You just dropped nearly $250 on a pair of white plastic buds that are basically designed to be lost, crushed, or drowned. It’s a stressful purchase. Then, the specialist at the Apple Store or that pesky notification on your iPhone asks the big question: "Do you want to add AirPods Pro 2 AppleCare+ for $29?"
Honestly, it feels like a trap.
Most of us have a love-hate relationship with extended warranties. They usually feel like a scam. But the AirPods Pro 2 AppleCare situation is a bit different because of how these specific devices are built. They aren't meant to be repaired. If the battery dies or a driver rattles, Apple doesn't open them up with tiny screwdrivers. They throw them in a bin and give you a new one. That's the reality of the "hearables" market.
The cold hard truth about the AirPods Pro 2 AppleCare coverage
If you're looking for the technical breakdown, AppleCare+ for Headphones covers two years of hardware repairs and accidental damage protection. But the devil is in the details. You get unlimited incidents of accidental damage. Sounds great, right? Well, it’s not totally free. Each time you sit on your buds or drop them in a latte, you're looking at a $29 deductible.
Compare that to the out-of-warranty cost. If you don't have coverage and you bust a single AirPod Pro 2, Apple is going to charge you $89. Lose the charging case? That’s another $99. If you destroy the whole set at once without insurance, you're basically buying a new pair at full retail price.
What about the battery?
This is where it gets interesting. AirPods use tiny lithium-ion batteries. These things have a shelf life. If you use your pods every day for four hours of Zoom calls and gym sessions, those batteries will degrade. Usually, after 18 to 24 months, you’ll notice the charge doesn’t last through a flight anymore.
👉 See also: What Is Hack Meaning? Why the Internet Keeps Changing the Definition
AppleCare+ covers battery service if your buds hold less than 80% of their original capacity. The catch? It’s hard to prove. Unlike an iPhone, there isn't a "Battery Health" percentage buried in the settings for AirPods. You have to rely on Apple's internal diagnostics. But if they fail, the replacement is $0. Without the plan, a battery "service" is $49 per earbud. That’s $98 just to get your battery life back to normal. Suddenly, that $29 upfront cost looks like a genius move.
Why the AirPods Pro 2 are a special case for insurance
I’ve seen people skip insurance on iPads and MacBooks because those are sturdy. You keep them on desks. You treat them with respect. AirPods live in your sweaty pockets. They fall out of your ears while you're running for a bus.
There's also the "Find My" factor. While the AirPods Pro 2 have the U1 (or U2 in the USB-C version) chip for precision finding, it doesn't help if your dog decides the MagSafe case is a chew toy. AirPods Pro 2 AppleCare specifically covers "accidental damage from handling." It does not cover theft or loss.
Wait. Let me say that again.
If you lose your AirPods, AppleCare+ does nothing for you. You are out of luck. You have to pay the "lost" replacement fee, which is roughly $89 per bud. Many people get this confused because the iPhone version of AppleCare has a Theft and Loss tier. The headphone version doesn't.
✨ Don't miss: Why a 9 digit zip lookup actually saves you money (and headaches)
The USB-C vs. Lightning wrinkle
If you bought the newer USB-C version of the AirPods Pro 2, you have a slightly higher IP54 rating for dust resistance. The older Lightning version was just IPX4. Does this mean you don't need the warranty? Not really. Dust is rarely what kills these things; it’s usually the "oops" moments. Whether it’s the 2022 model or the 2023 refresh, the internal architecture is a mess of glue and ribbons. According to the teardown experts at iFixit, these have a repairability score of 0 out of 10.
Zero.
You cannot fix them. If the active noise cancellation (ANC) starts making a high-pitched whistling sound—a common issue with the first generation that still occasionally pops up in the Pro 2—the only solution is a total swap.
How to actually buy it (and the 60-day ticking clock)
You've got a window. You don't have to buy it the second you swipe your credit card. You have 60 days from the purchase date to add the coverage.
- Go to Settings on your iPhone.
- Tap on your AirPods (they should be connected).
- Look for "AppleCare+ Coverage Available."
- Pay the $29.
Alternatively, you can go to an Apple Store, but they might want to inspect the buds to make sure you haven't already crushed them. Honestly, doing it through the phone is way easier.
🔗 Read more: Why the time on Fitbit is wrong and how to actually fix it
Is the monthly plan a scam?
Apple started offering a monthly recurring plan for AppleCare. For the AirPods Pro 2, it’s usually around $2.49 a month. If you plan on keeping your AirPods for exactly two years, the upfront $29 is cheaper. If you’re the type of person who upgrades every time a new model drops, the monthly plan gives you the flexibility to cancel the second you sell your old pair.
The "Refurbished" Trap
If you bought your AirPods Pro 2 from a third-party seller or got them "renewed" on Amazon, be careful. Usually, you can't add official AppleCare+ to refurbished units unless they were sold directly by Apple as "Certified Refurbished."
Many people think they’re covered because the previous owner had it. AppleCare stays with the device serial number, but if the previous owner was paying monthly, they can cancel it anytime. If they paid upfront, you're in the clear. Always check the serial number on Apple’s "Check Coverage" website before you assume you're protected.
Real-world scenarios: When it pays off
Let's look at Jim. Jim is a runner. Six months in, his left AirPod Pro 2 falls out of his ear and bounces into a storm drain. AppleCare won't help him because it's lost. Jim is sad.
Now let's look at Sarah. Sarah drops her charging case on the concrete. The hinge snaps. The AirPods still work, but they won't charge because the case is mangled. Without AirPods Pro 2 AppleCare, she's paying $99. With it, she pays $29. She saved $70.
Then there’s the "static" issue. Some users report a crackling sound in the transparency mode after a year of heavy use. This is often caused by debris getting into the external microphones or a hardware failure in the MEMS mic. Since this is a hardware failure and not accidental damage, Apple usually swaps them for $0 under AppleCare+. Without it, you’re stuck buying a whole new set because "repairing" a microphone is impossible in this form factor.
Actionable steps for your AirPods Pro 2
- Check your purchase date. If you are within the 60-day window, seriously consider the $29 investment. It is one of the cheapest AppleCare plans across the entire product line.
- Test your battery at month 23. If you bought the plan, don't let it expire without checking your runtime. If you're getting significantly less than the advertised 6 hours per charge, take them to the Genius Bar.
- Keep your receipt. Even though the serial number is digital, sometimes the purchase date in Apple's system is wrong (especially if you bought from Costco or Best Buy).
- Ignore the "theft" myth. Do not buy this thinking you're protected against a thief. Use a protective case with a locking lid or a carabiner to prevent the "pop-open" loss where the buds fly out of the case when it hits the ground.
- Evaluate your environment. If you only use your AirPods at your desk, skip it. If you use them at the gym, while commuting, or near water, it's essentially a mandatory purchase for peace of mind.
The reality is that AirPods are disposable tech. They have an expiration date. Investing in the warranty isn't just about accidental drops; it’s about ensuring that your $250 investment actually lasts more than two years through a battery swap. In a world of unrepairable gadgets, this is one of the few times the "extended warranty" actually makes financial sense for the average user.