You think you know Metallica. You’ve heard "Enter Sandman" at every sporting event since 1991. You’ve probably hummed the "Nothing Else Matters" melody while staring out a rainy window. But when you look at the sheer volume of all songs from Metallica, you realize the radio hits are just the tip of a very heavy, very jagged iceberg.
People argue about them constantly. It’s basically a full-time job for metalheads. One guy says everything after 1988 is garbage; another swears 72 Seasons is a masterpiece. Honestly, the truth is way more nuanced.
✨ Don't miss: Why Omen III: The Final Conflict is Actually Better Than You Remember
The band has released over 100 original songs across 11 studio albums, not to mention the covers, the live-only rarities, and that weird collaboration with Lou Reed that we all collectively agreed to stop talking about.
The Early Days: Pure Speed and "Kill 'Em All"
In 1983, nobody was doing what Metallica was doing. Well, maybe Slayer, but Metallica had this weird melodic sensibility even when they were trying to rip your head off. "Hit the Lights" was the opening shot. It’s messy. It’s fast. It’s exactly what four kids fueled by cheap beer and Diamond Head records should sound like.
Then you’ve got "Seek & Destroy." If you haven't screamed "Searching... seek and destroy!" in a crowded room, have you even lived? It’s a staple. Even now, decades later, it remains one of their most-played songs live, usually closing out the night.
Why "Ride the Lightning" Changed Everything
If the first album was just about speed, the second was about atmosphere. This is where the all songs from Metallica conversation gets interesting. They wrote a ballad. People lost their minds.
"Fade to Black" was basically heresy in 1984. "A thrash band with acoustic guitars? They sold out!"
Yeah, right.
It’s one of the most honest songs about depression ever recorded. Then you have "For Whom the Bell Tolls." That opening bass line from Cliff Burton? Iconic. It’s not even a guitar; it’s Cliff running a wah-wah pedal through a distortion box, making it sound like a bell from hell.
The Masterpiece and the Tragedy
Master of Puppets is usually cited as the peak. Every song is a 10/10. "Battery" starts with those beautiful Spanish-style guitars before turning into a literal assault. The title track, "Master of Puppets," is technically perfect. Down-picking only. If you try to alternate pick that main riff, James Hetfield will personally manifest in your room and judge you.
But then Cliff died.
The band's trajectory shifted. They released ...And Justice for All in 1988. It’s cold. It’s progressive. It has almost no bass. Seriously, you can’t hear Jason Newsted at all. But songs like "One" proved they could handle complex storytelling and odd time signatures without losing the "heavy."
The Black Album: When Metallica Became Global
This is the "Black Album" era. You know the songs.
- "Enter Sandman"
- "The Unforgiven"
- "Sad But True"
- "Wherever I May Roam"
They stopped writing eight-minute epics and started writing four-minute punches to the gut. Bob Rock, the producer, basically stripped everything down. It worked. It became one of the best-selling albums of all time. But for the hardcore thrash fans, it was the beginning of the end.
The "Loads" and the Great Identity Crisis
The mid-90s were weird. The band cut their hair. They wore eyeliner. They recorded Load and Reload. Honestly? Some of the best all songs from Metallica are hidden here.
"The Outlaw Torn" is an absolute journey. "Bleeding Me" shows a side of James’s vocals that we hadn't seen—vulnerable and bluesy. Sure, "Fuel" is a bit "commercial," but it rips. People hate on this era, but if another band had released these albums, they’d be considered classics.
The Snare Drum Heard 'Round the World
We have to talk about St. Anger.
The snare drum sounds like a trash can lid. There are no guitar solos. It’s 75 minutes of raw, unpolished aggression and therapy sessions. "Frantic" and "St. Anger" are... polarizing. But you have to respect the balls it took to release something that ugly after being the biggest band in the world.
🔗 Read more: Yellowjackets Season 3 Episode 3 Preview: Where the Wilderness Goes From Here
The Modern Era: 72 Seasons and Beyond
Lately, the band has settled into a groove. Death Magnetic brought back the solos. Hardwired... To Self-Destruct had "Moth Into Flame," which is a top-tier track.
And then there's the 2023 release, 72 Seasons. The title track is a 7-minute thrasher that feels like a throwback. "Inamorata," the album closer, is the longest song they’ve ever recorded—over 11 minutes. It’s a sludgy, Sabbath-inspired epic that proves they aren't just resting on their laurels.
Deep Cuts You Probably Missed
Everyone knows the hits, but the real meat is in the tracks they rarely play.
- "Fixxxer" (Reload): A haunting song about childhood trauma that they only played live once in 40 years.
- "The Frayed Ends of Sanity" (...And Justice for All): That Wizard of Oz chant at the beginning is creepy, and the middle section is a rhythmic nightmare for drummers.
- "Dyers Eve" (...And Justice for All): Probably the fastest song they’ve ever written. James is basically venting at his parents for 5 minutes of pure fury.
- "All Within My Hands" (St. Anger): The "S&M2" version with the symphony is actually beautiful. It completely reimagines a song that was originally unlistenable.
The Technical Reality of Their Songwriting
If you look at the credits for all songs from Metallica, it’s usually the Hetfield/Ulrich show. Kirk Hammett contributes the occasional legendary riff (like the one in "Sandman"), but James and Lars are the architects.
James provides the "crunch." He’s the greatest rhythm guitarist in metal history. Period. His right hand is a machine. Lars, despite the internet memes about his drumming, is the one who arranges the songs. He knows where the hooks go. He knows how to build tension.
They also have a massive catalog of covers. Garage Inc. is a masterclass in how to pay tribute to your influences. Their version of "Whiskey in the Jar" is more famous than the original Thin Lizzy version for a whole generation of fans. And "Am I Evil?"—originally by Diamond Head—is so synonymous with Metallica that people are shocked to find out they didn't write it.
Making Sense of the Catalog
When you're trying to digest the full discography, don't just stick to the "This Is Metallica" playlists on Spotify. You’ve gotta dig.
Go find the "Beyond Magnetic" EP. It has four tracks left over from the Death Magnetic sessions that are actually better than some of the songs that made the album. "Just a Bullet Away" has a riff that will get stuck in your head for a week.
Also, check out the live versions. Metallica is a live band first. Songs like "Creeping Death" only truly come alive when there are 50,000 people shouting "Die! Die! Die!" in the bridge.
Actionable Insights for the New (or Old) Fan
If you want to truly appreciate the depth of their work, try this:
- Listen to the Instrumentals: "Anesthesia (Pulling Teeth)," "The Call of Ktulu," "Orion," and "To Live Is To Die." They tell stories without saying a word.
- Watch 'Some Kind of Monster': It’s a documentary, but it gives context to why the St. Anger songs sound the way they do. It makes the music better, strangely enough.
- Compare the Eras: Listen to "Metal Militia" (1983) and then "72 Seasons" (2023). It’s the same DNA, just evolved.
- Focus on the Lyrics: James shifted from singing about H.P. Lovecraft monsters to singing about his own internal demons. That transition is what kept the band relevant while their peers faded away.
The catalog is massive. It's intimidating. But whether it's the thrash of the 80s, the stadium rock of the 90s, or the experimental grit of the 2000s, there is a thread of authenticity that runs through every single track. They’ve never been afraid to fail, and that’s why they’re still the kings.