Honestly, if you try to memorize every single name in the line of succession, you're gonna have a bad time. It’s a lot. We are sitting here in 2026, and the list of all of the presidents has become this weird, living tapestry of American ego, brilliance, and some genuinely baffling decisions. Most people think they know the deal—Washington was the first, Lincoln saved the Union, and then there’s everyone else. But the reality? It’s way messier than your high school history teacher let on.
Did you know we've actually had 45 people serve, but the numbering says 47? Yeah, Grover Cleveland is the reason for the original headache because he served two non-consecutive terms (22nd and 24th). And now, Donald Trump has done the same thing, serving as the 45th and 47th. It’s a bit like a sports team bringing back an old coach for a second stint.
The Myth of the Perfect Founder
We tend to look back at the early guys like they were marble statues. They weren't. They were stressed out, often petty, and constantly worried the whole "American experiment" was about to implode. George Washington basically spent his entire eight years trying to keep Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson from strangling each other in the hallway.
John Adams, the second guy, was kinda grumpy and hated being in Washington's shadow. He once called the Vice Presidency "the most insignificant office that ever the invention of man contrived." Then you’ve got James Madison. He was tiny—about 5'4" and barely 100 pounds. You could’ve basically tucked the Father of the Constitution under your arm and walked away with him.
Why the "Middle" Presidents Get Ignored
There is this massive chunk of time between Andrew Jackson and Abraham Lincoln where the names start to blur. Millard Fillmore? Franklin Pierce? James Buchanan?
💡 You might also like: Passive Resistance Explained: Why It Is Way More Than Just Standing Still
These guys are usually the ones people skip. But Buchanan is actually a fascinating case study in what not to do. Most historians rank him as one of the absolute worst. Why? Because he basically sat on his hands while the country drifted toward the Civil War. He thought if he just ignored the problem of slavery and secession, it might go away. Spoilers: it didn’t.
The 20th Century Power Shift
Everything changed with Teddy Roosevelt. He was a force of nature. He boxed in the White House until he got hit so hard he went blind in one eye. He survived an assassination attempt by getting shot in the chest and then finishing his 90-minute speech before going to the hospital. He’s the reason the "Imperial Presidency" exists. He decided the president should be the center of American life, and honestly, we haven't looked back since.
Then you have FDR. He’s the only one who served more than two terms—four, to be exact. He led through the Depression and World War II, basically reinventing how the government interacts with your bank account and your daily life. After him, they passed the 22nd Amendment so nobody could stay that long again.
The Cold War Chaos
The late 20th century was just one long stress test. You’ve got:
📖 Related: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
- JFK, who was the first real "TV president."
- LBJ, who was terrifyingly tall and used to lean over people to intimidate them into voting for his bills.
- Nixon, who is the only one to ever resign.
- Gerald Ford, who was never actually elected to be VP or President (he was appointed).
It’s a wild run of personalities.
What Actually Makes a "Great" President?
If you ask a historian who the best is, they usually say Lincoln, Washington, or FDR. But if you ask the public, the answers change based on who is in power.
There’s a concept in political science called "E-E-A-T"—Expertise, Experience, Authoritativeness, and Trust. When we look at all of the presidents, we’re usually looking for someone who can handle a crisis. That’s why Lincoln is the GOAT (Greatest of All Time) for most. He didn't just win a war; he managed a team of rivals who all thought they were smarter than him.
But then there are the "quiet" successes. Calvin Coolidge was known as "Silent Cal." He once had a woman tell him she bet she could get more than two words out of him. He looked at her and said, "You lose." He presided over a massive economic boom by basically staying out of the way.
👉 See also: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
The Modern Era and the 2026 Perspective
In 2026, our view of the presidency is more polarized than ever. We’ve seen the return of non-consecutive terms and the rise of the "outsider" candidate. Joe Biden’s term focused heavily on post-pandemic recovery and infrastructure, while Donald Trump’s second term has focused on radical shifts in trade and government efficiency.
The reality is that the office changes the person as much as the person changes the office. It’s an impossible job. You’re the head of state, the head of government, and the commander-in-chief of the most powerful military in history. It's a recipe for gray hair and high blood pressure.
Actionable Steps for History Buffs
If you actually want to understand the presidency beyond just a list of names and dates, don't just read a textbook. Textbooks are dry.
- Visit the Presidential Libraries. They aren't just archives; they’re curated stories of how these people viewed their own legacies. The LBJ library in Austin is particularly intense.
- Read the "Worst" Lists. Don't just study the greats. Understanding why Warren G. Harding or Andrew Johnson failed tells you more about the mechanics of the office than studying Washington ever will.
- Check the Primary Sources. Go to the National Archives website. Reading an actual letter written by Abraham Lincoln during the darkest days of 1862 is a lot different than reading a summary of it.
- Watch the Debates. If you want to see the shift in how we choose leaders, watch the 1960 Kennedy-Nixon debate and then watch a debate from the 2020s. The change in tone and substance is a masterclass in American cultural shifts.
The story of the American presidency isn't finished. It’s a work in progress, and every four years, we decide which direction the next chapter takes.