The empty chair. It’s the image that basically defined an entire season of reality TV and, honestly, a whole decade of sports tabloid fodder. When Jordan Rodgers stepped onto the set of The Bachelorette in 2016, he wasn't just another former athlete looking for love; he was the younger brother of one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game. But as the season unfolded, it became clear that being aaron rodgers brother bachelor contestant wasn't about highlight reels or Super Bowl rings. It was about a family that had completely fractured in the public eye.
People still talk about it. Even now, in 2026, with Aaron nearing the end of his career and Jordan settled into a life far away from the NFL sidelines, that "hometown date" remains a masterclass in awkward reality television. You remember it: JoJo Fletcher walking into a house in Chico, California, and seeing two vacant seats at the dinner table. They were meant for Aaron and his then-girlfriend Olivia Munn. They stayed empty. It was a loud, silent statement that the Rodgers family was not okay.
The "Bullsh**t Show" and the Fight for Privacy
For years, Aaron Rodgers kept his mouth shut. He’s always been a guy who values control—control of the ball, control of his narrative, and especially control of his personal life. But the silence finally broke. In the late 2024 Netflix docuseries Enigma, the quarterback didn't hold back. He called the whole Bachelorette appearance a "bullsh**t show." He wasn't just annoyed; he was livid.
Aaron’s side of the story is pretty simple, if you believe him. He claims he was never even invited to that infamous dinner. According to him, the "empty chair" stunt was a calculated move by his family and the show’s producers to drum up drama. He basically accused Jordan of using the family rift to get famous. "His words, not mine," Aaron noted, referencing a conversation where Jordan allegedly admitted the show was a career move.
Jordan, meanwhile, has always maintained he was just being honest. He told JoJo on camera that he and Aaron "don't really have that much of a relationship." He framed it as a difference in how they "chose to do life." Jordan stayed close to his parents and his older brother, Luke. Aaron went his own way.
📖 Related: Lindsay Lohan Leak: What Really Happened with the List and the Scams
Why the Rift Actually Started
If you think this was all about a reality show, you're only seeing the tip of the iceberg. The roots of the drama go back much further, likely to 2014. That was the year Aaron started dating actress Olivia Munn. Rumors swirled for years that the family didn't approve of her, or that she was "gatekeeping" Aaron from his parents.
- The 2014 Blowup: Reports suggest a massive argument happened before a game in Tampa. Olivia allegedly told Aaron’s parents they shouldn't attend the game, and Aaron backed her up.
- The Religious Divide: This is a big one. The Rodgers family is deeply, traditionally Christian. Aaron has been very vocal about moving away from that "dogmatic" upbringing. In 2020, he called his childhood spirituality "merit-based," which his family reportedly viewed as a direct slap in the face.
- The Wildfires: In 2018, things got petty on X (formerly Twitter). Aaron donated $1 million to California wildfire relief. Instead of a "good job, bro," Jordan publicly called him out for not checking on their own mother during the fires.
It’s messy. It’s human. And it’s exactly why the aaron rodgers brother bachelor connection remains a top search result whenever either of them does anything newsworthy.
Jordan Rodgers: Life After the Final Rose
While the feud simmered, Jordan actually made good on the "love" part of the show. Most Bachelor couples last about as long as a glass of champagne in a hot tub, but Jordan and JoJo Fletcher defied the odds. They didn't rush it. They stayed engaged for six years, dealing with pandemic delays and the constant shadow of the Rodgers name.
They finally tied the knot in May 2022 at a vineyard in California. Guess who wasn't there? Aaron. It wasn't a surprise, but it solidified the fact that the brothers were living in two different universes.
👉 See also: Kaley Cuoco Tit Size: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Transformation
Fast forward to the end of 2025. Jordan and JoJo welcomed their first child, a daughter named Romy Blair, just before Christmas. It was a "rainbow baby" for them, following a public struggle with starting a family. While Jordan is posting "Dad goals" content on Instagram, Aaron is playing out the twilight of his career in a different city, with a different family dynamic entirely.
The Secret Marriage of 2025
The irony of the whole "private vs. public" debate hit a peak last year. In June 2025, Aaron Rodgers revealed he had quietly gotten married. He didn't post a 10-slide gallery or do a People magazine spread. He just showed up at the Kentucky Derby with a wedding ring.
His wife, a woman named Brittani, is reportedly the "anti-celebrity." Aaron has gone on record saying she wants absolutely nothing to do with the spotlight. She’s been called a "phantom" because there are virtually no public photos of her.
But here’s the kicker: Jordan and his parents found out about the wedding from the internet. Just like everyone else. A source told the Daily Mail that Jordan and JoJo were "angry" that Aaron skipped their wedding, so they didn't feel the need to "twist themselves up" over his secret nuptials. The cycle of estrangement just keeps spinning.
✨ Don't miss: Dale Mercer Net Worth: Why the RHONY Star is Richer Than You Think
Where They Stand Today: Is Reconciliation Possible?
Honestly, it looks like a stalemate. In his recent interviews, Aaron sounds more at peace than he did five years ago. He says he has "love, respect, and gratitude" for his parents for how they raised him. He even acknowledges that Jordan "won" his season of the show and seems happy. He just doesn't want to be part of it.
Jordan seems to have found his own identity. He’s a successful college football analyst for the SEC Network. He’s a dad. He’s no longer just "the brother." He’s his own man, and that man doesn't seem to have a slot on his calendar for a brother who doesn't reach out.
Actionable Takeaways for the Fans
If you're following this saga, there are a few things to keep in mind about how these public feuds work:
- Don't believe every "source": Tabloids love to pit Olivia Munn or Shailene Woodley or Brittani against the Rodgers parents. Usually, the issues are much deeper than whoever someone is dating.
- Public vs. Private values: This is a classic case of what happens when one family member wants to be an island and the others want to be a community. Neither is "wrong," but they are incompatible.
- The "Success" Tax: Aaron's fame changed the gravity of the family. Jordan felt the pressure to live up to it; Aaron felt the pressure to escape the expectations.
The aaron rodgers brother bachelor story isn't just about a TV show. It’s a decade-long case study in how fame, religion, and personality clashes can tear apart even the most "All-American" family. As of early 2026, the two chairs remain empty, and nobody seems to be rushing to sit down.
To truly understand the depth of this rift, you have to look at the timeline of Aaron’s public comments on religion—specifically his 2020 interview on the Pretty Intense podcast—which many insiders cite as the point of no return for his devout parents.