Laundry is boring. It's a chore we do on autopilot until suddenly, your neck starts itching or your kid breaks out in a mysterious rash that looks like a topographical map of the Andes. That's usually the moment people start frantically Googling "hypoallergenic detergent" at 2:00 AM. If you've landed on all free and clear plus, you’re looking at one of the heavy hitters in the "sensitive skin" aisle, but there’s actually a lot of confusion about what that "plus" really brings to the table compared to the standard white bottle.
Most of us assume "plus" means more chemicals. In this case, it’s actually about what’s being added to handle the gross stuff without triggering an eczema flare-up.
The "Plus" Factor: It’s All About the Oxi
Honestly, the biggest difference with all free and clear plus is the addition of Oxi stain fighters. The original "Free Clear" formula is basically the gold standard for dermatologists because it removes the big two triggers: perfumes and dyes. But let's be real—sometimes the original formula struggles with grass stains or that spilled coffee on your favorite white tee.
The "plus" version tries to bridge that gap. It uses oxygen-based bleach (sodium percarbonate variants) to lift stains through oxidation rather than just heavy surfactants. It’s a tactical upgrade. You get the benefit of a "tough" detergent without the synthetic fragrances that make your skin crawl.
It’s a weird balance to strike. Usually, "tough on stains" is code for "loaded with harsh enzymes and masking scents." All manages to dodge that by keeping the core formula inert while amping up the oxygen-based lifting power.
Why Fragrance is the Enemy
We’ve been conditioned to think "clean" has a smell. It doesn't. Clean is the absence of smell.
The National Eczema Association (NEA) has actually given this product their Seal of Acceptance. Why? Because fragrance is one of the top five allergens in the world. When you use a scented detergent, those fragrance molecules stay trapped in the fibers of your clothes. They rub against your skin all day. They get into your pores when you sweat. If you have a compromised skin barrier—think eczema, psoriasis, or just general "winter skin"—those molecules are basically tiny irritants constantly poking at your immune system.
✨ Don't miss: Green Emerald Day Massage: Why Your Body Actually Needs This Specific Therapy
all free and clear plus skips that entire drama.
Does It Actually Work on Tough Stains?
I've seen people claim that free and clear detergents are "weak." That's a myth.
The cleaning power mostly comes from surfactants—molecules that grab oil on one end and water on the other. This detergent uses a multi-enzyme blend. Enzymes are biological catalysts; they basically "eat" specific types of stains. Protease goes after protein (blood, grass, baby formula), while Amylase tackles starches (pasta sauce, chocolate).
By adding the Oxi component to the "plus" version, you’re adding a third layer of cleaning. While the enzymes break down the structural integrity of the stain, the Oxi whitens and brightens. It's particularly good for those yellowing sweat stains on white undershirts.
However, don't expect it to work miracles on a three-day-old set-in oil stain without some help. You still need to pretreat. Rub a little bit of the liquid directly into the stain, let it sit for ten minutes, and then toss it in.
The Science of "Free and Clear"
There is a specific reason why this brand is often the #1 recommended detergent by dermatologists and pediatricians. It isn't just marketing fluff.
🔗 Read more: The Recipe Marble Pound Cake Secrets Professional Bakers Don't Usually Share
When a product says "Free and Clear," it specifically refers to being free of:
- Dyes: These are purely aesthetic. Your detergent doesn't need to be blue to work. Dyes are notorious for causing contact dermatitis.
- Perfumes: As mentioned, these are the primary irritants.
- Preservatives like MIT: Some detergents use Methylisothiazolinone to keep the liquid shelf-stable, but it’s a massive allergen for many people.
The all free and clear plus formula is designed to be highly water-soluble. This is the part people miss. It’s not just about what’s in the bottle, but how well it leaves the clothes. If a detergent doesn't rinse out completely, it leaves a residue. That residue is what actually causes the itching. This formula is engineered to rinse away almost entirely, even in cold water cycles.
Speaking of cold water—this stuff is surprisingly effective at low temperatures. That’s a win for your energy bill and your clothes' longevity.
Is It Better Than the Competition?
You’ve got Tide Free & Gentle, Seventh Generation, and specialized brands like Charlie’s Soap. Where does All fit?
Tide Free & Gentle is the most direct competitor. Honestly? They are very similar. The main difference usually comes down to the specific enzyme mix and price. All tends to be slightly more affordable per load, especially if you buy the massive jugs at Costco or Sam's Club.
Seventh Generation and other "natural" brands often avoid petroleum-based surfactants. While that's great for the environment, some people find they don't clean quite as deeply as a traditional synthetic detergent like All. If you're dealing with serious grease or "kid grime," the synthetic surfactants in all free and clear plus usually have the edge.
💡 You might also like: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
The Concentrated Debate
You'll see "2x Concentrated" on the label. Please, for the love of your washing machine, read the cap.
Modern High-Efficiency (HE) washers use very little water. If you use the old-school "full cap" of concentrated detergent, you’re creating a suds-pocalypse. Not only does this ruin your machine over time by causing mold buildup in the outer drum, but it also ensures the detergent won't rinse out of your clothes.
If you're still itchy after switching to a "free" detergent, you're probably using too much. Try cutting your dosage in half. You’d be shocked how little you actually need.
Practical Steps for Sensitive Skin Success
Switching your detergent is step one, but if you're still dealing with skin issues, you have to look at the whole "laundry ecosystem."
- Clean your machine first. If you’ve been using scented, waxy detergents for years, your washer has a coating of "scrud"—a mix of detergent residue and fabric softener. Run an empty hot cycle with a dedicated washing machine cleaner or a cup of white vinegar before you start your first load with All.
- Ditch the dryer sheets. This is the big one. Most dryer sheets are basically squares of polyester coated in animal tallow and heavy fragrance. They coat your clothes in a waxy film to reduce static. If you use all free and clear plus but keep using scented dryer sheets, you’ve completely defeated the purpose. Switch to wool dryer balls instead.
- Double rinse is your friend. If you have "Princess and the Pea" level sensitive skin, use the "extra rinse" setting on your washer. It ensures every last molecule of surfactant is stripped away.
- Don't overstuff the drum. If the clothes can't move, the water can't get through the fibers to rinse out the soap. Leave at least a hand-width of space at the top.
The reality is that all free and clear plus is a workhorse. It’s not fancy. The bottle isn't going to look "aesthetic" on your laundry room shelf like some boutique brand. But it does exactly what it promises: it gets the dirt out without making your skin feel like it's on fire. For anyone managing eczema or sensitive newborns, that's worth more than any "Mountain Spring" scent ever could be.
If you’re ready to make the switch, start with your bedding. We spend a third of our lives with our faces pressed against pillowcases. If you don't see an improvement in your skin after a week of sleeping on "Free and Clear" sheets, your irritant might be something else entirely, like your skincare routine or a food sensitivity.
Stop overpaying for detergents that use perfume to hide poor cleaning power. Get the "plus" version if you have kids or a messy job; stick to the standard version if your clothes just need a basic refresh. Your skin will thank you.