So, you’re 5'9". Maybe you’re looking at a chart in a doctor’s office or staring at a fitness app that’s flashing red numbers at you. It’s frustrating. Most of the time, we’re told there’s this "perfect" number we need to hit to be healthy, but honestly, that's kinda oversimplifying how human bodies actually work.
If you look at the standard charts, they’ll tell you that for someone standing five-foot-nine, the 5 9 ideal weight usually lands somewhere between 128 and 169 pounds. That’s a huge range. It’s a forty-pound gap! How can a single "ideal" cover a lean marathon runner and a heavy-set powerlifter? It can't. That’s why we need to talk about what these numbers actually mean and why your "ideal" might look nothing like your neighbor's, even if you're both the exact same height.
The BMI Problem and Why It Trips People Up
Most "ideal weight" calculators are just glorified Body Mass Index (BMI) tools. Created by Adolphe Quetelet in the 1830s—yeah, almost 200 years ago—BMI was never meant to diagnose the health of an individual person. It was a statistical tool for populations. For a 5'9" person, the BMI formula ($weight / height^2$) puts you in the "normal" category if you weigh between roughly 125 and 168 pounds.
But here’s the kicker. BMI doesn’t know if you’re carrying 20 pounds of extra fat or 20 pounds of dense muscle. Muscle is significantly more dense than adipose tissue. If you’ve been hitting the gym and building a solid frame, you might clock in at 180 pounds and look incredibly fit, yet a standard chart would label you as "overweight." It’s a blunt instrument.
Nick Trefethen, a professor of numerical analysis at Oxford University, actually proposed a "New BMI" formula a few years back because he realized the old one underestimates the healthy weight of taller people and overestimates it for shorter people. For someone who is 5'9", the standard formula is slightly more forgiving than it is for someone who is 5'2", but it’s still just math, not medicine.
Frame Size: The Factor Nobody Mentions
Have you ever noticed that some people just have "bigger bones"? It’s not a myth. Scientists actually categorize frame size into small, medium, and large by measuring wrist circumference. This matters immensely when determining a 5 9 ideal weight.
If you have a small frame, your "ideal" might lean toward the lower end of the 130s. If you have a large frame—broad shoulders, wide hips, thick wrists—trying to hit 135 pounds might actually be unhealthy and unsustainable for your skeletal structure. For a 5'9" male with a large frame, the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company tables (which, despite being old, are often more nuanced than BMI) suggest a range of 155 to 176 pounds. For a female of the same height and frame, it’s about 145 to 163 pounds.
Think about it this way: a car frame made of heavy steel weighs more than one made of aluminum, even if they're the same size. Your skeleton is your chassis. You can't diet away your bone structure.
How to Check Your Frame
Grab a measuring tape. Wrap it around your wrist, right where those knobby bones are.
- For a man standing 5'9", a wrist size of 6.5 to 7.5 inches is average.
- Over 7.5? You've got a large frame.
- For women at 5'9", anything over 6.5 inches puts you in the large-frame category.
Beyond the Scale: Waist-to-Hip Ratio
If you really want to know if your weight is "ideal," stop looking at the scale and start looking at where you carry your fat. This is what doctors like Dr. Margaret Ashwell have been shouting from the rooftops for years. She’s a major advocate for the Waist-to-Height Ratio (WHtR).
The rule is simple: your waist circumference should be less than half your height.
For a 5'9" person (69 inches), your waist should ideally be under 34.5 inches.
Why? Because visceral fat—the stuff that hangs out around your organs—is the real villain. You could be 150 pounds (perfectly "ideal" on a chart) but have a "pooch" and a high waist circumference, which puts you at a higher risk for Type 2 diabetes and heart disease than a 180-pound person with a flat stomach and a lot of leg muscle.
📖 Related: Finding Your Appropriate Weight: Why Scale Numbers Are Mostly Lying To You
Age Changes the Math
We need to get real about aging. The 5 9 ideal weight for a 22-year-old is rarely the same as it is for a 65-year-old. There’s something called the "Obesity Paradox" in geriatric medicine.
Research, including studies published in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, suggests that as we get older, carrying a little extra weight (being in the "overweight" BMI category of 25–29) might actually be protective. It provides a reserve of energy if you get sick and helps prevent osteoporosis. If you’re 5'9" and 70 years old, weighing 175 pounds might actually be "healthier" for you than being a "perfect" 140 pounds.
Performance vs. Aesthetics
What do you actually do with your body?
A 5'9" rock climber wants to be as light as possible to pull themselves up a cliff. They might aim for 135 or 140 pounds.
A 5'9" rugby player or a CrossFit athlete needs mass to move weight and absorb impact. They might be a lean, mean 190 pounds.
Both are "ideal" for their specific context.
If you are constantly tired, losing your hair, or always cold just to maintain a certain number on the scale, that is not your ideal weight. It's an arbitrary goal that’s hurting you. Conversely, if your weight makes your knees ache or your breath shorten when walking up stairs, the number is likely too high for your current muscle mass.
Real Numbers for Real People
Let's look at some actual data points for a 5'9" individual.
📖 Related: Fiber in Cabbage 1 Cup: What Most People Get Wrong About This Humble Veggie
- The "Model" Standard: In the fashion industry, a 5'9" female model often weighs between 115 and 125 pounds. This is technically underweight by health standards and is often achieved through extreme measures. It's not a health goal; it's a job requirement.
- The "Athlete" Standard: Look at a professional MMA fighter in the Lightweight division (155 lbs). Many walk around at 170-180 pounds at 5'9" before cutting weight. They are incredibly healthy at that weight.
- The "Average" Reality: In the US, the average weight for a man of this height is closer to 195 pounds. While this often trends into the "overweight" or "obese" category statistically, it shows how far off the "ideal" charts are from the modern reality.
The Mental Trap of the "Perfect" Number
We get obsessed. I’ve seen people lose 20 pounds, hit their "goal weight," and still feel miserable because they didn't magically get the body they saw in a magazine.
Weight is a data point, not a destiny.
Focusing on a 5 9 ideal weight can sometimes distract you from more important metrics like blood pressure, resting heart rate, and fasted blood sugar levels. If your vitals are perfect and you feel energetic, does it really matter if the scale says 172 instead of 162? Probably not.
Actionable Steps to Finding Your Personal "Ideal"
Stop chasing a ghost. If you want to find the weight where your body actually functions best, try these steps instead of refreshing a BMI calculator.
✨ Don't miss: Finding pics of tapeworms in cats is gross but here is exactly what you are looking at
- Get a DXA scan or a BodPod reading. If you can afford it, this is the gold standard. It tells you exactly how much of your weight is bone, muscle, and fat. Knowing you have a high bone density or high muscle mass can take the "weight" off your shoulders mentally.
- Track "Non-Scale Victories." How do your jeans fit? Can you carry three bags of groceries up the stairs without huffing? How is your sleep? These are better indicators of health than a spring-loaded box on your bathroom floor.
- Measure your waist. Use the half-your-height rule. If you're 5'9" and your waist is creeping over 35 inches, it might be time to look at your diet and activity levels, regardless of what the total weight is.
- Consult a professional who looks at "Functional Health." Find a doctor or a registered dietitian who talks about "body composition" rather than just "weight loss."
- Adjust for your frame. If you have broad shoulders and thick joints, give yourself permission to exist at the higher end of the spectrum.
The 5 9 ideal weight isn't a single point on a line. It’s a wide, blurry zone that changes as you age, gain muscle, or change your lifestyle. Don't let a chart from the 1800s tell you how to feel about your body in 2026. Focus on how you move and how you feel, and the weight will usually settle exactly where it needs to be.