You probably found a gold-colored coin in a drawer or a box of old stuff. It’s got Abraham Lincoln’s face on it. Across the top, it clearly says "1861–1865." Naturally, your heart skips a beat. You think you’ve stumbled onto a Civil War-era treasure. Maybe it’s worth thousands?
Hold on a second.
The reality is usually a bit more "modern." Most of the time, that abraham lincoln coin 1861 to 1865 worth is exactly one dollar. That’s because it’s likely a Presidential $1 Coin minted in 2010. Those dates—1861 to 1865—refer to the years Lincoln served as the 16th President, not the year the coin was actually struck.
But don't toss it back in the junk drawer just yet. There are some weird exceptions where Lincoln "coins" from that era actually exist, and those are the ones that make collectors go absolutely wild.
The 2010 Presidential Dollar Reality Check
If your coin has a golden hue and a picture of the Statue of Liberty on the back, it’s a 2010 Presidential Dollar. The U.S. Mint pumped these out by the millions.
🔗 Read more: What Time in London Ontario Is Right Now: The Confusion Explained
They aren't made of real gold. It's actually a manganese-brass clad over a copper core.
Basically, if it’s shiny and looks like it could have come from a vending machine, it’s worth $1. If it’s in perfect, uncirculated condition, maybe a collector gives you $2 or $3 for it. You’ll see people on eBay listing them for $500 or $1,000, claiming they are "rare error coins." Honestly? Most of those listings are just hoping to catch someone who hasn't done their homework. Unless it has a massive, verified minting error—like missing edge lettering—it’s just a dollar.
When the 1861-1865 Dates Actually Mean Money
Now, let’s talk about the "real" stuff. During the Civil War, people were terrified. They hoarded gold and silver. Even copper pennies disappeared from circulation because people didn't trust the government's paper money (Greenbacks).
This created a massive shortage of small change. Merchants couldn't give out change for a loaf of bread.
To solve this, private companies started minting "Civil War Tokens." These are the real 1861–1865 treasures. They are roughly the size of a modern penny but carry designs that the government never authorized.
Patriotic Tokens and Store Cards
You might find a token with Lincoln’s face on one side and a slogan like "The Union For Ever" or "The Right Man in the Right Place" on the back. These were minted between 1862 and 1864.
The value of a Lincoln Civil War token varies wildly:
- Common varieties: $20 to $50.
- High-grade (uncirculated) pieces: $150 to $300.
- Rare "off-metal" strikes: If the token was struck in silver or white metal instead of copper, you're looking at $500 to $1,500+.
One specific variety, known as the "Lincoln/OK" token (Fuld-127/248 a), is a fan favorite. Even a worn-out version of this can easily fetch $100 because collectors love anything with Lincoln’s profile from his actual lifetime.
The Famous 1861 "Lincoln" Medals
Lincoln didn't appear on a standard U.S. circulating coin until 1909. Before that, his face was mostly on "medals" or "campaign tokens."
In 1861, for his inauguration, several medals were produced. These aren't technical "coins" because you couldn't spend them at the store, but they are high-value numismatic items.
If you have a genuine 1861 Abraham Lincoln Inaugural Medal, the condition is everything. A bronze version in decent shape usually starts around $200. If you somehow have one of the rare silver versions presented to dignitaries, you’ve hit a jackpot that can reach into the thousands at a specialized auction house like Heritage Auctions or Stack's Bowers.
Why the "1861 to 1865" Dates Confuse Everyone
The confusion stems from the way the U.S. Mint designed the Presidential Dollar series. They put the years of service directly under the name.
- Lincoln: 1861–1865
- Washington: 1789–1797
- Jefferson: 1801–1809
If you look at the edge of the coin—yes, the skinny side—you will see the actual year it was made. For the Lincoln dollar, that year is 2010.
It’s an easy mistake. You see a famous face and a date from 160 years ago. Who wouldn't be excited? But numismatics (the study of coins) is a game of fine print.
Identifying a Genuine Civil War Era Item
If you think you have something older than a 2010 dollar, look for these signs:
- Thickness: Modern dollars are fairly thick and have a distinct "sandwich" look on the edge. Civil War tokens are thinner, more like a modern penny.
- Metal: If it looks like "pot metal" or dark, crusty copper, it's more likely to be an authentic 19th-century token.
- Wording: Authentic tokens often have merchant names (e.g., "I.O.U. 1 Cent") or very specific political slogans that wouldn't be on a modern government coin.
- The Reverse: Modern $1 coins always have the Statue of Liberty. If your coin has a wreath, a shield, or a merchant's address, it's a token.
What Should You Do With Your Coin?
First, check that edge. If you see "2010 P" or "2010 D," you have a standard Presidential Dollar. It’s great for a collection or for teaching kids about history, but it won't pay for a vacation.
If there is NO date on the edge, you might have an "Experimental Edge" or a "Missing Edge Lettering" error. These are legitimate errors that can be worth $50 to $100 depending on the grade. You'll need to get it looked at by a local coin shop or a grading service like NGC or PCGS to be sure.
If the coin is thin, looks like copper, and definitely says 1861 or 1863 on the face (without being a 2010 dollar), stop touching it. The oils from your fingers can actually ruin the patina and drop the value. Put it in a soft plastic flip or a small envelope.
Research the specific slogans or images on the back. Websites like the Civil War Token Society have databases that help you identify exactly which "Fuld number" your token is. That number determines the rarity. Some tokens have only 5 or 10 known survivors, making them incredibly valuable regardless of the metal.
Check for "off-metal" strikes using a magnet. A standard token is copper (non-magnetic). If it sticks to a magnet, it might be a contemporary counterfeit or a specific "white metal" variety.
Lastly, don't clean it. Never use polish, vinegar, or even a cloth. Collectors want "original skin." A cleaned coin loses 50% to 80% of its market value instantly. Keep it exactly as you found it until an expert can verify what you’ve got.
If it turns out to be the 2010 version, hey, you’ve still got a dollar. That’s enough for a coffee—or at least a head start on a new hobby.
Next Steps for You:
- Check the edge of the coin for the year 2010; if it's there, the coin is worth $1.
- Compare the reverse to the Statue of Liberty; if it doesn't match, you likely have a Civil War token or medal.
- Visit a local coin shop for a free verbal appraisal if the coin appears to be genuine 19th-century copper.
- Avoid cleaning the coin to preserve its numismatic value.