Finding a doctor you actually like is a nightmare. Honestly, it’s one of those adulting tasks that everyone avoids until they absolutely can't. If you live anywhere near Nassau County, you’ve probably heard the name All About Women Garden City whispered in Facebook groups or mentioned over coffee. It’s a specialized OB/GYN practice located right on Franklin Avenue, and it has carved out a very specific reputation in a crowded Long Island medical landscape.
Most people aren't just looking for a sterile room and a lab coat. They want someone who doesn't check their watch every thirty seconds.
The practice, officially known as All About Women Obstetric and Gynecologic Care, is part of the larger NYU Langone Health network. This is a huge deal for patients because it means you get that "small boutique" feel in the office, but you’re backed by the massive infrastructure of one of the top hospital systems in the country. If things get complicated, you aren't just adrift; you're plugged into the NYU system.
The Real Deal on the Garden City Team
Let’s talk about the people. Because at the end of the day, a practice is just a collection of humans in scrubs. The lead figures here, like Dr. Marlo S. Rosenberg and Dr. Shari E. Lusskin, aren't just names on a shingle. Dr. Rosenberg, for instance, has been a fixture in the community for years. She’s board-certified, which is the baseline, sure, but she’s also known for a bedside manner that doesn't feel like a scripted corporate greeting.
People travel from all over Queens and Suffolk just to stick with this specific group. Why? Because women’s healthcare is inherently vulnerable. You’re talking about reproductive health, menopause, high-risk pregnancies, and the kind of stuff that makes most people feel anxious. When you find a provider who remembers your name and doesn't treat your symptoms like a math problem to be solved, you stay.
The team also includes nurse practitioners and physician assistants who often handle the day-to-day wellness exams. Some patients actually prefer this. Why? NPs often have more time to talk through things like birth control options or why your hormones feel like a chaotic rollercoaster.
What Does All About Women Garden City Actually Do?
It’s not just about Pap smears. Though, obviously, they do those. The scope of All About Women Garden City covers the entire lifespan of a woman, which is a lot of ground to cover.
Take pregnancy. If you’re expecting, you want to know who is delivering your baby. They handle routine prenatal care, but they also have the chops for high-risk obstetrics. This is where the NYU Langone connection becomes a massive asset. If you have gestational diabetes or preeclampsia, you want a team that can pivot from a "routine checkup" to "specialized intervention" without breaking a sweat.
📖 Related: Why the 45 degree angle bench is the missing link for your upper chest
Then there’s the surgical side. Nobody wants to think about surgery. It’s scary. But if you need a hysterectomy or treatment for endometriosis, this practice leans heavily into minimally invasive techniques. We’re talking about laparoscopic procedures that mean smaller scars and getting back to your life faster. Gone are the days when every major gynecological issue meant a six-week recovery on the couch.
They also tackle:
- Menopause management (because hot flashes are the worst)
- Infertility workups and initial screenings
- Adolescent gynecology (that awkward first visit for your teenager)
- Contraception, from IUDs to Nexplanon
- Treatment for PCOS and heavy periods
The "Garden City" Experience: Logistics and Vibes
Let’s be real: the office location matters. Being on Franklin Avenue means you’re in the heart of the village. It’s convenient, but parking can sometimes be a bit of a "Hunger Games" situation if you arrive at peak times. Pro tip? Give yourself an extra ten minutes just to find a spot or use the nearby lots.
The waiting room is usually what you’d expect from a high-end Long Island practice. It’s clean. It’s professional. But, like any popular medical office, they can run behind. If there’s an emergency delivery at the hospital—which happens because babies don't care about your 2:00 PM appointment—things get delayed. It’s the trade-off for seeing a doctor who actually delivers babies.
One thing patients consistently bring up is the NYU Langone MyChart portal. If you hate playing phone tag with a receptionist just to get a lab result, this is a lifesaver. You can see your results, message your doctor, and schedule follow-ups from your phone while you’re standing in line at the grocery store. It’s the kind of modern efficiency that makes the actual medical care feel less like a chore.
Why the NYU Langone Affiliation Matters
In the world of private practice, things are changing. A lot of small offices are being swallowed up by giant conglomerates. For All About Women Garden City, being part of NYU Langone Long Island (formerly Winthrop) provides a level of security.
If you are giving birth, you’re likely headed to NYU Langone Hospital—Long Island in Mineola. It’s a Level 1 Trauma Center with a Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) that is world-class. Knowing that your doctor is affiliated with a hospital that can handle the "what-ifs" provides a peace of mind that a standalone clinic just can't match.
👉 See also: The Truth Behind RFK Autism Destroys Families Claims and the Science of Neurodiversity
It’s about the continuum of care. Your records move with you. The specialist in Mineola sees exactly what your doctor in Garden City saw. No faxing. No lost papers. No repeating your entire medical history for the fifth time.
Addressing the Elephant in the Room: The Reviews
If you go online, you’ll see a mix of reviews. That’s the nature of healthcare in 2026. Some people rave about Dr. Rosenberg’s compassion. Others complain about a long wait time or a grumpy person at the front desk.
It's important to take medical reviews with a grain of salt. A five-star review might come from someone who had an easy, fast appointment, while a one-star review might be from someone who was frustrated by the billing department. Billing, by the way, is often handled through the central NYU system, which can be a bit bureaucratic. It’s the price you pay for the high-level clinical care.
The nuance here is that "good" care isn't just about a fast visit. It’s about clinical outcomes. It’s about the doctor who catches a small abnormality on an ultrasound that someone else might have missed. That is where the expertise at All About Women Garden City shines.
Navigating Your First Visit
If you’re a new patient, don't just show up and hope for the best.
First, confirm your insurance. NYU Langone takes most major plans (Empire BlueCross, Aetna, Cigna, etc.), but plans change faster than the weather. Call the office directly to verify. Don't just rely on the website.
Second, bring your records. If you’re transferring from another practice, having your last three years of Paps and any surgical notes will save you a massive headache.
✨ Don't miss: Medicine Ball Set With Rack: What Your Home Gym Is Actually Missing
Third, be honest. Doctors can't help you if you hide the "small stuff." Whether it's mental health struggles, libido issues, or a weird pain you think is probably nothing—mention it. This practice is built on the idea of treating the "whole woman," but they need the full picture to do that effectively.
Modern Gynecology and 2026 Standards
We’ve moved past the era where women's health was just a subset of general medicine. In 2026, the focus at places like All About Women Garden City has shifted toward preventative wellness and personalized medicine. They are increasingly looking at how genetics play a role in things like breast cancer risk and hereditary conditions.
They also recognize that "women's health" includes the transition into menopause, which for a long time was ignored by the medical community. There is a much deeper focus now on Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) and non-hormonal alternatives for women who are struggling with the transition. It’s not just "deal with it" anymore. It’s "let’s find a solution that fits your lifestyle."
Actionable Steps for Your Healthcare Journey
If you're considering making a switch or starting your journey with this practice, here is how to handle it like a pro.
- Audit your current symptoms. Before your appointment, jot down a quick list of anything "off." Use your phone's notes app. When you're sitting in that thin paper gown, you will forget.
- Check the Portal. Once you’re in the system, set up your MyChart immediately. It is the fastest way to communicate.
- Ask about the "on-call" rotation. If you are pregnant, ask how the delivery rotation works. You might love one doctor, but if they aren't on call when the baby decides to show up, you’ll be meeting someone else. Get to know the whole team during your prenatal visits.
- Verify the location. Remember, they are at 1325 Franklin Ave. There are a lot of medical buildings in Garden City; don't end up at the wrong one.
- Review your benefits. Specifically, look at what your "wellness visit" covers versus a "problem-focused visit." This is where most billing surprises happen in US healthcare.
Choosing a healthcare provider is a big deal. It’s a relationship. All About Women Garden City offers a blend of top-tier academic medicine and local, community-focused care. It’s not perfect—no medical office is—but for many women on Long Island, it’s the closest thing to it.
Start by calling their main line to see how far out they are booking. Usually, for a routine annual, you’ll need to look a few months ahead. For urgent issues, they usually try to squeeze you in much faster. Being proactive about your reproductive health is the best gift you can give your future self. Get the appointment on the calendar and go from there.