We have a massive problem. It’s quiet. It’s embarrassing. Honestly, it’s a bit terrifying once you look at the actual numbers. You’ve probably noticed it in small ways—emails that don't make sense, people struggling to follow basic written instructions, or the way nuance seems to die a quick death on social media. But the reality is much grimmer than just "kids these days don't read." The truth is that America is sliding toward illiteracy, and it isn’t just a school problem. It’s an everything problem.
According to the U.S. Department of Education and the National Institute of Literacy, a staggering 21% of adults in the United States fall into the "illiterate" or "low literacy" category. Think about that for a second. One in five adults. These aren't just people who "don't like books." These are people who literally cannot read a prescription bottle or fill out a job application. We’re talking about 45 million people.
It's not just the bottom of the curve either. The "sliding" part refers to the middle. We are losing our collective ability to process complex information. We are becoming a nation of "functional illiterates"—people who can decode the words on a page but can't tell you what they actually mean.
The Proficiency Gap and the Death of Deep Reading
If you look at the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), often called "The Nation’s Report Card," the data is pretty bleak. Reading scores for 13-year-olds have seen their largest drop in decades. This isn't just a "post-pandemic" blip. The decline started way before 2020.
Reading isn't just a hobby. It's a cognitive workout. Maryanne Wolf, a developmental psychologist and author of Proust and the Squid, argues that the human brain wasn't actually "wired" to read. We had to hijack other parts of our brain to do it. When we stop deep reading—the kind that requires sustained focus on a physical page—those neural pathways actually start to weaken. We’re losing the "reading brain" in real-time.
Basically, we’ve swapped depth for speed.
We skim. We scroll. We look for keywords. We want the TL;DR. This isn't just laziness; it's a fundamental shift in how our brains process language. When America is sliding toward illiteracy, it looks like a population that can read a 280-character post but gets a headache trying to get through a three-page contract or a long-form essay.
What the numbers actually say
The Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC) breaks literacy down into levels. Level 1 is the basement. People at this level can read brief texts on familiar topics but struggle to evaluate information or draw even simple inferences. In the U.S., a huge chunk of the population is stuck right there.
There's a massive economic cost to this. Low literacy is estimated to cost the U.S. economy $2.2 trillion annually. Why? Because if you can't read well, you can't work well. You can't innovate. You can't even stay healthy because you can't follow medical advice or understand health insurance documents. It’s a cycle that traps families in poverty for generations.
🔗 Read more: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
Why America is Sliding Toward Illiteracy Right Now
So, how did we get here? It's easy to blame TikTok. It's easy to blame the "screens." And yeah, they play a role. But the rot goes deeper into the way we teach kids to read.
For decades, a method called "Balanced Literacy" dominated American classrooms. It sounded great. It promised to make kids love books. The problem? It didn't actually teach them how to decode words. Instead of phonics—learning how sounds correspond to letters—kids were taught to "guess" words based on context or pictures.
- "Three-cueing."
- "Whole language."
- "Look-say."
These methods failed millions. Journalist Emily Hanford’s "Sold a Story" podcast blew the lid off this. She documented how we ignored the "Science of Reading" for a more "vibes-based" approach. We basically told kids to be detectives instead of readers. When the pictures go away in middle school, these kids hit a wall. Hard.
They can't read the history textbook. They can't read the science manual. They give up.
The Screen vs. The Page
There is also the "bi-literate" brain problem. When we read on a screen, we are in "distraction mode." There are ads, links, and notifications. Our eyes move in an "F" pattern, scanning for the main point and ignoring the rest. Over time, this makes reading a physical book feel like a chore. It feels "too slow."
But the "slow" part is where the thinking happens.
If you aren't reading deeply, you aren't thinking deeply. You're just reacting to stimuli. This is why political discourse has become so fractured. If you can’t parse a complex argument, you’re more likely to fall for a snappy slogan or a misleading headline. Illiteracy is a threat to democracy. Period.
The Literacy-Poverty Connection
There is no way to talk about this without talking about class. In the U.S., literacy is a luxury.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
Wealthy parents can pay for tutors if their kid isn't getting phonics at school. They have houses full of books. They have the "word gap"—the idea that kids from professional families hear 30 million more words by age three than kids from low-income families. That gap never really closes. It just widens.
The "school-to-prison pipeline" is often just a "literacy-to-prison pipeline." Did you know that some states have used third-grade reading scores to help predict how many prison beds they’ll need in the future? It’s a gut-punch of a statistic. If a child isn't reading proficiently by the end of third grade, they are four times more likely to drop out of high school.
A Literacy Crisis in the Workplace
It’s not just "blue collar" jobs. We are seeing a "literacy tax" in corporate America. Managers spend hours rewriting emails for their staff. Human Resources departments struggle to find candidates who can write a coherent memo.
I talked to a hiring manager recently who said they stopped looking at resumes and started doing "in-person writing tests" because so many applicants were using AI to mask the fact that they couldn't string a sentence together. AI might be a tool, but it’s also becoming a crutch for a population that’s losing its grip on language.
If you can't express yourself, you are invisible. You are easily manipulated. You have no voice.
Is There a Way Back?
It’s not all doom. There’s a massive movement right now to bring the "Science of Reading" back into schools. States like Mississippi—long at the bottom of literacy rankings—have seen "miraculous" improvements by mandating phonics-based instruction. They call it the "Mississippi Miracle."
It wasn't a miracle. It was just teaching kids how to actually read.
But we can't just wait for the schools to fix it. This is a cultural shift. We have to value "boredom." We have to value the long-form. We have to realize that America is sliding toward illiteracy because we’ve stopped prioritizing the intellectual stamina required to be a literate society.
📖 Related: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
The "Aliteracy" Problem
There's a difference between "illiteracy" (can't read) and "aliteracy" (can read but chooses not to). Aliteracy is the silent killer. When educated people stop reading books, the quality of public discourse drops. We lose our shared vocabulary. We lose empathy, because fiction is one of the few ways we truly "step into" someone else’s life.
When we stop reading, we start losing the ability to imagine a different world.
Actionable Steps to Combat the Decline
We can't change the national statistics overnight, but we can change the trajectory of our own lives and communities. It starts with small, deliberate choices to reclaim our attention and our language.
Audit Your "Deep Reading" Time
Check your screen time. If you’re spending four hours a day on "micro-content" (TikTok, Reels, X), your brain is being trained for short-term hits. Try to dedicate at least 20 minutes a day to a physical book or a long-form article on paper. No notifications. No tabs. Just the text.
Advocate for Phonics in Your District
If you have kids, or even if you don't, look at how your local schools are teaching reading. Ask if they use "Structured Literacy" or "Balanced Literacy." If it’s the latter, point them toward the research from the National Reading Panel. Support your local library. They are the front lines in this war.
Model Literacy
Kids don't do what you say; they do what you do. If they see you reading a book, they are exponentially more likely to pick one up themselves. Read aloud to them long after they "know how" to read. It builds vocabulary and shows them that stories have value beyond a screen.
Practice Writing Without Assistance
Try writing your next few emails or reports without using AI or even auto-complete. It will be harder. You’ll struggle for the right word. That struggle is the point. That’s your brain building its muscles back up.
Support Local Journalism
The decline of local newspapers has played a huge role in the slide toward illiteracy. Local news provides a common set of facts and a reason to read about things that affect your immediate life. When the paper dies, the community's literacy often follows.
The slide isn't inevitable. It’s a choice. Every time we choose a book over a scroll, or a deep conversation over a soundbite, we’re pushing back against the tide. We have to decide if we want to be a nation of thinkers or a nation of reactors. The clock is ticking.