So, you just finished watching that weirdly addictive supernatural slasher and now you're scouring the internet for the all cheerleaders die cast. I get it. There’s something about that movie—maybe it’s the Wiccan crystals or the bizarre body-swapping—that sticks in your brain. It’s been well over a decade since Lucky McKee and Chris Sivertson unleashed this remake on the world, and honestly, the "where are they now" factor is pretty fascinating.
A lot of these actors were just starting out. Some have become massive stars you see on your screen every week, while others kinda leaned into the indie world or moved behind the scenes.
The Core Squad: Where the Cheerleaders Landed
The movie lived or died on its leading ladies. You can’t have a zombie cheerleader movie without a solid group of girls who can actually act through layers of "undead" makeup.
Caitlin Stasey (Maddy Killian) Caitlin was already a bit of a deal in Australia because of Neighbours, but this was her big swing at a US leading role. She was perfect as the vengeful, brooding Maddy. Since then? She’s been everywhere. You probably recognize her as Kenna from the CW’s Reign. More recently, she had a pretty iconic (and terrifying) role in the 2022 horror hit Smile as Laura Weaver. She’s stayed very active in the horror and indie circuit, even doing some directing herself with projects like After Glow. She’s definitely the breakout of the bunch.
📖 Related: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Sianoa Smit-McPhee (Leena Miller) Leena was the "goth girl" with the magic stones, and Sianoa played her with this great, detached energy. If her last name sounds familiar, it’s because her brother is Kodi Smit-McPhee (from The Power of the Dog and X-Men). Sianoa hasn't been quite as prolific as Caitlin lately, but she did a great job in the HBO series Hung and the Australian mystery The Kettering Incident. Fun fact: she actually wrote and performed "Take a Bite of My Heart" for the movie’s soundtrack.
Brooke Butler (Tracy Bingham) Brooke played the head cheerleader Tracy, who starts as the "mean girl" but ends up a literal zombie. Honestly, Brooke has had a really interesting career trajectory. She showed up in Ozark as the young version of the terrifying Darlene Snell—talk about range. Fast forward to 2025, and she’s still killing it. She recently starred in Sunfish (& Other Stories on Green Lake), which actually premiered at Sundance. She’s also a real-life athlete; she was a top-tier cheerleader for USC back in the day, so those stunts in the movie weren't all movie magic.
Amanda Grace Benitez (Hanna Popkin) Wait, I should clarify. In the credits, she’s often listed as Amanda Grace Cooper. She played Hanna, the sister who ends up in a body-swap situation. She’s stayed mostly in the indie and horror space, appearing in things like The Ranger and Don't Look Back. She’s also a massive animal rights advocate, which is pretty cool.
👉 See also: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
The Guys Who Caused All the Trouble
You can't talk about the all cheerleaders die cast without mentioning the "villains" of the piece—the football players.
- Tom Williamson (Terry Stankus): Terry was arguably the most loathsome character in the movie. Tom Williamson went from playing this jerk to a much more sympathetic long-term role as AJ Hensdale on The Fosters. He’s a regular face on TV now, with spots on NCIS and Blue Bloods.
- Chris Petrovski (George Shank): He played one of the football players involved in the fatal crash. Since then, he had a massive run on Madam Secretary as Dmitri Petrov.
Why the Cast Still Matters Today
Most low-budget horror movies from 2013 are long forgotten. But people keep searching for the all cheerleaders die cast because the film has this weird, campy longevity. It wasn't just a mindless slasher; it was trying to say something about high school power dynamics, even if it did that while a cheerleader was eating someone's dog. (Yeah, that scene still stays with me).
The chemistry between the leads—especially Stasey and Butler—felt real. It didn't feel like "actors playing archetypes." It felt like a group of people who actually hated (and then loved) each other.
✨ Don't miss: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
What You Should Watch Next
If you’re a fan of this specific group of actors, here is a quick "cheat sheet" of where to find them in 2026:
- For more Caitlin Stasey: Watch Class of '07. It’s an Australian comedy about a high school reunion during an apocalypse. It’s basically the spiritual successor to the vibe of All Cheerleaders Die.
- For more Brooke Butler: Keep an eye out for Sunfish. It's a much more serious, dramatic turn for her, proving she's way more than just a "scream queen."
- For more Tom Williamson: If you want to see him play someone who isn't a total monster, binge The Fosters. It’s a complete 180 from his role as Terry.
The reality of the industry is that a lot of "cult" casts scatter to the winds. But for the all cheerleaders die cast, most of them are actually still working and doing some of their best work right now. If you're looking for more info on the production itself, the directors Lucky McKee and Chris Sivertson are still making movies, often together.
Actionable Insight for Fans
If you’re trying to track down a specific actor from the film who didn't make the "big leagues" yet, your best bet is Letterboxd or Instagram. Many of the supporting cast members, like Reanin Johannink or Jordan Wilson, have pivoted into stunt work or smaller independent projects that don't always hit the mainstream radar but are still very active in the L.A. or Australian film scenes. Check the "Cast" tab on Letterboxd to see their most recent micro-budget projects; you'd be surprised how often they pop up in each other's work.