Ever walked into a shop in Intercourse or Bird-in-Hand and felt like you stepped back two centuries? It’s a trip. Most people heading to Lancaster County are looking for that specific mix of handmade quilts, horse-drawn buggies, and the kind of butter that makes your heart skip a beat—literally. If you’ve spent any time researching the Pennsylvania Dutch, you’ve probably come across A is for Amish. It’s more than just a catchy phrase or a children’s book title; it’s a gateway into a culture that is notoriously private yet incredibly visible.
People get the Amish wrong all the time. They think it’s a monolithic block of people living exactly like it’s 1693. Honestly, it’s way more complicated than that.
Why A is for Amish is Still the Starting Point
When we talk about A is for Amish, we are usually talking about the iconic alphabet book by Nancy Maria Grande, but the concept has evolved into a broader cultural shorthand. It represents the "Amish 101" for the millions of tourists who descend on the East Coast every year. You see the book in gift shops next to jars of chow-chow and hand-carved wooden whistles. It’s the primer.
But here is the thing: the "A" doesn't just stand for Amish. It stands for Ordnung.
The Ordnung is the unwritten set of rules that governs every single aspect of Amish life. You won't find it in a bookstore. You won't find it on a PDF. It’s a living, breathing oral tradition. It dictates the width of a hat brim and whether or not a tractor can have rubber tires. In some districts, a tractor is fine for belt power but can't be driven on the road. Why? Because the goal isn't just to be "old-fashioned." The goal is to keep the community together. If you can drive a tractor to the next town, you aren't relying on your neighbor and his team of horses.
The Amish aren't anti-technology. They are pro-community. There is a massive difference.
The Reality of the "Simple" Life
The "simple life" is actually incredibly exhausting. I’ve talked to folks who think moving to a farm and ditching their iPhone would be a vacation. It’s not. It’s 4:30 AM wake-up calls. It's the smell of manure that never truly leaves your clothes. It’s manual labor that would break most of us by noon.
The A is for Amish lifestyle is built on the theology of Gelassenheit.
This is a German word that doesn't have a perfect English translation. It’s basically a mix of "yieldedness," humility, and surrender. It is the exact opposite of the modern American "main character energy." In our world, we are told to stand out. In the Amish world, you are told to fit in. You are a small part of a big, eternal whole.
The Rumspringa Myth vs. Reality
We have to talk about Rumspringa because television has absolutely ruined the public's understanding of it. You’ve seen the "reality" shows. Kids going to Vegas, drinking heavily, and acting out. While that can happen, it’s the exception, not the rule.
For most, Rumspringa is just a period where the rules of the church don't technically apply because the youth hasn't been baptized yet. It’s a time for finding a spouse. It's a time for maybe wearing a store-bought shirt or driving a car. But here is the kicker: about 85% to 90% of Amish youth choose to be baptized and stay in the community.
Think about that.
In a world of TikTok and infinite choices, nine out of ten kids choose the buggy and the 4:30 AM wake-up call. That tells you that the community offers something modern society is starving for: a sense of belonging.
Business, Buggies, and the Modern World
The Amish are some of the most "accidental" successful entrepreneurs in the country. Because they don't use the traditional grid, they’ve had to innovate.
- Pneumatic tools: Many Amish workshops run entirely on compressed air.
- Solar power: You’ll see solar panels on the roofs of barns to charge the batteries for the buggy lights.
- LPG (Liquid Petroleum Gas): This is how they run their refrigerators and stoves.
They are master capitalists who don't want to be part of the consumerist rat race. It's a paradox. You’ll see an Amish-run construction crew using high-end power tools (modified to run on air) to build a multi-million dollar suburban home. They are highly sought after because their work ethic is legendary. They don't cut corners.
If you are looking for A is for Amish craftsmanship, you are looking for furniture that will outlive your grandchildren. It’s not "shabby chic." It’s solid oak, mortise-and-tenon joinery, and a finish that feels like glass.
Education and the 1972 Turning Point
One of the biggest misconceptions is that the Amish are uneducated. They are actually very educated—just not in the way the state usually wants.
They go to school until the 8th grade. After that, they enter a "vocational" period. In 1972, the Supreme Court case Wisconsin v. Yoder basically gave them the legal right to stop formal schooling at 14. The court recognized that their "informal" education—learning to farm, build, cook, and manage a household—was perfectly sufficient for their way of life.
They don't need calculus to run a dairy farm. They need to know how to manage a herd, repair a plow, and keep a ledger.
Common Questions About the "A is for Amish" Culture
Do they pay taxes?
Yes. Every single one. They pay income tax, property tax, and sales tax. The only thing they don't pay into is Social Security. They have a religious exemption because they believe the community should take care of its own elderly. They don't take money from the government, so they don't put money in. It’s a fair trade.
Why no photos?
It’s not because they think a camera will steal their soul. It’s about the "graven image" thing in the Bible, but more specifically, it’s about pride. Posing for a photo is seen as an act of vanity. If you’re visiting Lancaster or Holmes County, please, don’t shove a camera in their faces. It’s incredibly disrespectful.
Can anyone join?
Technically, yes. Practically? Almost never. It’s called being a "seeker." You’d have to give up your car, your electricity, your clothing, and your entire social circle. Most people can't last a week.
The Amish and the Environment
There is a lot of talk lately about sustainability. The Amish have been doing "farm-to-table" since before it was a marketing slogan. But they aren't necessarily "green" in the way a Portland hipster is green.
They use pesticides if they have to. They use diesel engines to run their milk chillers. They are pragmatists. However, because they use horses, their carbon footprint is naturally lower. They rotate crops. They preserve land. In many ways, the A is for Amish philosophy is the ultimate form of conservation—conserving a way of life that doesn't depend on a fragile global supply chain.
What You Can Learn from the Amish Way
You don't have to sell your car and buy a bonnet to take something away from this.
The core of the A is for Amish lifestyle is intentionality. Most of us live our lives on autopilot. We buy things because an algorithm told us to. We spend four hours a day scrolling through Reels. The Amish decide, as a group, what enters their homes.
When a new technology comes out, the church elders look at it and ask: "Will this bring us closer together, or pull us apart?"
If the answer is "pull us apart," they say no. Imagine if we did that with social media fifteen years ago.
Finding the Authentic Experience
If you want to see the real side of this culture, get off the main drag. Avoid the places with the giant statues and the neon signs.
- Look for roadside stands. This is where the real food is. If it’s a cardboard sign at the end of a gravel driveway, pull over.
- Visit a dry goods store. This is where the Amish shop. You’ll see the bolts of fabric used for their clothes and the massive jars of bulk spices.
- Go on a Tuesday or Wednesday. Weekends are for tourists. Mid-week is for real life.
The A is for Amish story is still being written. The population is actually growing quite fast—doubling roughly every 20 years. They aren't disappearing. They are expanding into states like Kentucky, Montana, and even South America.
✨ Don't miss: How to Make a Airplane: Why Most Paper Pilots Fail and the Physics That Actually Matter
They are proving that you can thrive in the 21st century without being owned by it.
Practical Steps for Engaging with Amish Culture
If you're planning a trip or just want to learn more, here's how to do it right:
- Read "The Riddle of Amish Culture" by Donald Kraybill. He is the leading expert on the subject. If you want facts instead of myths, he’s your guy.
- Support the economy directly. Buy the quilt. Buy the eggs. Buy the table. The money goes directly to a family, not a corporate headquarters.
- Respect the Sabbath. Everything—and I mean everything—is closed on Sunday. Don't be the person knocking on a farmhouse door on a Sunday morning asking for directions.
- Check your speed. Buggies are slow. If you’re driving in Amish country, slow down. Car-buggy accidents are often fatal, and they happen because drivers are impatient.
Living "Amish" isn't about the absence of things. It's about the presence of people. That is the most important lesson you can take from the A is for Amish philosophy. Whether you're in the heart of Ohio or the suburbs of New York, choosing community over convenience is a radical, powerful act.
Take a look at your own "Ordnung." What rules do you live by? Are they helping you connect with the people you love, or are they just keeping you busy? Sometimes, the simplest way is actually the most revolutionary.
Actionable Insight: Next time you are tempted to buy a mass-produced piece of furniture or food, seek out a local craftsman or farmer. It doesn't have to be Amish, but adopting that "A is for Amish" mindset of quality and local support changes how you interact with your own community. Start by turning off your phone for two hours this Sunday and see what happens to your stress levels. You might find that the "simple life" isn't as out of reach as you thought.