.jpg?w=3800&h=2000)
College football is basically unrecognizable from what it was five years ago. We have 12-team playoffs, players getting paid millions in NIL deals, and conferences that look like they were put together by a confused cartographer. Amidst all that chaos, one thing remains weirdly consistent: the drama surrounding the 2025 AP poll college football rankings.
It’s Sunday afternoon. You’re refreshing your feed at 2:00 PM ET. You want to see if your team jumped three spots or got snubbed after a "quality win" over a directional school. Honestly, that ritual is the only thing keeping us grounded while the rest of the sport moves at light speed.
The Chaos of the Preseason 2025 AP Poll College Football Rankings
The preseason poll is usually a beauty pageant. It’s based on who recruited the best five-star recruits and which quarterback has the coolest highlight reel from spring camp. This year, though, the voters were in a tough spot. You had the defending champion Ohio State Buckeyes trying to reload after losing a massive chunk of their 2024 title-winning roster to the NFL Draft.
Texas took the No. 1 spot in the preseason 2025 AP poll college football release, and for good reason. Arch Manning finally stepped into the spotlight. When your last name is Manning and you’re playing for Steve Sarkisian, people are going to vote for you. It’s almost a rule at this point.
But look at the rest of that early top five. Penn State at No. 2? That was a bold move by the writers. They returned almost everyone, including Drew Allar and that monster backfield duo of Nicholas Singleton and Kaytron Allen. Then you had Ohio State at No. 3, Clemson at No. 4, and Georgia at No. 5.
Why the Early Rankings Felt Different
For the first time, the AP Poll isn't just a trophy for the mantel. It's the psychological baseline for the 12-team playoff race. In the old days, a preseason No. 15 ranking meant you were basically out of the title hunt if you lost one game in September. Now? If you're in the Top 25, you're in the conversation. Period.
✨ Don't miss: Simona Halep and the Reality of Tennis Player Breast Reduction
The SEC absolutely dominated the preseason landscape. They put 10 teams in the Top 25. That’s a record. It also makes the weekly movement in the 2025 AP poll college football rankings feel like a game of musical chairs. Every Saturday is an elimination game when half the conference is ranked.
How the Poll Actually Works (And Why Fans Get Mad)
People think there’s some supercomputer in a basement at AP headquarters crunching numbers. Nope. It’s just 62 sportswriters and broadcasters. They each submit a ballot. A No. 1 vote is worth 25 points, No. 2 is 24, and so on.
It’s subjective. Very subjective.
One voter might value "strength of schedule" above all else. Another might just look at the final score and decide a win is a win. This is why you see those weird "Receiving Votes" sections where a team like Navy or James Madison suddenly pops up because one guy in Maryland really likes what they’re doing with the triple option.
The Human Element
Voters are humans. They have biases. They have fatigue. If a team wins 10-7 in a "boring" game, they might drop in the 2025 AP poll college football rankings even if they didn't lose. We call it "poll inertia." It’s the idea that once a team is ranked high, they stay there until they actually face-plant.
🔗 Read more: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
The Teams That Broke the 2025 Poll
Indiana. Nobody—and I mean nobody—expected Indiana to be sitting at No. 1 in the AP Poll by December. Last year, they were the "feel-good story" that people thought would fade away. Instead, they just kept winning. By the time we hit the home stretch of the 2025 season, the Hoosiers weren't just a fluke; they were the consensus best team in the eyes of the AP voters.
Then you have the "disappointments."
- Texas: Started at No. 1, but those offensive line injuries we heard about in August really took a toll. They slid down to No. 14 by the end of the regular season.
- Alabama: It’s weird seeing the Crimson Tide at No. 11. In the Saban era, that was a crisis. In the DeBoer era, it’s just a "rebuilding year" while they figure out the post-Milroe life.
- Michigan: They’ve been hovering around No. 18. Solid, but not the juggernaut that won it all a couple of years back.
The Rise of the "New" Powers
Look at Texas Tech and Ole Miss. They’ve both spent significant time in the Top 10 this year. Lane Kiffin has finally turned Oxford into a place where the 2025 AP poll college football voters actually trust the defense. And Texas Tech? They’ve become the kings of the "chaos" late-night games that keep East Coast voters awake and terrified.
Does the AP Poll Still Matter?
This is the big question. Since 2014, the College Football Playoff (CFP) Committee has released its own rankings. Those are the ones that actually determine who plays for the trophy.
So, is the AP Poll obsolete?
💡 You might also like: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
Not really. The AP Poll is the "people’s poll." It comes out every week from August to January. The CFP rankings don’t even start until November. The AP Poll sets the narrative. It creates the "Top 25" matchups that ESPN and FOX use to sell ad space in September and October.
If you aren't ranked in the 2025 AP poll college football list by mid-October, you have a massive uphill battle to convince the CFP Committee that you belong in the 12-team field. The AP Poll builds the "resume" that the committee eventually critiques.
What to Watch for Next
We are heading into the final stretch. The bowl games and the playoff rounds will eventually lead to the "Final AP Poll." This is the one that goes into the history books.
If you want to stay ahead of the curve, keep an eye on the "Group of Five" race. Boise State and Tulane have been flirting with the Top 20 all year. One of them is likely going to secure that automatic playoff bid, and their standing in the 2025 AP poll college football rankings will be the first indicator of how much respect they’ll get when the seeding is announced.
Actionable Insights for the Savvy Fan
- Don't panic over Week 1: The preseason poll is a guess. If your team drops from No. 5 to No. 12 after a close loss, remember there’s more "vertical movement" early in the season than late.
- Watch the "Points," not just the "Rank": If the gap between No. 1 and No. 2 is only 5 points, the voters are split. That means a lead is fragile.
- Check the individual ballots: The AP website actually shows you how every single writer voted. If you think a certain writer has a vendetta against your school, you can usually find the evidence there.
The road to the 2026 National Championship is already being paved by these weekly votes. Whether you love the poll or think it’s a total joke, you’re going to be checking it next Sunday. We all will.