So, let's talk about the girl with the voice. If you followed 90 Day Fiancé Season 5, you definitely remember Evelyn Cormier. She was the 18-year-old from Claremont, New Hampshire, who had that incredibly deep, sultry singing voice and a very specific vision for her life. Honestly, her story was one of the most divisive in the franchise’s history. Some fans saw a young woman following her dreams and her heart, while others saw a teenager who was maybe a bit too stubborn for her own good.
Evelyn's journey with David Vázquez Zermeño, a man from Spain who was nine years her senior, wasn't your typical reality TV train wreck. It was more of a slow burn of cultural clashes, small-town pride, and the grueling reality of making a marriage work when you're barely out of high school. People still Google them constantly. Why? Because unlike the couples who scream at each other in hotel lobbies, Evelyn and David felt real. They felt like that couple you know from church who got married way too fast and everyone whispered about it at the potluck.
The Claremont Bubble and the Age Gap Debate
Claremont isn't just a place; in the world of 90 Day Fiancé, it was a character. Evelyn loved her hometown. She famously told David that there was "no such thing as a best crepe" in the world that could beat what they had in New Hampshire. It became a meme. It became a point of contention. David, who had lived in major European cities, was suddenly dropped into a quiet, snowy town where everyone knew Evelyn’s business.
The age gap was the elephant in the room. He was 27; she was 18. When they first met via social media—after David messaged her about her band—the optics were tough for viewers to swallow. However, Evelyn Cormier never blinked. She carried herself with a confidence that bordered on "I know better than you," which, to be fair, is how most 18-year-olds act, but most 18-year-olds aren't on national television.
Their wedding was beautiful, sure, but the tension regarding their living situation was palpable. David wanted the "American Dream" to look like a big city. Evelyn wanted it to look like the woods of New England.
Life After the Cameras Stopped Rolling
Most people think reality stars just vanish or become full-time influencers. Evelyn didn't do that. She doubled down on the music. In 2019, she took a massive risk and auditioned for American Idol.
🔗 Read more: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
It paid off.
She made it to the Top 14. Katy Perry actually called her voice "one of the most unique" she had ever heard. It was a huge validation for Evelyn, who had spent years being told by TLC fans that she was just a "small-town girl with a hobby." During her run on Idol, David was there in the wings, supporting her. For a moment, it looked like they were the ultimate success story. They moved to Los Angeles. They were chasing the dream. They were proving the haters wrong.
But L.A. is a long way from Claremont.
The Split Nobody—and Everybody—Saw Coming
In late 2021, the news broke. After four years of marriage, Evelyn and David were calling it quits. It wasn't just a "we're taking a break" post. It was a formal divorce announcement. Evelyn spoke to InTouch Weekly and other outlets, hinting that the relationship wasn't as perfect as it looked on Instagram. She mentioned "mental/emotional abuse" and a "passionless" marriage.
David, for his part, denied these allegations through his representation, stating he wished her the best but wouldn't engage in a public mudslinging match.
💡 You might also like: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
It was a messy end to a story that had started with so much "New Hampshire wholesome" energy. Fans were shocked, but if you look back at the footage from their season, the cracks were always there. They had fundamentally different views on where to live, how to handle their finances, and what "compromise" actually meant. You can't build a lifelong foundation on the fact that you both like the same indie folk music.
Where Is Evelyn Cormier Now?
She’s busy. Honestly, she’s busier than she ever was on TLC.
Evelyn has leaned fully into her identity as an artist. She’s released more music, including singles like "Yard Sale" and "In the Garden." She also got into acting, appearing in independent projects and even doing some voiceover work. If you check her social media today, the "90 Day" tag is largely gone from her bio. She’s rebranded. She’s a professional creative now.
She also found love again. She’s been open about her relationship with her boyfriend, Harrison, often posting about their adventures and how much more "aligned" she feels in this stage of her life. It’s a classic story of a first marriage serving as a massive, painful learning experience.
The Legacy of the "Claremont Queen"
Whether you loved her or found her annoying, Evelyn Cormier changed the way people look at the younger contestants on 90 Day Fiancé. She wasn't looking for a green card, and she wasn't looking for a sugar daddy. She was a girl who thought she knew exactly what she wanted at 18, only to realize at 23 that the world is a lot bigger than Claremont.
📖 Related: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
People still talk about her because she represents a very specific type of person: the overachiever who realizes that sometimes, being right isn't the same as being happy.
What You Can Learn From Evelyn’s Journey
If you’re following the lives of these reality stars for more than just the drama, there are some actual takeaways here.
- Location matters more than you think. If one partner is a "city mouse" and the other is a "country mouse," someone is going to end up resentful. David tried to love New Hampshire, but his heart wasn't in the quiet life.
- The "First Love" trap is real. Getting married at 18 is a massive gamble. The person you are at 18 is rarely the person you are at 25. Evelyn's evolution on American Idol showed a woman who was outgrowing her initial environment.
- Rebranding is possible. Evelyn successfully transitioned from "Reality TV Villain/Girl" to "Respected Musician." It took grit and a thick skin against internet trolls.
If you’re interested in following her current path, her music is available on all major streaming platforms. Watching her journey from a polarizing teenager to a self-assured woman in her mid-20s is actually a pretty fascinating study in human growth.
Check out her latest EP if you want to see how her sound has evolved since the TLC days. It’s a lot more polished, a bit more cynical, and way more authentic. She isn't the girl in the Claremont gazebo anymore. She's a woman who went through the reality TV ringer and came out the other side with her voice intact.