Honestly, most people walk into a pool store thinking they only have two options: a circle or a rectangle. It’s a bit of a tragedy. You’re about to drop thousands of dollars on a backyard centerpiece, and yet, the conversation usually stops at "will it fit?" Choosing between different above ground swimming pool shapes isn't just about aesthetics; it’s about structural integrity, water circulation, and how much you’re going to hate vacuuming the corners three years from now.
Backyards are rarely perfect squares. They’ve got slopes. They’ve got weird oak trees you aren't allowed to cut down. They’ve got utility lines. Because of these constraints, the shape you pick dictates whether your pool feels like a luxurious oasis or a giant bucket someone dropped in the grass.
The circular standard and why it’s actually a structural powerhouse
Round pools are the OGs of the industry. There is a very nerdy, physics-based reason for this: equalized pressure. When you fill a round pool with thousands of gallons of water, the force is distributed evenly against the walls at every single point. No weak spots. This is why round pools are generally the cheapest to buy and the easiest to install for a DIYer.
They also offer the most "swim room" for your buck.
Think about it. In an 18-foot round pool, you have a consistent diameter no matter where you splash. It’s great for kids playing "sharks and minnows" because there aren't any corners to get trapped in. However, the downside is that they are space hogs. If you have a long, narrow side yard, a round pool is basically a non-starter. You’ll end up with these awkward "dead zones" of grass in the corners of your yard that are too small to mow but too big to ignore.
📖 Related: 51 N 39th St Philadelphia PA: What You Actually Need to Know About This University City Address
Why circular pools win on maintenance
I’ve talked to pool techs who swear by rounds for one reason: circulation. When your return jet kicks on, the water moves in a natural vortex. Debris gets pushed toward the center or the skimmer much more efficiently than in a shape with sharp angles. If you’re lazy about manual vacuuming (and let’s be real, most of us are), the circular flow is your best friend.
The oval debate: Is it worth the extra hardware?
Oval pools exist because people wanted the "lap pool" feel without digging a hole in the ground. They look more sophisticated. They fit perfectly in narrow lots. But here is the catch that most sales brochures won't lead with: the buttresses.
Because an oval doesn't have the natural structural integrity of a circle, the long straight walls want to bow outward under the weight of the water. To stop your pool from exploding, manufacturers use heavy-duty side supports called buttresses.
- Some buttresses stick out 3 to 4 feet from the side of the pool.
- "Buttress-free" models exist, but they require a much more complex underground installation with steel "U-channels."
- You’ll pay significantly more for an oval pool of the same gallonage as a round one.
Is it worth it? If you want to swim laps, yes. If you’re trying to mirror the rectangular lines of your deck or your house, absolutely. But don't go into it thinking it’s an easy weekend project. Oval pools are notoriously finicky to level. If you’re off by an inch on one of those long sides, the liner will wrinkle, and the wall could eventually buckle.
Rectangles and the rise of the "container" pool
For a long time, true rectangular above ground swimming pool shapes were rare unless you were looking at those blue-tarp "Easy Set" models. But things have changed. With the trend of "shipping container" pools and high-end semi-inground options from brands like Stealth or Radiant, the rectangle is making a massive comeback.
Rectangles are the gold standard for aesthetics. They look intentional. If you wrap a rectangular above ground pool in a high-quality timber deck, it’s almost impossible to tell it isn't an inground installation.
The lap swimming reality
If you are a serious swimmer, the rectangle is the only shape that makes sense. You can actually do flip turns. You can use a tether. In a round pool, you’re basically just swimming in a never-ending curve, which can make you a little dizzy after twenty minutes.
The structural challenge here is even more intense than with ovals. To keep those long walls straight, these pools often use massive amounts of reinforced steel or even concrete footings. This is why you’ll see the price jump from $4,000 for a round pool to $12,000+ for a high-end rectangular setup.
Kidney and Grecian shapes: The "Semi-Inground" middle ground
Then there are the "fancy" shapes. You don't see these in the $500 clearance aisle at big-box stores. Shapes like the Kidney or the Grecian (which is a rectangle with notched corners) are typically reserved for semi-inground pools. These are made of thicker materials—often powder-coated aluminum or galvanized steel—because they are designed to be buried halfway in the earth.
- Kidney shapes follow the natural contours of a landscape. They’re great if you want a "lagoon" vibe with lots of plants and rockwork.
- Grecian shapes provide a classic, Mediterranean look. The cut corners actually provide a great spot for internal steps, which is a huge upgrade over those flimsy A-frame ladders.
The downside? Liners. If you have a standard round pool and the liner rips, you can find a replacement at any pool supply shop in the country. If you have a custom kidney-shaped above ground pool, you’re likely ordering a custom-cut liner. That means more money and a longer wait time when things go wrong.
How to actually choose based on your lifestyle
Stop looking at the pictures of the pools and start looking at your actual life. I’ve seen families buy a massive 30-foot round pool only to realize they can't afford to heat it because the surface area is so huge that all the heat escapes overnight.
Small kids? Go round. No sharp turns, easy to supervise, and you can usually find "splash pads" that fit the radius perfectly.
Athletic goals? Get a narrow oval or a rectangle.
Tight budget? Stay away from ovals. The extra cost of the bracing and the more difficult installation usually isn't worth it if you’re just looking to cool off on a Tuesday in July.
The "Deck Factor"
You have to think about the deck. A round pool is a nightmare to build a deck around if you want it to look "finished." You’re cutting dozens of tiny angles to follow the curve. A rectangular or oval pool allows for straight joists and easy planking. If you're hiring a contractor, they might charge you a "headache tax" for a circular deck.
Beyond the shape: Depth and bottom contours
While we talk about "shapes" in terms of the perimeter, don't forget the bottom. Most above ground pools have a flat bottom. It’s simple. It’s safe.
However, some premium oval and circular pools allow for a "dig out." This is a hopper bottom that gives you a deeper area (maybe 6 or 7 feet) in the center. If you want to actually "dive" (though you should be extremely careful with this in any above ground pool), you need that depth. This changes the liner requirements significantly. You can’t just stretch a standard liner into a deep hole; you need an "expandable" liner designed for the extra tension.
Maintenance nightmares nobody tells you about
Let's talk about the "dead zones." In any pool shape that isn't a perfect circle, you will have spots where the water stagnates.
- In ovals, the "ends" often get less flow than the middle.
- In rectangles, the corners are magnets for algae.
- In kidney shapes, the "indent" often traps floating leaves and pollen.
To fix this, you usually need a better filtration system or a robotic cleaner that is specifically programmed to handle 90-degree angles. If you buy a cheap suction-side cleaner for a rectangular pool, don't be surprised when it gets stuck in the corner and just sits there for three hours while the rest of the pool stays dirty.
Finalizing the backyard vision
The "best" shape is the one that leaves you enough room to actually live in your yard. I’ve seen people install a pool so large they can no longer walk around it to reach the garden hose. You want at least 3 feet of clearance around the entire perimeter for maintenance, vacuuming, and safety checks.
Check your local zoning laws too. Some towns measure the "setback" from the widest point of the pool. If you have an oval pool with 3-foot buttresses, your "pool" is effectively 6 feet wider than the actual water surface. This has tripped up more homeowners than I can count.
Actionable Next Steps
- Stake it out: Don't just measure. Take a can of landscape spray paint or a long garden hose and actually draw the shape on your grass. Leave it there for a week. See how it affects your walk to the trash cans or the grill.
- Check the slope: Above ground pools require a level surface. A 24-foot round pool is much easier to level on a slight slope than a 15x30 oval. If your yard drops more than 6 inches across the span of the pool, prepare for significant excavation costs.
- Consult a deck builder first: If you plan on adding a deck later, get a quote for the deck based on the pool shape before you buy the pool. You might find that the money you "saved" by getting a cheap round pool is immediately eaten up by the high cost of a curved deck.
- Verify liner availability: If you go with a non-standard shape (like a Grecian or a specific brand's "proprietary" curve), call a third-party liner manufacturer and ask if they stock that size. You don't want to be beholden to one single company for parts for the next 15 years.
- Review the pump specs: Make sure the pump and filter included with the pool are rated for the gallonage of that specific shape. Rectangles often hold more water than you’d expect, and an undersized pump will lead to a green pool by mid-August.
Choosing the right above ground swimming pool shapes is a balance of physics, finance, and furniture. Take the time to map it out. Your future self, standing there with a skimmer net in hand, will thank you.