When AMC first announced that Alexandra Daddario would lead the cast of Anne Rice’s Mayfair Witches, the internet basically lost its mind. It made sense. She has those striking, almost otherworldly eyes that seem tailor-made for a supernatural thriller. People expected a direct translation of the powerhouse neurosurgeon from Rice’s 1,000-page gothic tome, The Witching Hour.
But then the show actually aired.
And honestly? A lot of fans were confused. The Rowan Fielding we saw on screen wasn’t the cold, hyper-competent, and slightly terrifying woman from the books. Instead, she felt... vulnerable. Maybe even a little bit lost. This disconnect has sparked some of the most heated debates in the "Immortal Universe" fandom, especially as we head deeper into the show’s run.
What Most People Get Wrong About Rowan Mayfair
If you go into this show expecting the book version of Rowan, you’re gonna have a bad time. In the novels, Rowan is an ice queen. She’s a surgeon who knows she has a "killing touch" and uses it with a terrifying level of pragmatism. She’s tall, blonde, and has a commanding presence that makes people flinch.
Daddario plays her differently.
The TV version of Alexandra Daddario Mayfair Witches is a woman constantly on the verge of a breakdown. She stutters. She faints. She looks wide-eyed and bewildered. Some critics called it "atrocious acting," but if you look closer, it’s clearly a deliberate choice by showrunners Esta Spalding and Michelle Ashford. They didn't want a superhero; they wanted a victim of gaslighting who discovers she has the power to fight back.
Is it frustrating to watch? Sometimes, yeah. But it’s a specific interpretation of a character who has been lied to her entire life. Rowan isn't just discovering magic; she’s discovering that her entire identity was a fabrication constructed by the Talamasca and her estranged family.
The Lasher Connection
The chemistry—or lack thereof—between Daddario and Jack Huston (who plays the entity Lasher) is another huge talking point. In the books, their connection is purely erotic and destructive. In the series, it feels more like a toxic relationship with a supernatural stalker. Daddario has mentioned in interviews that she viewed the relationship as a "bad boyfriend" metaphor.
✨ Don't miss: Cowboy Carter Album Sales: What Most People Get Wrong
- Book Lasher: A seductive, centuries-old ghost.
- TV Lasher: A more physical, sometimes oily presence that feels a bit more "real world" creepy.
The Production Shift: New Orleans to Vancouver
One of the coolest things about the first season was the location. They filmed at the Soria-Creel House in New Orleans' Garden District. It’s this massive, haunting mansion at 3102 Prytania Street that basically looks exactly like what Anne Rice described. It gave the show an atmospheric weight that you just can't fake on a soundstage.
Things changed for Season 3.
Production officially moved from the humid, moss-draped streets of New Orleans to Vancouver. This is a big deal for the "vibe" of the show. While Vancouver is the filming capital of the world, it lacks that specific, heavy New Orleans air. Fans are curious if the change in scenery will reflect a change in the story’s tone as Rowan moves further away from her roots.
Why Season 2 Changed the Game
Season 2, which premiered in early 2025, took some massive swings. After that wild Season 1 finale where Rowan basically gave birth to a fully-grown Lasher (yeah, it was weird), the show had to lean into the "darkness" promised by its marketing.
💡 You might also like: Why Top Songs From Musicals Still Get Stuck in Your Head Decades Later
We saw a more assertive Rowan. The "helpless waif" complaints started to die down as she began to embrace her role as the 13th witch. The addition of Ben Feldman as Sam Larkin—Rowan’s ex-boyfriend—added some much-needed human grounding to a show that was getting increasingly trippy.
New Faces and Returning Stars
The cast list for the second and third seasons expanded the Mayfair lore significantly:
- Alyssa Jirrels as Moira Mayfair: Rowan’s cousin who brings a much more "modern witch" energy.
- Harry Hamlin as Cortland: Still the patriarch we love to hate, providing that veteran acting gravitas.
- Ted Levine as Julien Mayfair: A massive inclusion for book fans, as Julien is arguably the most complex character in the entire trilogy.
The "Immortal Universe" Connection
You can’t talk about Alexandra Daddario Mayfair Witches without mentioning Interview with the Vampire. AMC is trying to build a shared universe here, much like Marvel but with more velvet and blood.
There’s a lot of pressure on Daddario to carry her side of the franchise. While Interview is a critical darling, Mayfair Witches has had a rockier road. However, the ratings have been strong enough to keep it going. The upcoming Talamasca spin-off is expected to be the "glue" that finally brings Rowan and the vampires together.
Honestly, the show is at its best when it stops trying to be a medical drama and leans into the "insane" elements of Anne Rice’s writing. We’re talking about generational trauma, incestuous family trees, and a demon that wants to become human. It’s messy. It’s gothic. It’s a lot.
Actionable Steps for Fans
If you're trying to keep up with the chaotic world of the Mayfairs, here is what you should do next to get the full experience:
✨ Don't miss: Where Can I Watch The Last Rodeo for Free? What You Need to Know
- Watch the Netflix Rollout: If you missed the AMC airing, Season 2 is scheduled to hit Netflix US in December 2025. This is usually when the "second wave" of fan theories and discussions hits social media.
- Read "The Witching Hour" (But keep it separate): To truly appreciate—or critique—Daddario's performance, you have to read the first book. Just go into it knowing the show is an "inspired by" adaptation rather than a page-for-page recreation.
- Track the Vancouver Filming: Since Season 3 is filming through early 2026, keep an eye on local Vancouver production trackers. The change in location suggests we might see more of the "Scottish origins" of the Mayfair line.
- Follow the Talamasca News: Since the Talamasca order is the connecting thread between the witches and the vampires, watching for news on that show will give you the best hints about potential crossovers for Rowan.
The journey of Alexandra Daddario as Rowan Mayfair has been anything but predictable. Whether you love the new direction or miss the book's ice-cold protagonist, there's no denying that the show has carved out a very specific, very weird niche in the current TV landscape.