Draft season is basically here, and honestly, if you’re still using a standard 1-QB mindset for your 2025 fantasy football superflex rankings, you’re going to get buried by week four. Superflex changes everything. It turns that “wait on a quarterback” mantra into a dangerous game of chicken that most people lose.
In a format where you can start two signal-callers, the math is simple. QBs score the most points. If you don't have two high-end starters, you're essentially spotting your opponent 10 to 15 points every single Sunday.
But here’s the thing: the 2025 landscape is weirdly top-heavy. We've seen a massive shift in how the elite tier is built. For years, you just took the guys who ran the most and called it a day. Now? The league is catching up to the "scramble-first" archetypes, and passing volume is becoming king again.
The Elite Tier: 2025 fantasy football superflex rankings Breakdown
At the very top, Josh Allen remains the undisputed king. It’s almost boring at this point, but the man is a fantasy cheat code. Even as he ages and the Bills occasionally try to "protect" him by limiting designed runs, he still finds his way into the end zone. He’s the 1.01 in almost every serious superflex draft I’ve seen this January.
Then it gets spicy.
Drake Maye has skyrocketed. If you watched the end of his rookie campaign, you saw a guy who finally looked comfortable in that Patriots offense. With Stefon Diggs now in New England—which, let’s be real, nobody saw coming—Maye has a legitimate WR1 to pepper with targets. His combination of a massive arm and sneaky rushing upside has him sitting at QB2 for many experts.
💡 You might also like: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
Lamar Jackson and Jayden Daniels are right there, too. Daniels averaged over 23 points per game in his starts last year. That’s insane for a rookie. The Commanders added some serious protection for him in free agency, bringing in Laremy Tunsil to hold down the left side. If he stays healthy, his ceiling is higher than anyone's. But that "if" is doing a lot of heavy lifting.
Why the "Double Tap" Strategy is Dying
In 2023 or 2024, the "Double Tap"—taking two QBs with your first two picks—was the gold standard.
Not anymore.
The mid-round value at quarterback is actually decent this year. You’ve got guys like Trevor Lawrence and Brock Purdy falling into the fourth or fifth rounds. Purdy just signed a massive extension and has proven he’s more than just a "system QB." If you can get a cornerstone like Ja'Marr Chase or Justin Jefferson in the first and still land a guy like Purdy as your QB2 later, that’s a much more balanced roster build.
The Rookie Infusion: Who Actually Matters?
This 2025 rookie class isn't exactly the 2024 class. We don't have three or four "generational" QBs coming in. Instead, the strength is at the skill positions.
📖 Related: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
Ashton Jeanty is the name everyone is screaming about. The Raiders took him early, and he’s going to get 20+ touches a game from day one. In superflex, he’s a fringe first-rounder. He’s that good. He’s got the contact balance of a young Nick Chubb but with better hands.
For the QBs, Cameron Ward (Titans) and Jaxson Dart (Giants) are the two you need to track. Ward is likely the Week 1 starter in Tennessee. He’s got that Baker Mayfield "moxie" but with a bit more raw athleticism. The Giants taking Dart is fascinating because it basically signals the end of the Daniel Jones era. Dart is a project, but in a superflex dynasty league, he’s a top-five rookie pick.
The Risky Business of Rushing Upside
We need to talk about Anthony Richardson. Honestly, he’s the most polarizing player in fantasy right now. One week he looks like the best player on the planet; the next, he's on the trainer’s table. The Colts brought in Daniel Jones to compete/back him up, which tells you exactly what they think of his durability.
If you draft Richardson, you must draft a safe QB3. You can't rely on him for 17 games. It’s just not realistic.
Evaluating the WR/RB "Hero" Build
If you’re picking at the back end of the first round, you’re often faced with a choice: take a Tier 2 QB like Joe Burrow or Jalen Hurts, or grab an elite RB like Bijan Robinson.
👉 See also: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
In 2025, the "Hero RB" build is making a comeback. The gap between Bijan and the RB15 is huge. The gap between Burrow and the QB15 (maybe a C.J. Stroud or Jordan Love) isn't as wide as you think.
- Bijan Robinson is finally being used like the superstar he is.
- Jahmyr Gibbs is basically a wide receiver who happens to take handoffs.
- Breece Hall is the engine of that Jets offense, regardless of who is under center.
Actionable Draft Steps for Your Superflex League
Don't just wing it. Superflex rewards the prepared and punishes the "vibes-based" drafters.
First, tier your quarterbacks. If you miss out on the top seven, don't panic-reach for a guy like Kirk Cousins in the second round. The value isn't there.
Second, track the "Bridge QBs." Jameis Winston in New York is a fascinating late-round target. He’s going to throw for 300 yards or 3 interceptions—maybe both—but he’ll keep those Giants receivers like Malik Nabers fantasy-relevant.
Third, don't ignore the TE wasteland. Unless you get Brock Bowers or Trey McBride, you’re better off waiting. Colston Loveland ended up in Chicago with Caleb Williams, which is a dream landing spot for a rookie tight end. He's a great late-round dart throw.
Finally, remember that trade value in superflex is heavily skewed. A starting QB, even a mediocre one, is worth a mid-to-late first-round pick in most leagues. If you have three starters, you hold the leverage in your league. Draft for talent, but always keep an eye on the trade market.
Start by looking at your league's specific scoring. If it's 6-point passing touchdowns, the gap between the pocket passers and the runners shrinks significantly. That alone could move a guy like Joe Burrow up five spots in your personal 2025 fantasy football superflex rankings.