’ve done this before. In 1857, the U.S. got rid of the half-cent. At the time, the half-cent had more purchasing power than the modern penny does today. People survived. The economy didn't collapse. We just moved on to more efficient ways of trading value.
The penny has become a "zombie currency." It’s dead, but it’s still walking among us, eating our tax dollars and clogging up our drawers.
Real-World Steps Toward De-Pennification
If you're tired of the clutter and the waste, you don't have to wait for an Act of Congress to start moving away from the penny.
- Go Digital: The easiest way to ignore the penny is to use digital payments. Apps and cards don't care about rounding; they handle the exact math perfectly.
- The Jar Method: If you do end up with pennies, don't let them sit forever. Use a Coinstar or take them to a credit union that has a free coin counter. Turning that "dead" money into a digital balance or a gift card puts that capital back into the economy.
- Support the Coinage Reform Act: Every few years, legislation is introduced to suspend the production of the penny. While it usually stalls in committee due to the aforementioned lobbying, staying informed and letting your representatives know you support a more efficient currency system is the only way the "tyranny" actually ends.
- Donate Wisely: If you want to help a charity, give them a dollar. It’s worth 100 times more than a penny and costs them significantly less to deposit.
The reality is that America must free itself from the tyranny of the penny to align our physical currency with 21st-century economics. The coin served us well for a long time, but its era has passed. It's time to stop paying three cents for a one-cent souvenir and start focusing on a currency that actually makes sense for the way we live now.
Actionable Insights for the "Post-Penny" Mindset
- Audit your change: Gather every penny in your house this weekend. You’ll likely find $5 to $10 hidden in jars and drawers.
- Stop the flow: At registers, tell the cashier to "keep the change" if it's just pennies. It saves you the pocket space and saves them the hassle.
- Advocate for rounding: If you own a small business, consider rounding cash transactions to the nearest nickel voluntarily. Many coffee shops already do this to speed up service during the morning rush.
- Think in nickels: Start mentally adjusting to a 5-cent increment. It simplifies your personal accounting and prepares you for the inevitable day the penny finally disappears.