Honestly, if you turned off the 2024 NBA All-Star Game halfway through, nobody could really blame you. By the time the final buzzer echoed through Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis, the scoreboard looked like something out of a video game glitch. 211 to 186. Think about that for a second. The Eastern Conference dropped 211 points in a 48-minute basketball game.
It was history. But was it good? That’s where things get kinda complicated.
The Night the Scoreboard Broke
The 73rd edition of this midseason showcase was supposed to be a return to "normalcy." The NBA ditched the captain-draft format and the Elam Ending (that target score thing they’d been doing) to go back to the classic East vs. West. Commissioner Adam Silver and the league office had spent months practically begging players to actually play defense. They wanted a real game.
Instead, they got a layup line that lasted three hours.
The East didn’t just win; they obliterated every scoring record in the book. They were the first team to ever cross the 200-point threshold. When Tyrese Haliburton hit the shot that put them over 200, the vibe in the arena was less "wow, history!" and more "wait, are they really not going to guard anyone?"
Here’s the wild part about the numbers:
- 397 total points combined, destroying the previous record of 374.
- The East hit 42 three-pointers, which is just a staggering amount of long-distance shooting.
- Karl-Anthony Towns quietly dropped 50 points for the West. In any other year, that’s an easy MVP. In 2024, it was almost an afterthought because his team lost by 25.
Damian Lillard: The Hero Indy Didn’t Want?
Damian Lillard had himself a weekend. Let’s give the man his flowers. On Saturday night, he won the Three-Point Contest. Then on Sunday, he came out and dropped 39 points, including a couple of those signature "logo" shots from half-court that make your jaw drop.
He took home the Kobe Bryant All-Star Game MVP trophy. But the ceremony was... awkward.
Because the game was in Indy, the fans were desperate for their hometown hero, Tyrese Haliburton, to win the MVP. Haliburton started the game like he was possessed, hitting five straight threes in the first few minutes. He finished with 32 points. When Lillard’s name was announced for the award instead of Tyrese’s, the Indiana crowd actually showered Dame with boos.
Kinda harsh for a guy who just hit two shots from the mid-court stripe, right?
Why Everyone Is Still Talking About the "Intensity" Problem
If you’ve been on NBA Twitter or watched any sports talk shows lately, you know the league is in a bit of a crisis with this event. Adam Silver’s face during the trophy presentation said it all. He looked like a parent whose kids just failed a math test.
"And to the Eastern Conference All-Stars, you scored the most points. Well, congratulations." — Adam Silver
That might be the most "I'm not mad, I'm disappointed" quote in sports history.
The reality is that these guys are terrified of getting hurt. Anthony Davis admitted as much after the game. When you’re making $50 million a year and your team is fighting for a playoff spot, jumping into a pile for a loose ball in February feels like a bad business decision.
But for the fans? Watching 167 three-point attempts is basically just a glorified practice session. There was a moment where Luka Dončić tried to throw a dunk off the glass to himself and missed by about three feet. It was funny, sure, but it also highlighted the fact that the players were treatin' the whole thing like a Saturday morning run at the Y.
The Saturday Night Savior
If the Sunday game was a dud, Saturday night actually saved the weekend’s reputation. We finally got the Steph vs. Sabrina challenge.
It was easily the most "competitive" thing that happened in Indianapolis. Sabrina Ionescu stepped up and shot from the NBA line, putting up 26 points. Stephen Curry had to actually sweat to beat her, finishing with 29. That 10-minute segment had more tension and energy than the entire four quarters of the 2024 NBA All-Star Game.
We also saw Mac McClung defend his dunk contest title by jumping over Shaquille O'Neal. Literally. He jumped over a 7-foot-1 human being. It was the only time the building felt like it was truly shaking.
What’s the Move Going Forward?
So, where does the NBA go from here? The 2024 experiment proved that just changing the format back to East vs. West doesn’t fix the effort.
🔗 Read more: Ed Oliver Buffalo Bills: Why the Interior Terror is Finally Worth the $68 Million
There’s a lot of talk about moving to a U.S. vs. International format. Imagine Giannis, Luka, Jokic, and Wemby taking on LeBron, Steph, KD, and Tatum. The theory is that national pride might actually make them want to win.
Others think we should just give the winning conference home-court advantage in the Finals again, or maybe just a massive cash prize that goes to a charity of the players' choice.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're planning on tuning in for future All-Star weekends, here's the best way to handle it:
- Prioritize Saturday Night: The Skills Challenge, 3-Point Contest, and Dunk Contest are currently providing more "real" entertainment than the game itself.
- Watch the Intros: The player introductions and the musical performances (Jennifer Hudson killed it in Indy) are still top-tier production.
- Follow the Mic'd Up Segments: The best part of the 2024 game wasn't the hoops; it was hearing Jokic and Luka joke around on the sidelines.
The 2024 NBA All-Star Game was a statistical anomaly that showed us both the incredible skill of these players and the massive gap between what the league wants and what the players are willing to give. It was a 211-point history lesson in why the midseason classic needs a serious spark.
For those looking to dive deeper into the stats, keep an eye on how the league adjusts the "minimum games played" rules for awards, as that same tension between rest and performance is what defined this entire weekend in Indiana.