The visual of Aaron Rodgers in a black and gold jersey still feels a bit like a fever dream, even after an entire season. But reality hit hard on Monday night. As the rain—or maybe it was just the collective tears of the Yinzer faithful—fell at Acrisure Stadium, the Aaron Rodgers Pittsburgh Steelers era seemingly hit its expiration date.
It wasn't supposed to end with a 30-6 blowout loss to the Houston Texans in the Wild Card round.
✨ Don't miss: The Notre Dame Logo Before and After: Why the 2024 Refresh Sparked Such a Massive Debate
Honestly, the whole thing was a massive gamble from the jump. When Rodgers signed that one-year deal back in June 2025, people called it a marriage of convenience. The Steelers needed a pulse at quarterback. Rodgers needed a coach who wouldn't try to "over-manage" his eccentricities. For a while, it worked. They won the AFC North. Rodgers threw for over 3,300 yards. Then, the wheels didn't just fall off—they disintegrated.
What Really Happened With the Aaron Rodgers Pittsburgh Steelers Season?
If you looked at the stats alone, you might think it was a success. 24 touchdowns. Only 7 interceptions. That’s vintage Rodgers efficiency, right? Sorta.
The truth is a lot messier. Rodgers, at 42, showed every bit of his age. His pocket presence, once his greatest superpower, was basically non-existent by December. According to Pro Football Focus, his average time to throw (2.58 seconds) was the lowest of his entire career. He wasn't dissecting defenses; he was getting rid of the ball because he didn't want to get hit.
That led to some weird offensive splits. Kenneth Gainwell and Jaylen Warren ended up being the primary targets because Rodgers was constantly checking down. It kept the chains moving, but it didn't win games against elite teams.
Then came the bombshell. Mike Tomlin stepped down.
🔗 Read more: Dodgers Game July 3 Explained: Why This Specific Matchup Felt Different
On Tuesday, the news broke that Tomlin is resigning after 19 seasons. This changes everything. Art Rooney II didn't mince words during Wednesday's press conference, stating quite plainly that Rodgers came to Pittsburgh specifically to play for Mike. With Tomlin gone, the incentive for a 42-year-old legend to stick around for a "rebuilding" phase under a new coach is basically zero.
The Mike Tomlin Connection
You've probably seen the clip of Rodgers and Tomlin sharing a "look" back when Rodgers was still in Green Bay. That mutual respect was the entire foundation of this 2025 run.
Rodgers spent most of the season defending Tomlin against the "Twitter experts" and media talking heads. He called the idea of Tomlin being on the hot seat an "absolute joke." There's a deep, old-school bond there that you just don't see in the modern NFL very often.
- The Culture Factor: Rodgers mentioned multiple times that Pittsburgh's "history of excellence" reminded him of the early days in Green Bay.
- The Freedom: Tomlin allowed Rodgers to be Rodgers—darkness retreats, podcast appearances, and all.
- The Ending: If Monday was Rodgers' final game, his last pass being a pick-six is a brutal way to go out.
Why a 2026 Return is Unlikely
The Steelers are facing a massive identity crisis. They have 25 free agents. They don't have a head coach. And they have a quarterback who is currently contemplating retirement in between segments on the Pat McAfee Show.
The roster is a bit of a jigsaw puzzle with missing pieces. While players like Cam Heyward and DK Metcalf (who the Steelers grabbed in a mid-season move) have voiced their desire for Rodgers to return, the front office might have different plans. Rooney hinted that the next head coach will have a massive say in the "quarterback plan," and most young, incoming coaches want their own guy. They want a rookie they can mold, not a first-ballot Hall of Famer who might retire before the first frost of November.
Currently, the Steelers have Mason Rudolph and Will Howard under contract for 2026. Neither screams "Super Bowl contender," but they represent a cheaper, younger bridge to the future.
Practical Realities for the Offseason
If you're a Steelers fan trying to figure out what's next, here is the cold, hard prose of the situation. The team's cap space is tight. Rodgers would likely command a significant salary even on a one-year "farewell" deal. Plus, his mobility is gone. In the playoff loss to Houston, he was sacked four times and looked stationary.
The "win now" window that opened when Rodgers signed has slammed shut.
Actionable Insights for the Steelers Faithful
So, what do you do now that the Aaron Rodgers Pittsburgh Steelers experiment is likely over?
- Watch the Coaching Search: The next hire dictates everything. If the Steelers go with a defensive-minded coach, expect a heavy run-game focus and a safe, veteran QB like Geno Smith or Kirk Cousins if they hit the market. If they go with an offensive guru, keep an eye on the NFL Draft.
- Accept the Youth Movement: With Tomlin and likely Rodgers gone, the "Steelers Way" is going to look different. It’s time to stop looking for the next Ben Roethlisberger and start looking for a modern, mobile playmaker.
- Appreciate the 2025 Title: Don't let the playoff blowout sour the fact that they won the AFC North. In a year where everyone counted them out, they remained relevant into January. That's the Tomlin-Rodgers effect, even if it was short-lived.
The Rodgers era in Pittsburgh was a beautiful, chaotic, and ultimately frustrating blip in the team's long history. It proved that you can't just plug a legend into a flawed roster and expect a trophy. But man, for those few weeks in October when they were 4-1, it sure was fun to watch. Now, the real work begins.