We’ve all seen the Disney version. Most of us have probably even waded through the trippy 1951 animation or the CGI-heavy Tim Burton films. You know the look: the blonde hair, the blue dress, the white pinafore, and that general vibe of Victorian politeness pushed to the brink of insanity.
But if you actually met the real Alice Liddell, the girl who inspired the whole thing, you probably wouldn’t recognize her.
Honestly, she wasn’t blonde. Not even close. She had a dark, heavy brunette bob with a fringe that looked surprisingly modern for the 1850s. She wasn’t some passive, wide-eyed dreamer, either. By most historical accounts—and even the admission of the author himself—Alice Liddell was a bit of a handful. She was bossy. She was persistent. And if she hadn't been, the book Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland probably wouldn't exist.
The "Golden Afternoon" That Changed Everything
It started on July 4, 1862. It’s funny how history hinges on these random, mundane moments. Charles Lutwidge Dodgson—better known by his pen name Lewis Carroll—was a math tutor at Christ Church, Oxford. He was also a bit of an odd duck. He had a severe stammer that seemed to vanish only when he was talking to children.
On that specific Friday, he and a friend, Robinson Duckworth, took the three Liddell sisters (Lorina, Alice, and Edith) on a rowing trip up the River Thames.
Alice was ten.
As they rowed from Folly Bridge toward Godstow, she begged Dodgson to tell a story. He’d done this before, spinning nonsense yarns to keep them entertained, but this time was different. He started telling them about a girl named Alice who fell down a rabbit hole.
He didn't think much of it at first. Just another way to kill time on a hot day. But Alice was obsessed. She didn't just want to hear it; she demanded he write it down for her. She nagged him for months. Most kids forget these things in a week, but Alice didn't let up.
📖 Related: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
It took him over two years to actually finish the handwritten manuscript, which he originally titled Alice’s Adventures Under Ground. He even drew the illustrations himself—27 of them—and pasted a photo of her in the back.
Why the Character Isn't Actually Her
Here is where it gets weird. Even though she’s the namesake, scholars argue endlessly about whether the character is Alice Liddell.
Carroll himself was kind of evasive about it. He once claimed the character was entirely imaginary and didn't resemble any "human child." This might have been a bit of Victorian PR, though. If you look at the early draft he gave her, the connections are everywhere.
The "Lacie" in the Dormouse's story? That's an anagram for Alice. "Elsie" was L.C. (Lorina Charlotte). "Tillie" was a nickname for Edith.
But when the book went to a professional publisher, everything changed. Carroll hired John Tenniel, a famous political cartoonist for Punch magazine, to do the illustrations. Tenniel didn't use Alice Liddell as his model. Instead, he drew a girl who looked more like the "idealized" Victorian child—hence the blonde hair and the iconic dress.
Basically, the "Alice" we all know is a mashup of a real girl’s personality and a cartoonist's imagination.
The Falling Out: What Really Happened?
If you look into the history of Alice Liddell and Lewis Carroll, you’ll eventually hit a wall. In June 1863, something happened. The friendship between the Liddell family and Dodgson just... stopped.
👉 See also: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
People love a good conspiracy. For decades, biographers have whispered about a suppressed marriage proposal. Did Dodgson, a 31-year-old man, ask to marry an 11-year-old girl?
The truth is, we don't know. The page in his diary for those specific days was literally cut out with scissors by one of his descendants.
However, a discovered note by his niece suggests the "rift" might have been way more boring. It’s possible Mrs. Liddell thought Dodgson was using the children as a cover to flirt with their governess, or even the older sister, Lorina. In the buttoned-up world of Oxford academia, even a whiff of scandal was enough to get you banned from the house.
Whatever it was, they stayed distant. He sent her a copy of the second book, Through the Looking-Glass, but they rarely saw each other again.
The Burden of Being a Muse
Imagine being 80 years old and people are still asking you about a story a guy told you when you were ten.
That was Alice’s life. She grew up, did the "Grand Tour" of Europe, and supposedly caught the eye of Prince Leopold, Queen Victoria’s youngest son. There are rumors of a romance there, too. He eventually named his first daughter Alice, and she named one of her sons Leopold.
She eventually married a wealthy cricketer named Reginald Hargreaves and lived a fairly standard life of a high-society hostess. But she was never just Mrs. Hargreaves. She was always "The Real Alice."
✨ Don't miss: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
By the time she was an old woman, she was broke.
After her husband died in 1926, she couldn’t afford the upkeep on their estate. She had to sell her most prized possession: the original manuscript Dodgson had given her decades earlier. It sold at Sotheby's for £15,400. To give you an idea of the scale, that's over £1 million in today's money.
In her final years, she admitted she was "tired of being Alice in Wonderland." It’s a bit tragic, really. She was a living monument to someone else’s imagination.
Moving Past the Fairy Tale
If you're looking to understand the real story behind the rabbit hole, forget the movies for a second. The reality is a lot more human. It's a story about a lonely, brilliant man who found a way to communicate through nonsense, and a sharp-witted girl who knew a good story when she heard one.
Key takeaways for history buffs:
- The hair matter: Real Alice was a brunette. Tenniel’s illustrations created the blonde icon.
- The "Golden Afternoon" wasn't that golden: Weather records from July 4, 1862, actually show it was a "cool and rather wet" day. The "sunny sky" Carroll wrote about was likely poetic license.
- A literary pioneer: Before this book, most children's stories were "moral" lessons. Carroll and Alice basically invented the "nonsense" genre for kids.
If you ever find yourself in Oxford, you can still see the traces of this. The "Cheshire Cat tree" is still in the garden at Christ Church. The "Rabbit Hole" is a small door in the cathedral.
To really get the vibe, try reading the original manuscript, Alice’s Adventures Under Ground. It’s shorter, weirder, and feels a lot more like a private joke between two friends than a global franchise.
Next time you see a blonde girl in a blue dress on a t-shirt, just remember the dark-haired girl who stood her ground in a rowing boat and demanded a story. Without her stubbornness, we’d all be a lot more bored.
Check out the British Library's digital archives if you want to see the original handwriting. It's surprisingly legible, almost like he knew people would still be reading it 160 years later.