You know that feeling when a show just feels off because a specific person is missing? That’s exactly what happened in 2010 when CBS made the baffling decision to let go of A.J. Cook, the talented actress who plays JJ on Criminal Minds. Fans didn't just get annoyed. They revolted. It was a whole thing.
Jennifer "JJ" Jareau wasn't just another face in the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit. She was the glue. While the rest of the team was busy profiling serial killers and staring into the abyss of human depravity, JJ was the one talking to the families. She had the empathy. She was the bridge between the gruesome reality of the job and the grieving people left behind.
Born Andrea Joy Cook in Oshawa, Ontario, the Canadian actress didn't exactly have an easy road to Hollywood stardom. It’s kinda wild to think about, but she was actually legally blind as a child because of severe cataracts. She didn't get the surgery to correct it until she was in her early twenties. Imagine trying to build a career in film when you can barely see the marks you’re supposed to hit. That’s grit. Pure and simple.
How A.J. Cook Redefined the "Liaison" Role
When Criminal Minds premiered in 2005, JJ’s job was technically "Media Liaison." In TV terms, that usually means the character who stands at a podium and gives boring updates to reporters. But Cook brought something different. She made JJ feel like a real person trapped in a nightmare.
Most people don't realize that JJ wasn't even in the pilot episode. The producers realized they needed a different energy, and A.J. stepped in by the second episode. She stayed for years, growing from a slightly green communications officer into a seasoned field agent.
✨ Don't miss: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
Then, the 2010 disaster happened.
During Season 6, citing "creative reasons" (which is usually code for budget cuts), the network dropped her. The backlash was instantaneous. More than 40,000 fans signed petitions. They sent letters. They made a noise so loud that the executives couldn't ignore it. By Season 7, she was back, and honestly, the show was better for it. They even wrote her return into the plot, giving JJ a massive promotion and a much darker, more complex backstory involving her time at the State Department.
Beyond the BAU: The Career You Might Have Missed
If you only know her as the actress who plays JJ on Criminal Minds, you’re missing out on some classic 2000s cinema. Remember Final Destination 2? She was the lead, Kimberly Corman. She’s the one who has the premonition about the horrific highway pileup involving the logging truck. If you’ve ever been terrified of driving behind a truck carrying logs, you can thank A.J. Cook for that core memory.
She also starred in Out Cold, a snowboarding comedy that has become a bit of a cult classic. It’s a complete 180 from the grim, dark hallways of the BAU. It shows her range. She can do the "girl next door" thing, the "scream queen" thing, and the "badass federal agent" thing without breaking a sweat.
🔗 Read more: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
The Evolution of Jennifer Jareau
Watching the show from the beginning is like watching A.J. Cook grow up on screen. In the early seasons, she was the one protecting the team from the press. She was the "kid sister" in some ways. But as the seasons progressed, JJ evolved. She became a mother. She became a profiler. She handled some of the most traumatic storylines in the series, including her own kidnapping and the complications of her marriage to Will LaMontagne Jr.
Interesting fact: Her real-life sons, Mekhai and Phoenix, actually played her onscreen children, Henry and Michael.
That wasn't just a casting gimmick. It added a level of authentic emotion to her performance that you just can't fake with child actors you met five minutes before the cameras started rolling. When JJ looks worried about her kids, that's a real mom looking at her real babies. It’s those small details that made the actress who plays JJ on Criminal Minds so indispensable to the fanbase.
Why the Fans Won’t Let Go
What makes A.J. Cook so special? Is it just the nostalgia? Kinda. But it's more than that.
💡 You might also like: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
The Criminal Minds community is fiercely protective of the original cast. There’s a chemistry between Cook, Matthew Gray Gubler (Reid), and Joe Mantegna (Rossi) that is lightning in a bottle. You can’t manufacture that. When the show was revived as Criminal Minds: Evolution on Paramount+, seeing JJ back in action felt like a homecoming for millions of viewers.
She’s also been vocal about the industry's double standards. She’s handled the ups and downs of a long-running procedural with a lot of grace, often advocating for her character's growth rather than just being "the girl on the team." She even stepped behind the camera to direct episodes like "Chameleon," proving she understands the mechanics of the show from the inside out.
The Realistic Side of TV Fame
A.J. Cook isn't a tabloid fixture. You don't see her stumbling out of clubs or getting involved in Twitter feuds. She’s basically the definition of a "working actor." She’s been married to Nathan Andersen since 2001—which is basically a lifetime in Hollywood years.
They met in a film class at Utah Valley University. It’s a grounded, relatable story. That groundedness is exactly what she brings to JJ. Even when the plotlines get totally wild and unrealistic (which, let's be honest, happens a lot in crime procedurals), JJ remains the character the audience can relate to. She’s the one who feels the weight of the cases.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans and Aspiring Actors
If you're looking to dive deeper into A.J. Cook’s work or even if you're an actor trying to learn from her career path, there are a few things to keep in mind.
- Watch the "Evolution" transition. Compare her performance in Season 1 of the original series to the latest episodes of Criminal Minds: Evolution. Pay attention to her vocal register and physical presence; she intentionally made JJ harder and more world-weary over time.
- Check out her directorial work. Watching the episodes she directed gives you a sense of her visual storytelling style. It’s a great study in how an actor’s perspective can change the pacing of a scene.
- Support the "Originals." Much of her career longevity is due to fan engagement. If you like a character, tell the network. The 2010 rehiring of A.J. Cook is literally a case study in the power of social media and fan petitions before that was even a mainstream concept.
- Explore her early horror work. If you want to see her handle high-tension scenes without the "FBI" shield to protect her, Final Destination 2 is the gold standard. It shows her ability to carry a movie as a solo lead.
The actress who plays JJ on Criminal Minds isn't just a part of a successful show; she’s a survivor of an industry that often tries to replace women as they get older or more expensive. A.J. Cook beat the system by being too good—and too loved—to lose. Whether she’s chasing down UnSubs or directing from behind the lens, she remains the steady heartbeat of the BAU.