Honestly, if you've been following the New York Giants this season, you know the Abdul Carter experience has been a total roller coaster. One minute he’s looking like the second coming of Micah Parsons, and the next, everyone is refreshing their feed for an Abdul Carter injury update because he’s popped up on the report with something new.
It's been a lot.
The kid was the third overall pick for a reason. He’s fast. Like, "shouldn't be that big and move that quick" fast. But his rookie year in 2025 wasn't exactly the smooth sailing fans in East Rutherford were hoping for when they turned in the card. Between a lingering shoulder issue from his Penn State days and some mid-season hamstring drama, Carter’s health has been the primary talking point of the Giants' defense.
The Hamstring Scare in Denver and the "Flight Factor"
Back in October, we got a real taste of how quickly things can go sideways. Carter was cruising, looking healthy, and then—boom. He shows up as "questionable" right before a road trip to Denver.
What’s wild is that he practiced fully on Wednesday and Thursday. Then Friday hits, and suddenly his hamstring is tight. Ian Rapoport reported that the four-hour flight to Colorado actually made the injury worse because he was sitting still for so long.
Can you imagine? You're a world-class athlete and a plane ride almost takes you out of the game. He ended up being a game-time decision. He played, but you could tell he wasn't 100%. He was on a "pitch count," mostly sticking to pass-rush situations rather than chasing guys down on special teams.
A Quick Look at the Rookie Campaign
- Total Tackles: 43
- Sacks: 4.0 (A bit lower than expected, but he came on late)
- Quarterback Hits: 23 (This is where he actually dominated)
- Forced Fumbles: 2
The stats don't tell the whole story. While 4.0 sacks might look "just okay" for a top-three pick, he was actually 11th among all NFL edge defenders in total pressures. He was getting there; he just wasn't always closing the deal.
That Lingering Shoulder and the Foot Stress Reaction
If we're being real, the Abdul Carter injury update cycle actually started before he even put on a Giants jersey.
Remember the Fiesta Bowl against Boise State? He went out early with a left shoulder injury. He tried to come back with a sleeve on his arm, but he was clearly gimping. Then, right as he’s heading into the NFL Combine in early 2025, doctors find a stress reaction in his right foot.
Everyone panicked.
There was talk of surgery. Drew Rosenhaus, his agent, had to go on a media blitz to convince teams he wouldn't need a screw in his foot. Luckily, he didn't. He avoided the surgery, healed up, and the Giants took the gamble anyway.
The Late-Season Illness and Week 18 Status
Fast forward to the end of the 2025 season. Just when it looked like he was hitting his stride—tallying 3.5 sacks in the final five games—an illness swept through the Giants' locker room.
In the final week of December 2025, Carter missed back-to-back practices. People were worried he’d miss the season finale against the Cowboys. Thankfully, he cleared the protocol and returned to practice on Friday, January 2, 2026. He played in that Week 18 game without an injury designation, finally showing that when he’s healthy, he’s a nightmare for offensive tackles.
💡 You might also like: Boston Celtics Schedule 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
What Most People Get Wrong About His Health
A lot of folks think Carter is "injury-prone."
That’s a bit of a stretch. If you look at the "injuries," they've mostly been freak occurrences. A stress reaction from overtraining, a shoulder stinger in a bowl game, and a hamstring that didn't like a long flight.
The real concern for the Giants hasn't been his durability as much as his consistency. During the middle of the season, he went 11 straight weeks without a sack. Some of that was health-related, sure, but there were also reports about him needing to "grow up" and handle the professional side of the game better. Interim coach Mike Kafka even benched him briefly for being late to team activities.
Why 2026 Looks Different
Now that we’re in the early weeks of 2026, the focus has shifted from "is he hurt?" to "how high is the ceiling?"
Kayvon Thibodeaux’s shoulder surgery late in the '25 season actually forced Carter to play more snaps, and he thrived. He finished the year as one of the top weekly edge defenders, according to Ourlads. He’s finally had a full year in an NFL strength and conditioning program, which is huge for a guy who was basically playing linebacker at Penn State just two years ago.
The "illness" that took him out for a few days in late December is ancient history. He’s currently healthy and heading into a crucial offseason where he doesn't have to rehab a major surgery for the first time in a while.
What to Watch For Next
If you’re tracking his status for your dynasty league or just as a Giants fan, keep an eye on his weight. He played at about 248 pounds this year, but there’s talk he might want to bulk up to 255 to hold up better against the run.
Also, watch the coaching staff. With Kafka taking a bigger role in his development, Carter is being held to a much higher standard off the field. If he stays healthy and stays on time, he’s an easy double-digit sack candidate for next year.
Next Steps for Following the Situation
Stay tuned to the official Giants injury reports during the upcoming OTAs in the spring. You should specifically look for any mention of that right foot; while it didn't require surgery last year, stress reactions can sometimes flare up if the workload increases too quickly. For now, he is a full "go" with no active limitations.