The lights went down at the Peacock Theater in Los Angeles, and honestly, the tension was thick enough to cut with a Buster Sword. We all knew Astro Bot was a heavy hitter, but seeing a platformer take the crown for Game of the Year in an era of massive open-world RPGs felt like a shift in the tectonic plates of the industry. It wasn't just a win for Sony; it was a win for pure, unadulterated joy.
People keep calling 2024 a "slow year" for gaming. That is just fundamentally wrong. When you look at the 2024 game awards winners, you see a year where the underdogs didn't just participate—they dominated. We saw a poker-themed roguelike sweep multiple categories and a Chinese action-RPG break the internet. It was weird, it was loud, and it was exactly what we needed.
The Big One: Why Astro Bot Won Game of the Year
There’s always a bit of a "safe choice" narrative that follows the GOTY announcement. Critics say Astro Bot was the easy pick because it’s polished and charming. But that ignores the technical mastery Team Asobi pulled off. Winning both Game of the Year and Best Game Direction is no small feat. It basically means the jury felt the vision for the game was perfectly executed from the first jump to the final boss.
It beat out some absolute titans. Final Fantasy VII Rebirth and Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree were right there. The fact that a DLC—even one as massive as Shadow of the Erdtree—got a GOTY nod caused a massive stir online. Some fans felt expansions shouldn't compete with full games, but the quality was undeniable. Still, Astro’s win proved that "fun" is still the most valuable currency in gaming.
The Balatro Phenomenon
If you told me at the start of the year that a game about poker would be one of the most decorated titles of the night, I would've thought you were joking. Balatro didn't just win; it took home Best Independent Game, Best Debut Indie Game, and Best Mobile Game. LocalThunk, the solo developer, basically created a digital drug that everyone from hardcore gamers to casual phone players couldn't put down.
It’s rare to see a triple win like that. Usually, the awards get spread out to share the love. But the momentum for Balatro was unstoppable. It’s a testament to the idea that you don’t need a 400-person team or a $100 million budget to capture the world's attention. You just need a really, really good loop.
The Genre Masters: Metaphor and Wukong
Atlus is on a legendary run right now. Metaphor: ReFantazio cleaned up in the categories where storytelling matters most. It snatched Best RPG, Best Narrative, and Best Art Direction. Following the Persona 5 blueprint but turning it into a high-fantasy political drama was a masterstroke. It’s a dense game, but the way it handles its themes of anxiety and social change clearly resonated with the voters.
Then there’s the Black Myth: Wukong situation.
The game was a cultural juggernaut. It took home Best Action Game and, perhaps more importantly, the Player’s Voice award. That last one is a big deal because it’s 100% fan-voted. While the jury might have preferred the polish of Astro Bot, the people chose the Monkey King. There was even some drama when Game Science’s CEO, Feng Ji, expressed some public frustration about missing out on the top prize. It was a reminder that the stakes for these awards have become massive for international studios looking to break into the Western mainstream.
✨ Don't miss: Why Star Ocean Till the End of Time Still Divides JRPG Fans 20 Years Later
Breaking Down the Other Key Winners
- Best Score and Music: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth. This felt like a lock. Square Enix’s ability to take Nobuo Uematsu’s classic themes and modernize them while adding hours of new material is unparalleled.
- Best Performance: Melina Juergens for Senua’s Saga: Hellblade II. Melina isn't just an actress; she's the literal face and soul of that franchise. Her portrayal of psychosis and grief is arguably some of the best acting we’ve seen in the medium, period.
- Best Ongoing Game: Helldivers 2. Arrowhead’s co-op shooter was the viral hit of the spring. Even with the technical hiccups and the whole PSN account controversy, the "Galactic War" kept players coming back in droves. It also grabbed Best Multiplayer Game, which makes sense given how much it dominated social media for months.
- Best Adaptation: Fallout. This was a tough category. Arcane Season 2 was a masterpiece, but the Fallout show managed to capture the weird, dark humor of the games so perfectly that it brought millions of new players into the ecosystem.
The Controversy You Might Have Missed
The Player’s Voice award sparked a lot of "gacha gate" talk. Three of the top five finalists—Genshin Impact, Wuthering Waves, and Zenless Zone Zero—were free-to-play gacha games. Critics argued that these games have such massive built-in player bases (often incentivized by in-game rewards) that smaller titles don't stand a chance in public votes. It’s a valid point. The industry is still trying to figure out how to balance "most popular" with "best," and the 2024 ceremony brought that tension to the surface.
Also, Baldur's Gate 3 won Best Community Support. Yes, it came out in 2023. But Larian Studios’ commitment to fixing bugs and adding new endings long after the game launched set a new bar for what "live service" should actually look like. Swen Vincke even used his time on stage to call out publishers who put profit over creativity, which was a bit of a "mic drop" moment for the night.
Actionable Insights for Players
If you’re looking at this list and wondering what to play next, don't just go for the GOTY. Each of these winners represents a different "vibe" of 2024.
- If you want pure joy: Get Astro Bot. It’s the best use of the DualSense controller ever made.
- If you want to lose 100 hours: Metaphor: ReFantazio is the deepest RPG of the year.
- If you only have 15 minutes: Balatro on mobile is dangerous. You've been warned.
- If you want a cinematic experience: Hellblade II is short, but the audio design is something you need to experience with a good pair of headphones.
The 2024 game awards winners proved that the "prestige" of a game doesn't always come from its budget. Whether it’s a tiny indie card game or a massive Chinese action-RPG, the games that moved the needle this year were the ones that took risks. Go out and try something outside your usual genre—2024 was the year the unexpected became the standard.