It is hard to wrap your head around the Jan Broberg story. Honestly, if you saw it in a fictional script, you’d probably roll your eyes and call it unrealistic. But the movie A Friend of the Family—and the various limited series and documentaries that preceded it—proves that truth isn't just stranger than fiction; it’s often more terrifying. Robert Berchtold didn't just kidnap a girl once. He did it twice. And he managed to convince her parents to help him do it.
When people search for information on the movie A Friend of the Family, they are usually looking for the Peacock miniseries starring Jake Lacy, or perhaps the 2017 documentary Abducted in Plain Sight. While the 2022 scripted version took the world by storm, the narrative has been shifting through the cultural zeitgeist for decades. It's a case study in grooming, psychological manipulation, and the utter failure of a community to protect a child from a monster who looked like a "nice guy."
The Reality Behind the Movie A Friend of the Family
Let’s be real for a second. The Broberg family, Bob and Mary Ann, have faced an incredible amount of scrutiny over the years. People watch the movie A Friend of the Family and scream at their screens. How could they be so blind? How did they let him back into the house? To understand the movie, you have to understand the era. We're talking about Pocatello, Idaho, in the 1970s. It was a tight-knit, religious community where your neighbor wasn't just a neighbor; they were practically kin. Robert Berchtold, or "B," as he was known, was a master of finding the cracks in people's lives. He didn't just target Jan; he targeted the entire family structure. He looked for the insecurities in the parents and filled them.
The 2022 series does a better job than most at showing the "slow burn." It wasn't an overnight abduction. It was years of tiny concessions. Berchtold used a mix of "alien technology" stories (yes, really) and religious manipulation to make Jan believe her kidnapping was a mission to save the planet. It sounds absurd now, but to a twelve-year-old child being drugged and manipulated by a trusted adult figure, it was her entire reality.
The Psychology of "B"
Jake Lacy’s portrayal of Berchtold is chilling because he isn't a mustache-twirling villain. He's charming. He's helpful. He fixes things around the house. This is the core of what makes the A Friend of the Family narrative so effective—it highlights the "neighbor next door" trope that defines true crime horror.
Psychologists often point to this case as a textbook example of complex grooming. Berchtold used a technique called "isolation through integration." By making himself indispensable to the parents, he gained unfettered access to the children. He even went as far as to have sexual encounters with both parents to ensure their silence and create a "mutually assured destruction" scenario if anyone went to the police. It’s a level of deviousness that most people can't even fathom, which is why the Brobergs were so ill-equipped to handle it.
💡 You might also like: Doomsday Castle TV Show: Why Brent Sr. and His Kids Actually Built That Fortress
Comparing the Series to the Real Events
While the movie A Friend of the Family takes some creative liberties for pacing, the most "unbelievable" parts are actually the ones that are 100% true.
- The Mission: Berchtold really did record tapes telling Jan she was half-alien and needed to procreate with him to save her "home planet."
- The Second Kidnapping: After being caught the first time, Berchtold was somehow allowed back into the family's orbit, leading to a second abduction in 1976 where he took her to California and enrolled her in school under a false name.
- The FBI’s Role: The investigation was hampered by the fact that the Brobergs initially lied to protect Berchtold, fearing their own secrets would come out.
There is a specific scene in the series where the parents are essentially forced to choose between their reputation and their daughter. It’s a gut-wrenching moment because it reflects the social pressures of the time. The Mormon church plays a background role here—not as a villain, but as a culture where "keeping sweet" and maintaining a perfect image often took precedence over addressing uncomfortable truths.
Why Jan Broberg is Involved Now
One thing that sets the movie A Friend of the Family apart from other true crime cash-ins is Jan Broberg’s actual involvement. She served as a producer.
Jan has been incredibly vocal about her story, not for the fame, but to change how we talk about grooming. She wants people to stop blaming her parents and start looking at how predators operate. If you watch her interviews today, she speaks with a level of grace that is frankly staggering. She acknowledges that her parents were victims of a sociopath, too.
Critics of the series often argue that it's too sympathetic to Bob and Mary Ann. But Jan argues that if you make them the villains, you miss the point. If a "good family" can be dismantled this easily, anyone can.
📖 Related: Don’t Forget Me Little Bessie: Why James Lee Burke’s New Novel Still Matters
Impact on the True Crime Genre
The popularity of the movie A Friend of the Family signaled a shift in how we consume these stories. We are moving away from the "who-dun-it" and toward the "how-did-they-do-it." The horror isn't in the mystery; it's in the mechanics of the manipulation.
We see this in other recent hits like The Act or Candy. The focus is on the domestic space. The kitchen table. The backyard barbecue. These are the places where the most damage is done. The cinematic style of A Friend of the Family uses bright, saturated 70s colors to contrast with the darkness of the plot. It makes the whole thing feel like a fever dream.
Fact-Checking the "Alien" Narrative
You’ll hear people joke about the alien plot point, but it's important to realize how Berchtold used it. He used high-pitched voices and "transmissions" played over speakers in his motorhome. He told Jan that if she didn't obey, her family would be "vaporized."
For a kid in the 70s, without the internet or easy access to information, these threats were visceral. Berchtold essentially created a two-person cult. This is a detail the movie A Friend of the Family handles with surprising sensitivity, showing how a child's imagination can be weaponized against them.
Lessons We Haven't Learned Yet
Despite the fame of this case, grooming remains a misunderstood concept. Most people still think of "stranger danger." They teach their kids not to get into a van with a man offering candy. But the movie A Friend of the Family shows that the real danger is often the person who is already in your living room. It's the coach, the teacher, the uncle, or the "friend of the family."
👉 See also: Donnalou Stevens Older Ladies: Why This Viral Anthem Still Hits Different
Social media has only made this easier. While Berchtold had to move in next door, modern predators only need to move into a teenager's DMs. The tactics—isolation, "us against the world" mentality, and the slow erosion of boundaries—remain identical.
Actionable Takeaways for Parents and Advocates
Watching the movie A Friend of the Family is an exercise in frustration, but it should also be an exercise in vigilance. Here is how to apply the lessons from the Broberg case to the modern day:
- Redefine "Nice": Being "nice" is a social skill, not a character trait. Predators are almost always described as "the nicest guy in the world" before they are caught.
- Monitor "Special" Bonds: If an adult is seeking a "best friend" relationship with a child that excludes the parents, that is a massive red flag. There is no reason for an adult to have a private, secret-filled relationship with a minor.
- Believe the First Time: One of the biggest tragedies in the Broberg case was the second kidnapping. If someone shows you who they are, believe them. Forgiveness is a virtue, but it shouldn't come at the cost of safety.
- Open Communication: The only weapon against grooming is a home where no topic is taboo. If a child feels they will be punished or "shamed" for something that happened, they will keep the predator's secrets to protect the family.
The legacy of the movie A Friend of the Family isn't just about the shocking events of the 70s. It’s a reminder that the institutions we trust—church, police, and even our own families—can be manipulated by a dedicated liar. Jan Broberg’s survival and her subsequent life as an actress and advocate is a testament to human resilience, but the story remains a dark warning about the masks people wear.
If you are looking to dive deeper into the specifics of the court cases or the psychological profiles of the real individuals involved, you can find extensive records through the Jan Broberg Foundation or by revisiting the court transcripts from the 1970s trials which are now part of public record. Knowing the signs is the first step in ensuring a story like this never happens in your neighborhood.