Everyone has been there. You're in a circle—maybe it's a corporate icebreaker that feels like a root canal, or perhaps it's just a Friday night with friends and a few too many drinks—and someone says those dreaded words: "Let's play Two Truths and a Lie." Your mind goes blank. Suddenly, you've forgotten every interesting thing you've ever done. You end up saying you have a dog, you like pizza, and you've been to France. It's painful. It’s dull. To actually pull off 2 truths and a lie good lies, you have to understand the psychology of deception and the art of the "mundane truth."
Most people fail because they try too hard. They make the lie something massive, like "I once met Barack Obama at a gas station." Nobody believes that. Or, they make the truths so boring that the lie sticks out like a sore thumb. The secret to winning isn't just about having a great lie; it's about curated authenticity.
Why Your Strategy for 2 Truths and a Lie Good Lies Is Probably Failing
The biggest mistake? The "Extravagance Bias." We think a good lie needs to be spectacular. In reality, the best lies are the ones that sound like a slightly annoying Tuesday. If you tell people you won the lottery, they'll squint. If you tell them you once got a $200 parking ticket because you forgot what day of the week it was, they’ll nod in sympathetic frustration.
The believable mundane
Psychologically, humans are wired to spot "too good to be true" scenarios. Research into deceptive communication, often cited by experts like Dr. Paul Ekman, suggests that micro-expressions and inconsistencies usually happen when the speaker is over-performing. When you're trying to think of 2 truths and a lie good lies, you want to aim for the "middle ground of plausibility."
Think about your life. You've definitely done something weird that sounds fake. That’s your gold. You need to sandwich your lie between two truths that are actually more unbelievable than the lie itself. This is a classic misdirection tactic used by stage magicians. If the truth is "I’ve jumped out of a plane" and "I have a third nipple," and your lie is "I’m allergic to kiwis," people will almost always pick the nipple or the plane. They can’t help it. They want the drama to be the lie.
The Art of the Reverse Bluff
Let’s get into the weeds of how to structure these. You want to mess with their expectations.
One way to do this is the "Specific Detail" trick. When people lie, they often keep it vague to avoid getting tripped up. To counter this, add a weirdly specific, slightly boring detail to your lie. Instead of saying "I used to play the flute," say "I played the flute in middle school but had to quit because I developed a weird rash on my chin from the metal." It’s gross. It’s specific. It’s exactly the kind of thing someone wouldn't want to admit if it weren't true.
Honestly, the best 2 truths and a lie good lies are the ones that leverage your personality. If you're a straight-laced accountant, your lie should be something slightly rebellious but not impossible. "I once spent a night in a jail cell in Mexico because of a clerical error with my passport" works way better for an accountant than "I used to be a professional skateboarder."
👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
Examples of lies that actually work
- I have never seen a single episode of The Simpsons. (This works because it’s culturally ubiquitous; people find it hard to believe someone escaped it.)
- I am terrified of butterflies. (Lepidopterophobia is real, but common enough to be a "boring" truth.)
- I’ve never broken a bone in my body. (Statistically common, yet sounds like a challenge to some.)
- I once won a radio contest for a year's supply of mayonnaise.
Notice how none of those are "I saved a child from a burning building." They are low-stakes. Low-stakes lies are harder to sniff out because there's no ego attached to them.
Strategic Truth-Telling
You can’t have a good lie without "weirder than fiction" truths. This is where you dig deep. You need to find the things about yourself that sound like lies.
Maybe you were an extra in a movie that everyone hates. Or perhaps you have a bizarre collection, like vintage staplers or menus from restaurants that no longer exist. One of my favorite examples from a real-life game was a woman who claimed she had been hit by lightning. Everyone voted for that as the lie. It was true. She had the scar to prove it. Her lie? That she liked cilantro.
Leveraging the "Truth is Stranger" Rule
When choosing your truths to support your 2 truths and a lie good lies, look for:
- The Childhood Oddity: Did you have a pet that wasn't a cat or dog? A goat? A sugar glider?
- The Near-Miss: Did you almost get cast in a commercial? Did you barely miss a major accident?
- The Random Skill: Can you speak a dead language? Can you unicycle? Can you solve a Rubik's cube in under a minute?
The goal is to make your truths sound like "bad" lies. If your truth sounds like something a teenager would make up to seem cool, your friends will jump on it. Use that.
Using Delivery to Your Advantage
Your body language is your biggest giveaway. Or your biggest tool.
Most people look up and to the right when they're "constructing" a lie (though the "eye direction" myth has been largely debunked in modern forensic psychology, people still believe it, so they look for it). If you want to sell your lie, deliver it exactly the same way you deliver your truths. Same speed. Same tone. Same level of eye contact.
✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
Kinda funny how we think we're good at spotting liars. In reality, most of us are terrible at it. We rely on "truth bias," assuming people are telling the truth unless we have a reason to doubt them. In a game of Two Truths and a Lie, that bias is gone. Everyone is a cynic. So, play into their cynicism.
If you're telling your lie, don't over-explain. This is the "Over-Explanation Trap." If someone asks a follow-up question about your lie, keep the answer short. "Yeah, it was weird. I don't really like talking about it." That shuts down the interrogation and makes it seem like a painful, true memory.
The "False Flaw" Technique
People love to find flaws in others. It’s a bit dark, but it’s true. If one of your "truths" is a minor embarrassing failure, people will gravitate toward believing it.
For instance, "I failed my driving test four times" is a great truth. If your lie is something positive, like "I once saved a cat from a tree," they will think you're lying about the cat because you're "the person who fails driving tests."
Mixing the deck
- The Embarrassing Truth: I once walked into a glass door at a job interview.
- The Boring Truth: I have a collection of over 200 different tea bags.
- The Plausible Lie (The Winner): I’ve never been to a professional baseball game.
In this scenario, the baseball game feels like a lie because it's so common to have gone to one. But the glass door story is so specific and humiliating that it must be true. The tea bags sound like a quirky hobby. The lie sits right in the middle, undetected.
Practical Steps for Your Next Game
Don't wait until it's your turn to start thinking. You'll panic. Every single time.
Keep a "social bank" of stories. You don't need many. Just three or four weird-but-true facts and two or three incredibly mundane-but-false lies.
🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
Step 1: Audit your life for the "Unbelievable Truth." Think of the one story you tell at parties that always makes people say, "No way." That is your anchor. It’s your best weapon because it is true, so you can provide endless details if questioned.
Step 2: Craft the "Mundane Lie." Pick something that is a "non-event." You didn't do something. You don't like something. You've never been somewhere. These are much harder to disprove than "I did X."
Step 3: Watch the order. Never put the lie last. People have a recency bias. They tend to analyze the last thing they heard the most. Put your lie in the middle (the "sandwich" method) or first.
Step 4: Control the "Tell." If you find yourself smiling when you lie, start smiling during your truths too. If you tend to fidget, fidget the whole time. Consistency is the enemy of detection.
When you're looking for 2 truths and a lie good lies, remember that the game isn't actually about the facts. It's about how well you know the people in the room. If you're with people who think you're a world traveler, a lie about being afraid of flying will kill. If you're with family who knows everything about you, you have to go for the "forgotten childhood detail" or a "secret preference" they never noticed.
It’s about the narrative. We are storytelling animals. If your three statements tell a coherent (or hilariously incoherent) story about who you are, you’ve already won. The lie doesn't have to be perfect; it just has to belong in the same world as your truths.
Stop trying to be the most interesting person in the room with your lie. Aim to be the most "consistently odd" person. That’s how you keep them guessing long after the game is over.
Next time you're put on the spot, don't reach for the "I met a celebrity" trope. Reach for the "I've never eaten a Big Mac" or the "I have a phobia of cotton balls." Those are the lies that stick. Those are the lies that win.