Look, the 2026 rookie class is weird. Honestly, it’s just weird. If you’re sitting there holding three first-round picks thinking you’re about to land the next Marvin Harrison Jr. or Bijan Robinson, you might want to take a breath. It’s not that the talent isn’t there; it’s just that the names everyone is screaming about today might not be the ones winning you a title three years from now.
Most dynasty football rookie rankings you’ll find right now are basically just mirror images of NFL mock drafts. That is a massive mistake. The NFL cares about "anchor tackles" and "coverage versatility." You care about points.
Let’s get into what actually matters.
The Jeremiyah Love Tier
If you have the 1.01 in a 1QB league, stop overthinking. Just stop. Jeremiyah Love is the guy. The Notre Dame standout has basically become the "free space" on the 2026 bingo card. He’s 6'0", 212 pounds, and runs with a pad level so low it makes linebackers look like they're trying to tackle a bowling ball.
He’s efficient. Like, really efficient. He averaged 6.9 yards per carry this past season and looked like a seasoned pro in the passing game with 280 receiving yards. Some scouts, like those over at Draft Sharks, are already comparing his toolkit to elite prospects because he doesn't just run—he catches. He has that "home-run speed" that turns a 4-yard checkdown into a 60-yard highlight.
💡 You might also like: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
The gap between Love and the RB2 in this class is a canyon.
Why the Quarterbacks Are a Trap (Sort Of)
In Superflex, things get messy. Fernando Mendoza out of Indiana just won the Heisman. That’s great for him! It’s awesome for Indiana. But for your fantasy team? He’s 6'6" and mostly stays in the pocket. In the modern game, if your QB doesn't run, he better be throwing for 4,500 yards and 40 touchdowns just to keep pace with the guys who do.
Mendoza is likely the NFL's QB1. He’s got the "pro-style" processing that makes GMs drool. But in dynasty football rookie rankings, I’m taking the swing on Ty Simpson or even Dante Moore first if the price is right. Simpson has that "dual-threat" profile that actually breaks fantasy scoring.
The Wide Receiver Identity Crisis
We’ve been spoiled lately. We expect every WR1 to be a 6'4" alpha who mosses everyone. This class is different. It’s a technician’s class.
📖 Related: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
Take Makai Lemon from USC. He’s not a giant. He’s not a burner. But the guy is always open. He just won the Biletnikoff Award because he understands leverage better than half the corners in the Big Ten. He’s been compared to Amon-Ra St. Brown, and honestly, the tape backs it up. He’s shifty, slippery, and loves the middle of the field.
Then you have Jordyn Tyson at Arizona State.
Tyson is the ceiling play.
He’s the guy who puts up 1,100 yards and 10 scores while making it look easy.
But—and this is a big "but"—he’s got a medical folder thick enough to use as a doorstop. Knee injuries, hamstring issues, surgeries. If he’s healthy, he’s a superstar. If he’s not, he’s a roster clogger.
- Makai Lemon (USC): The PPR king. If your league gives a full point per reception, he’s your WR1.
- Jordyn Tyson (ASU): The "alpha" build. High risk, massive reward.
- Carnell Tate (Ohio State): The safe bet. Ohio State wideouts are basically a cheat code at this point. He’s played second fiddle to Jeremiah Smith, but he still produces.
- Denzel Boston (Washington): The size mismatch. 6'4" and can actually track a deep ball.
The Kenyon Sadiq Problem
Let's talk about tight ends. Usually, drafting a rookie TE is like planting a tree; you won't see any fruit for three years. But Kenyon Sadiq from Oregon might be the exception that proves the rule.
Sadiq is 245 pounds but moves like a big wideout. He’s already getting top-20 NFL Draft buzz because he’s a nightmare to cover in the seam. In most dynasty football rookie rankings, he’s hovering around the late first round. That’s probably too low. If you’re in a TE-Premium league, Sadiq is a top-8 pick. No questions asked.
👉 See also: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The Sleepers You’re Ignoring
Everyone is focused on the Power Five, but don't sleep on Robert Henry Jr. from UTSA. His path was weird—zero-star recruit, JuCo grinder, then finally popping at the FBS level. He’s 205 pounds and runs like he’s trying to break the earth. He’s the kind of Day 3 NFL pick who ends up starting by Week 6 because he just refuses to go down on the first contact.
Then there's Jonah Coleman at Washington.
He’s thick.
5'9", 220 pounds.
He’s not fast, but he’s efficient.
He led the country in some "missed tackles forced" metrics before he got dinged up. If he lands in a zone-heavy scheme like the Rams or 49ers, he’s going to be a problem for opposing defenses and a godsend for your RB2 slot.
Tactical Draft Strategy for 2026
If you’re sitting on mid-first-round picks, the move is to trade for established veterans or move back. This class is very "flat" after the top three or four players. The difference between the 1.06 and the 2.02 isn't as big as it was in 2024 or 2025.
Don't reach for a quarterback just because it's Superflex. If Mendoza and Simpson are gone, take the elite WR talent. You can always trade a productive WR for a mid-tier QB later, but you can't fix a "bust" pick at 1.05.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Audit your RB room: If you aren't in a position to grab Jeremiyah Love, start looking at "productive but unsexy" names like Jonah Coleman or even Jadarian Price in the second round.
- Watch the medicals: Jordyn Tyson’s Combine medical checks are more important than his 40-yard dash. If he clears, he moves to WR1. If not, he’s a fade.
- Value the "Big Slots": Players like Makai Lemon are going to be more consistent than the "X" receivers in this specific class. Lean into the floor in your dynasty football rookie rankings this year.
- Leverage the TE-Premium: If your league rewards tight ends, Kenyon Sadiq is your target. Don't let him slide past the turn of the first round.