Fantasy football is a cruel, beautiful, and occasionally stupid game. We spend months agonizing over spreadsheets just to have a third-string tight end ruin our Sunday. But right now, in the thick of the 2025 cycle, the biggest mistake isn't a bad lineup call—it’s drafting like it’s still last year.
Most of your league mates are probably staring at 2024 stat sheets like they’re holy scripture. They see Christian McCaffrey’s name and feel that familiar twitch in their drafting finger. But 2025 is a different beast entirely. We’ve seen the rise of the "Hero RB" strategy, the total collapse of the "middle-class" quarterback, and a rookie class that actually lived up to the hype.
If you’re running a 12 team ppr mock draft 2025 right now, you’ve likely noticed the board looks upside down. Ja'Marr Chase is often the 1.01 over CMC. Why? Because reliability is the new gold. Chase outscored the next closest receiver by over 80 points last season. That’s not a gap; that’s a canyon.
The First Round Chaos: Why CMC Isn’t the Consensus 1.01
Honestly, drafting Christian McCaffrey at the top feels like a "do you feel lucky?" moment from a Dirty Harry movie. He’s 29. He missed the vast majority of 2024 with that lingering Achilles/calf nightmare. While he’s still the most efficient player in football when he’s on the field, the floor is zero. Literally zero.
In most of my recent mocks, the top of the first round looks something like this:
✨ Don't miss: Aaron Judge Season Stats: What Most People Get Wrong
- Ja’Marr Chase (The safest bet in a pass-heavy Bengals offense)
- Bijan Robinson (Finally the bell-cow we were promised)
- CeeDee Lamb (Dak is back, and the Dallas run game is still non-existent)
- Saquon Barkley (The Tush Push didn't kill his value like people feared)
- Justin Jefferson (Proven to be QB-proof even with Sam Darnold)
If you're picking at the turn—the 1.11 or 1.12—you’re basically playing a different game. You’re likely looking at Ashton Jeanty, the Raiders' new workhorse, or perhaps reaching for Malik Nabers. Nabers is a target monster. He grabbed a 35% target share as a rookie. Think about that. Even with the Giants' revolving door at QB, the volume is so high it almost doesn't matter who's throwing the ball.
Strategy Shift: The Death of Zero RB
For years, everyone tried to be the smartest person in the room with Zero RB. 2025 has killed that. Or at least, it's put it in a coma.
The data from SumerSports and recent expert mocks suggests we are firmly in the era of Hero RB. You grab one of those elite, high-volume backs early—think Bucky Irving or Jahmyr Gibbs—and then you hammer wide receivers. The "mid-round" running backs are a graveyard this year. There’s a massive cliff after the top 15-20 RBs. If you don't have a cornerstone by Round 3, you're going to be starting guys you don't even like.
💡 You might also like: Doug Martin: What Really Happened to the Muscle Hamster
The Elite Quarterback Trap
Here's something I’ve noticed in every 12 team ppr mock draft 2025 I’ve done lately: the "Elite Five" QBs are going way too early.
Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, Jayden Daniels, Jalen Hurts, and Joe Burrow are being scooped up in the late second or early third.
Is it worth it?
Kinda. But only if you’ve already secured two elite skill players. If you take Josh Allen at the 2.05, you’re passing on Nico Collins or Brian Thomas Jr. That’s a steep price to pay when you can get Trevor Lawrence—who finished as the QB4 last season under Liam Coen—five rounds later. Lawrence finally figured it out. He’s attacking the middle of the field now, and his rushing floor has quietly improved.
Mid-Round Values You Actually Want
When you get to Rounds 5 through 8, things get weird. This is where leagues are won or lost.
I’m obsessed with Ladd McConkey this year. The target share rumors out of camp are wild. If he hits the mid-teens in target share, he’s a WR1 disguised as a WR3 price tag.
- Chase Brown (Bengals): He’s the lead dog in an elite offense. Why is he still going in the 4th?
- Brock Bowers (Raiders): Even with the Raiders' QB questions, Bowers is the focal point. He’s a "tight end" in name only; he’s a power slot receiver.
- Jaxon Smith-Njigba: Finally getting the WR2 treatment he deserves in Seattle.
What People Get Wrong About 12-Team PPR
The biggest mistake? Fear.
People are afraid of "injury-prone" tags. They pass on De’Von Achane because he’s small. Look, Achane is the most efficient runner in the league. If he gives you 12 games, those 12 games will likely win you your weekly matchups. In a 12-team league, you need "spike" weeks. You aren't looking for "safe" 10-point games from a veteran like Terry McLaurin. You want the 30-point explosion.
Also, stop drafting "safe" backups.
Your bench shouldn't be a retirement home for boring veterans. It should be a laboratory for high-upside rookies and elite handcuffs. If you’re not drafting Ray Davis or Braelon Allen, you’re doing it wrong. These guys are one injury away from being top-10 weekly options.
Actionable Draft Day Steps
- Prioritize the "Elite Three" TEs or Wait: If you don't get Brock Bowers, Trey McBride, or George Kittle, just wait. The value of Sam LaPorta or Mark Andrews at their current ADP isn't worth the opportunity cost of a high-end WR.
- Anchor with one "Hero" RB: Get a guy like Bijan or Gibbs in the first two rounds. It allows you to ignore the RB position while your league mates scramble for scraps in Round 6.
- Target Year 2 WRs: The jump from Year 1 to Year 2 is historically the biggest for wideouts. Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas Jr. are the obvious ones, but keep an eye on Ricky Pearsall if his role expands in San Francisco.
- Monitor the "Lawrence Leap": Trevor Lawrence is the best value at QB right now. If you can pair him with a high-upside stack, do it.
Mock drafting is about finding where the "cliff" is at each position. In 2025, that cliff is steep at RB and TE. Map out your first four picks to ensure you aren't left staring at a roster of "guys who are okay" while your opponent has three legitimate superstars.