Winning Love Island USA is supposed to be the start of a fairytale. For Amaya Espinal and Bryan Arenales, it felt like exactly that. They were the first Latino couple to take the crown, walking away with the $100,000 prize and the "America's Sweetheart" title firmly in Amaya’s pocket.
Then the cameras stopped.
Honestly, the fallout was faster than anyone expected. If you’ve followed the "Amaya Papaya" journey from the Fiji villa to the concrete jungle of New York, you know things got messy. Fast.
The Whirlwind Romance That Conquered Fiji
Amaya didn't have it easy in the villa. Early on, she was the girl everyone seemed to have an opinion on. People called her "too much." They criticized her for being verbally affectionate—using words like mi amor and babe—and it actually brought her to tears.
Then came Bryan.
He wasn't an OG. He was a Casa Amor bombshell who did something the other guys wouldn't: he stood up for her. When Austin, Zak, and Ace were busy telling Amaya to "tone it down," Bryan basically told them to pipe down. He understood the culture. He understood her.
They were a powerhouse. Fans loved them because they felt real. They weren't just playing for the cameras; they were two people who actually seemed to see each other. By the time the finale rolled around on July 13, 2025, there was almost no doubt they’d win. They split the money. They promised to prioritize each other.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
Why Amaya and Bryan Love Island Fans Were Blindside
The honeymoon phase didn't even last through the summer.
By late August, the vibes shifted. Hard. Fans noticed the "unfollow" before any official statement was made. It’s the modern-day death knell for any reality TV couple. If you aren't following each other on Instagram, you aren't eating dinner together.
On August 27, 2025—just two days after the reunion aired—Amaya dropped the bombshell on her Instagram story.
"My papayas - Bryan and I are no longer together. After leaving the villa, it became very clear that we were on two different journeys. Our visions didn't align and relationships are supposed to be a team sport."
She added one of her signature "Amaya-isms" that went viral instantly: "You don't have to drink the whole sea to know it's salty."
The Miami Incident
What actually happened? While the official statements cited "different paths," the TikTok receipts told a different story.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Shortly after the breakup, Amaya was spotted in the comments of a TikTok video. The video allegedly showed Bryan at a club in Miami, flirting with other women. Amaya’s comment was heartbreakingly blunt. She mentioned being broken up with, only to see him in Miami two hours later doing the exact things she told him hurt her feelings.
Bryan’s side was more curated. He posted his own statement about being on "different pages" and "gaining clarity." He thanked her for the time. It was very public relations-friendly. Very safe.
The Reunion Illusion
Watching the Season 7 reunion was a trip. If you saw it, you remember them sitting together, smiling, and defending their relationship against cheating rumors.
Bryan admitted to some "lapse in judgment" at a club hosting gig but insisted nothing happened. Amaya stood by him. She told Andy Cohen, "If I’m with him... it’s because the relationship dynamic is healthy and great."
The problem? The reunion was taped on August 12.
In the two weeks between the taping and the air date, the wheels completely fell off. It’s a classic reality TV trap. You have to keep up appearances for the contract, but real life doesn’t wait for the edit.
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Where Are They Now?
It’s 2026, and the dust has mostly settled. Amaya has leaned heavily into her "Papaya" fanbase. She’s transitioned from being a cardiac nurse to a full-blown media personality and model, often seen at major fashion events and beauty campaigns in L.A. and New York.
Bryan has largely stayed in the fitness and hosting space.
They don't talk.
The $100,000 is long gone—likely split and invested—but the lesson remains. The villa is a vacuum. You don't have bills, you don't have clubs, and you don't have 1.8 million people watching your every move on a Saturday night in Miami.
Lessons from the Split
If you're looking for the "why," it basically boils down to the transition from the "bubble" to the "real world."
- Cultural alignment isn't everything. They shared a heritage, but they didn't share a lifestyle once the Fiji sun set.
- The "Edit" is powerful. We saw the hero arc for Bryan because he defended Amaya, but the post-show behavior suggests he wasn't ready for the "team sport" Amaya needed.
- Trust the "Unfollow." In the world of Love Island, the social media metrics are usually more accurate than the televised interviews.
If you’re still mourning the end of this couple, keep an eye on Amaya’s TikTok. She’s been much more transparent about her healing process than most winners. She’s focused on her career and hasn't jumped back into a public relationship yet. As for Bryan, he’s still doing the club circuit, seemingly enjoying the single life that the Miami rumors first hinted at.
For those tracking other Season 7 couples, keep in mind that Nic and Olandria are the ones to watch for longevity. They didn't have the "winning" drama, but they've stayed remarkably quiet and consistent—the polar opposite of the Amaya and Bryan explosion.
To stay updated on Amaya's current projects, follow her verified Instagram handle, as she frequently posts behind-the-scenes content from her modeling shoots and brand partnerships that have flourished post-win.