Salt Lake City was cold. February 2023 in Utah usually is, but the atmosphere inside Vivint Arena for the 2023 NBA All-Star Game felt a little... different. Honest truth? People were worried about the product. Ratings had been sliding for years, and the league was desperate for a spark. What they got was a mixed bag of historic individual brilliance and a game that left some coaches, like Michael Malone, calling it the "worst basketball game ever played."
Let's talk about Jayson Tatum. He didn't just play; he took over.
Tatum dropped a staggering 55 points, snatching the All-Star scoring record right out of Anthony Davis’s hands. He was hitting everything. Side-step threes. Transition dunks. It didn't matter. By the time the third quarter ended, he had 27 points in that period alone. That’s another record, by the way. He ended up with the Kobe Bryant MVP Trophy, and honestly, he was the primary reason Team Giannis finally took down Team LeBron.
The Night LeBron’s Streak Finally Snapped
Before this game, LeBron James was basically the untouchable king of the All-Star draft format. He was 5-0 as a captain. He had this weird "GM LeBron" magic where he always picked the winning squad. But the 2023 NBA All-Star Game changed the script.
Giannis Antetokounmpo, despite having a wrist injury that limited him to about 20 seconds of actual playing time, drafted a monster lineup. He took Tatum first among the starters. He grabbed Damian Lillard and Donovan Mitchell.
It was a draft-day masterclass.
The game ended with a target score of 182. Team Giannis hit it first, finishing at 184-175. It was a weird ending because Lillard iced it with a three, which is basically his signature move, but the lack of defense throughout the first three quarters made the final score feel almost hollow to some purists.
Why the Ratings Hit an All-Time Low
You can't talk about this weekend without mentioning the elephant in the room. The numbers were brutal. We are talking about 4.59 million viewers across TNT and TBS. That was a 29% drop from the year before.
🔗 Read more: Ilona Maher: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Gender
Why did people tune out?
- Injury Bug: No Steph Curry. No Kevin Durant. No Zion Williamson.
- Early Exits: LeBron hurt his hand on the rim and sat out the second half. Giannis played one possession.
- Lack of Intensity: Players were basically jogging. There was zero resistance at the rim until the very last few minutes.
Mac McClung: The Savior of Saturday Night
If the Sunday game was a bit of a slog, Saturday was the opposite, specifically because of one guy. Mac McClung.
Before the 2023 NBA All-Star Game festivities, people were complaining that the Dunk Contest was "dead." They said the league was reaching too far by inviting a G League player. McClung proved every single hater wrong. He didn't just win; he saved the event. He had three dunks with perfect 50 scores. His 540-degree dunk was something straight out of a video game.
He was the first G League player to ever participate, let alone win. It was the shot of adrenaline the weekend desperately needed.
Breaking Down the Box Score
It wasn't just the Tatum show. Donovan Mitchell was essentially the co-pilot, putting up 40 points and 10 assists. On the other side, Jaylen Brown was the only one really trying to make it a game for Team LeBron, finishing with 35 points and 14 rebounds.
🔗 Read more: St. John's v Creighton: Why This Big East Rivalry Just Hits Different
The duel between Tatum and Brown—Celtics teammates—was the highlight of the night. They went 1-on-1 for several possessions in the third, trash-talking and trading buckets. It felt like a high-level park game in the middle of a multi-million dollar production. Sorta cool, honestly.
What This Game Taught the NBA
The 2023 NBA All-Star Game was a wake-up call. Commissioner Adam Silver clearly saw the feedback. The "Elam Ending" (target score) was great in theory, but when players don't play defense until the score is 170, the tension is gone.
If you're looking for the actionable takeaways from this specific era of basketball, it's about the shift in star power. We saw the rise of the "young vets" like Tatum and Mitchell taking the mantle from the LeBron/KD generation.
How to Enjoy Future All-Star Weekends
If you're a fan who felt let down by the 2023 showing, here is how you should approach watching moving forward:
- Watch Saturday for the Skill: The 3-Point Contest (won by Damian Lillard in 2023) and the Dunk Contest are currently more competitive than the actual game.
- Follow the Micro-Duels: Forget the final score. The real fun is when two teammates or rivals decide to go 1-on-1 for three minutes. That's the "real" basketball.
- Check the Rosters Early: All-Star weekend is highly dependent on health. If the top five MVP candidates are out, expect a high-scoring but low-effort track meet.
The 2023 NBA All-Star Game will be remembered for 55 points and a kid from the G League who could fly. It wasn't perfect, and it certainly wasn't "pretty" basketball, but it remains a pivotal moment in how the NBA thinks about its mid-season showcase.
To get the most out of your NBA viewership this season, focus on tracking player efficiency ratings (PER) leading up to the break. This usually signals who will actually "show up" to compete during the festivities versus who is just there for the vacation. Checking the injury reports 48 hours before tip-off is also the only way to gauge if the game will actually be worth your Sunday night.