Honestly, walking into Abrusci's Fire and Wine Lakewood CO for the first time feels a bit like finding a secret handshake you didn't know you needed. It’s tucked away at 2200 Youngfield Street in that sweet spot of the Applewood neighborhood. People talk about "neighborhood staples" all the time, but this place actually survived the 2003 era when it was just a tiny Italian ristorante nearby. Now, it's this massive, modern-rustic hub with wood-fired ovens and a patio that basically owns the local social scene.
If you’re looking for a stuffy, white-tablecloth Italian experience where the waiter judges your wine choice, you’re in the wrong place.
The No-Tipping Reality at Abrusci's Fire and Wine Lakewood CO
Let’s address the elephant in the room immediately because it’s the thing that confuses new diners the most. Since June 2015, they’ve operated on a non-tipping model. Basically, there is a 20% hospitality charge added to every bill. You don't leave a tip. It’s done.
Why? Because owners Jeff Progar and Marvin Williams wanted to create a more stable, livable wage for the entire staff, not just the folks bringing you the bread. It makes the math easy at the end of the night, but it does mean your "Cheap Tuesday" dinner might look a little more expensive on the final receipt than you initially calculated. Just keep that in mind when you’re ordering that second round of craft cocktails.
What to Actually Order (And What to Skip)
The menu is a beast. It’s huge. It can be a little overwhelming if you're just looking for a quick bite.
📖 Related: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
The Rigatoni & Sausage is, hands down, the heavy hitter here. It's got that tomato cream sauce that makes you want to lick the bowl, though I'd suggest doing that in the privacy of your own home. If you want something a bit weirder, the Penne Gorgonzola is the "love it or hate it" dish. It has red grapes and walnuts in it. I know. It sounds like a salad that got lost in a pasta bowl, but the sweetness of the grapes against the funk of the gorgonzola is actually pretty brilliant.
One thing people often miss is the Pepperoni Rolls. They’re simple. They’re $8.50. They’re basically adult pizza rolls, and if you have kids, just order two plates immediately to avoid the inevitable table war.
The Gluten-Free Gold Mine
Now, if you have Celiac disease or a gluten sensitivity, you probably already know about Abrusci's. They are weirdly good at gluten-free food. Like, "did they accidentally give me the real flour?" good.
They don't just offer one sad GF pasta. They have a massive dedicated menu. We're talking:
👉 See also: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
- GF Fried Ravioli (which is a texture miracle)
- GF Tiramisu (rare as a unicorn in most Italian spots)
- GF Garlic Bread with that signature garlic paste
They source a lot of their specialty items from local spots like Gluten Free Things in Arvada. It’s a very "local supporting local" vibe. However, be aware that it’s still a shared kitchen. If you’re the kind of person who reacts to a single crumb in the air, use caution, but for the general GF crowd, this is basically the promised land.
The Fire and the Wine
The "Fire" part of the name comes from the wood-fired oven that hits $750$ degrees. Pizzas come out in about two minutes. The Hot Honey Pizza with prosciutto and goat cheese is the one everyone posts on Instagram, and for good reason—the spicy-sweet combo is addictive.
On the "Wine" side, they aren't just doing the standard house Chianti. They have a solid rotation of craft beers (Tivoli, Coors, etc.) and a cocktail list that features local spirits like Stranahan’s.
The Happy Hour Situation
Happy hour is daily, but it gets crowded. Fast. If you're trying to snag a spot on the patio during a Colorado summer evening, you better have a plan. The patio is gorgeous—think string lights, fire pits, and enough space to actually breathe.
✨ Don't miss: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
The "Pablito's" Side Quest
Fun fact: during the 2020 chaos, the team realized people needed breakfast burritos as much as they needed pasta. So, they launched Pablito's Burritos out of the same location. It started as a way to keep staff employed, but it turned into its own thing. If you see people lining up in the morning at an Italian restaurant, that’s why. It’s the ultimate neighborhood pivot.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
Don't just wing it. If you're heading to Abrusci's Fire and Wine Lakewood CO, follow these rules:
- Make a reservation for groups. Seriously. Even on a random Wednesday, the Applewood crowd shows up in droves.
- Try the Garlic Paste. It comes with the ciabatta. It’s roasted, mellow, and will absolutely ruin your breath for 24 hours. Worth it.
- Check the "Best Damn Sandwich." It’s literally called that on the menu. If you aren't in the mood for pasta, it’s a massive, reliable win.
- Parking is tricky. There’s a lot, but it fills up. You might end up parking a block away in the neighborhood. Just be respectful of the residents.
- Budget for the 20%. Remember that the price on the menu isn't the final price, but you won't be adding a tip at the end.
Whether you're there for a date night or just a Tuesday night where you can't fathom boiling water for pasta, it’s a spot that feels like the heart of Lakewood. Just don't forget to try those grapes in the pasta. Trust me on that one.