You’re wandering through the tiny hamlet of Wysoka, southwest of Kuttenberg, and some guy named Pavel asks you to basically dismantle the local economy. It sounds like a standard thievery quest. You need to steal a book, a rosary, some shoes, and—the real kicker—a gold medal lost in a bird's nest.
Honestly, the Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 "All's Fair" quest is where most players realize Warhorse Studios hasn't lost their touch for making quests that are equal parts brilliant and incredibly annoying. If you’re stuck looking at the treetops of Wysoka and wondering where the hell that magpie went, you aren't alone.
The Magpie Nest: It's Not Where You Think
Most quests in modern RPGs give you a golden breadcrumb trail or a glowing icon. KCD2 doesn't do that. For the "All's Fair" nest objective, Pavel tells you a magpie swiped Older Vejmola’s gold St. Francis medal. He points you toward a general area, but magpie nests are everywhere in this village.
Here is the thing: you can actually find it by listening.
If you have a decent pair of headphones, walk through the yard of the large residence in the southeast part of town—the one where Bohushka (the lady obsessed with poppy seed cakes) lives. In the eastern part of her garden, there is a large tree. If you stand near it, you’ll hear the distinct, chatter-like call of a Eurasian magpie. It’s a level of detail that is honestly ridiculous.
How to Get the Medal Down
Don't bother trying to climb. This isn't Assassin's Creed. You have a few options to get that nest to drop:
- The Archer's Way: Use a bow and arrow. It takes a bit of precision, but one hit knocks it loose.
- The Peasant's Way: Crouch down and look for the prompt to throw a rock or "shrapnel." It’s cheaper than wasting a good arrow.
Once the nest hits the dirt, search it. You’ll find the medallion tucked inside. It’s one of the five items Pavel needs, but it’s the only one that doesn't involve breaking and entering—sorta.
Stealing Everything Else Without Getting Hanged
The rest of the items in the kcd2 All's Fair nest questline require some actual stealth. If your Henry is currently wearing full plate armor and clanking like a kitchen drawer, go change. You need to be quiet.
The Poppy Seed Cake Mystery
Bohushka’s ring is the most "KCD" objective in the game. You’ll hear her sleep-talking about losing it in the dough. You won't find it in a chest. You won't find it on her person. Basically, you have to steal the Poppy Seed Kolach (pastries) sitting in her kitchen and actually eat them from your inventory. Henry will "find" the ring mid-chew. Just hope he doesn't chip a tooth.
💡 You might also like: Astroneer Data Circuit Model A: What You Actually Do With This Thing
The Priest and the Cobbler
Father Anthony’s alchemy book is a cakewalk. It’s in his house on the north side of town, sitting right on a writing desk. The cobbler’s shoes are a bit trickier because they are physically small and tucked in a dark corner near a chest in his bedroom. Since Pavel gives you the house key, you can just walk in, but wait until night so you don't get yelled at for trespassing.
Ursula’s Ma’s Rosary
This one is the toughest "pick" of the lot. You can find her at the graveyard during the day, but the rosary is usually in a chest at night. That chest has a "Very Hard" lock. If your lockpicking skill is garbage, your best bet is to pickpocket the key off the old lady while she’s sleeping. You usually get a generous 15-20 second window to rummage through her pockets.
The Big Twist: Pavel Isn't Who He Says
Once you have all five items, you face the real "moral" part of the quest. If you talk to Ursula before finishing, you’ll learn that Pavel’s story about "ruining a rival" to win her heart is mostly a lie. He’s actually planning to sell the loot and run away to Kuttenberg to start an apprenticeship. He’s using you as a professional shoplifter.
Choosing Your Ending
You have three real ways to end this:
- Give him the loot: This is the "criminal" path. You get Vitality XP and Pavel heads to Kuttenberg. A few days later, a new activity called "Seeking Justice" will pop up, where you eventually have to deal with the fallout of your crimes.
- Give him 1,000 Groschen: If you’re rich and feeling merciful, you can just pay for his apprenticeship. This keeps his (and your) reputation clean. He still leaves, but he’s not a wanted man.
- Return the items: You can snub Pavel and take the items back to their owners or Father Anthony. You’ll get a massive reputation boost in Wysoka, which is helpful if you plan on hanging around the region.
Actionable Tips for the All's Fair Quest
If you’re about to dive into this, keep these specific points in mind to save yourself a headache.
First, save before you eat the cakes. There’s a rare bug where the ring might not trigger if you eat the wrong pastry first; make sure you’re eating the "Poppy Seed Kolach" specifically. Second, use the "Wait" mechanic to jump to 1:00 AM for the thievery segments. Most NPCs in Wysoka have very predictable sleep schedules, but Father Anthony stays up late.
Finally, if you’re struggling with the magpie nest location, look for the tree that has a visible clump of twigs near the top—it’s the only one in that specific garden that you can actually interact with. Once you finish this, keep an eye on the town's gossip. The things you do in this quest actually ripple out into the world, especially if you chose to help Pavel steal everything.
📖 Related: World of Warcraft: Knives in the Dark and the Problem With Rogue Class Identity
Check your inventory for any "Quest Items" you might have forgotten to hand over; sometimes players keep the medal by accident and wonder why the quest won't progress. Handing over the full set is the only way to trigger the Vitality XP reward.