.jpg)
You know those movies that just kind of sit in the back of your brain for a decade? They aren't the blockbusters everyone talks about at dinner parties. They aren't the high-budget MCU spectacles. A Bag of Hammers movie is exactly that kind of film. Released in 2011 after a debut at SXSW, it’s a strange, scruffy, and surprisingly emotional comedy-drama that most people missed.
Honestly, the premise sounds like something you’d find in a bargain bin, but it’s way smarter than that. It’s about two best friends, Ben and Alan, who are basically "professional" car thieves. They pose as valets at funerals—which is a pretty dark hustle, if you think about it—and then just drive off with the cars. It’s low-stakes crime for high-stakes slackers. But everything shifts when a kid named Kelsey enters the picture.
The Weird Tonal Shift of A Bag of Hammers Movie
If you go into this expecting a straightforward bromance comedy, you’re going to get whiplash. The first twenty minutes are breezy. Jason Ritter and Jake Sandvig have this natural, fast-talking chemistry that feels like they’ve been friends since kindergarten. They argue about hypothetical fights (Ultimate Warrior always wins, apparently) and navigate their weird life in a sunny California suburb.
Then, the movie hits you with a ton of bricks.
The story takes a sharp turn when their neighbor, a struggling single mother named Lynette (played by Carrie Preston), dies by suicide. Suddenly, these two man-children are left with her 12-year-old son, Kelsey. The movie stops being a goofy caper and becomes a meditation on what it means to actually grow up. Director Brian Crano takes a massive risk here. He mixes indie whimsy with some really heavy, grounded trauma. Some critics at the time, like those at The Hollywood Reporter, thought the vibes didn't quite gel. They felt the "muddled" structure held it back.
💡 You might also like: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
But for a lot of fans? That’s the point. Life doesn't stay in one genre. One minute you're joking with your best friend, and the next, you're trying to figure out how to keep a kid out of the foster care system. It’s messy.
A Cast That Punches Above Its Weight
For a small $2 million indie film, the cast is kind of ridiculous. Look at these names:
- Jason Ritter: He’s the heart of the movie. If you’ve seen him in Joan of Arcadia or Parenthood, you know he does "vulnerable nice guy" better than almost anyone.
- Rebecca Hall: She plays Alan’s sister, Mel. She’s the voice of reason, and while she’s arguably overqualified for a "worried sister" role, she gives the movie a much-needed anchor.
- Chandler Canterbury: As Kelsey, he avoids the "annoying movie kid" trope. He’s quiet, observant, and clearly traumatized.
- Amanda Seyfried: She shows up in a brief, uncredited cameo as Ben’s ex-girlfriend. It’s a tiny role, but it adds to the feeling that this world has history.
The acting really saves the film from its own indie cliches. Even when the script feels a bit stilted—like a long speech Ben gives at a workplace later in the movie—the actors sell it. They make you care about these "unrepentant felons," as one reviewer called them.
The Johnny Flynn Soundtrack Factor
We have to talk about the music. If you’re a fan of folk music, you probably know Johnny Flynn. He wrote the entire score and the original songs for the film.
📖 Related: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
The music is almost a character itself. It’s twangy, acoustic, and deeply melancholic. Songs like "I Don’t Wanna Go" and "Flowers in My Garden" give the movie a timeless feel. It doesn't feel like a 2011 movie; it feels like a story that could happen anywhere, anytime. The soundtrack actually had its own life, getting a Record Store Day release on vinyl in 2012. It’s the kind of music that makes a sunny California afternoon feel incredibly lonely.
Why It Didn't Become a Massive Hit
Marketing a movie like this is a nightmare. Is it a comedy? Sorta. Is it a drama? Mostly. It sits in that "mumblecore-adjacent" space where it’s too polished to be true lo-fi but too weird to be mainstream.
Rex Reed, writing for the Observer at the time, was pretty brutal. He called it "baffled and unclear" and suggested it looked like it was composed of outtakes. It’s a fair critique if you’re looking for a tight, three-act structure. The ending, in particular, is a bit of a montage-heavy blur that leaves some viewers confused. Are these flashbacks? Are they alternate endings? The film doesn't hold your hand.
How to Watch It Today
If you want to track down A Bag of Hammers movie now, it’s actually pretty easy to find on streaming. You can usually find it for free (with ads) on platforms like The Roku Channel, Plex, or Vudu (Fandango at Home). If you want to skip the ads, it’s a cheap rental on Apple TV or Amazon.
👉 See also: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
It’s only 85 minutes long. In an era where every movie is three hours, there’s something refreshing about a film that gets in, breaks your heart, and gets out in under an hour and a half.
Practical Takeaways for Your Watchlist
- Don't expect a heist movie. Even though they steal cars, that’s just the background noise for a story about family.
- Watch for the chemistry. The banter between Ritter and Sandvig is the highlight.
- Prepare for a mood shift. It gets dark about 30 minutes in.
- Listen to the lyrics. Johnny Flynn’s songs often explain what the characters can't say out loud.
Ultimately, this isn't a perfect movie, but it's a sincere one. It deals with big, scary things like neglect and the cycle of poverty without being "preachy." It asks if two screw-ups can become good men just by deciding to show up for someone else. It's a small story about a "bag of hammers"—the heavy, bad stuff life throws at you—and how you carry it.
If you’re looking for a weekend watch that feels human and doesn't follow a formula, give this one a shot. It might just stay in the back of your brain for the next ten years, too.
To get the most out of the experience, try to find the original soundtrack on a streaming service after you watch; the lyrics to "Where My Father Went" hit a lot harder once you've seen the final frames of the film.